Attorney: Closed city meetings violated law

City closed meetings timeline
MARYVILLE, Mo. — City records show a pattern of closed meetings held by the Maryville City Council to discuss a wide range of topics out of the public eye, in potential violation of law, and that the council frequently approves seemingly erroneous closed meeting records which include votes from absent council members.
The issues come against the backdrop of increased public frustration over the council’s tight-lipped responses to residents concerned about a data center project.
In June, the city defended a May 11 closed meeting in which the minutes indicated the council discussed water capacity and general data center water usage. A statement from City Manager Ryan Heiland at the time said that a “legal review” determined the meeting had been closed in accordance with state law, and directed all further inquiries to the city’s general counsel, Taryn Henry.
Since then, a broader Forum analysis of meeting documents found a sharp uptick in closed meetings overall — the council held more closed meetings last year, 33, than in the two prior years combined — and highlighted about a dozen closed meetings since January 2025 with seemingly questionable legal bases for closure.
Dan Curry, an attorney for the Missouri Press Association, reviewed the meeting minutes.
“The vast majority of these meetings should not have been closed,” Curry said in an email to The Forum. “… Take that data center conversation. If there’s not a lawsuit on file, that is the kind of important conversation that the public has a right to know about. The personnel exception cannot be used to discuss positions generally — and that appears to be happening as well.
“Finally, closed sessions are limited to only the topics that have been properly closed pursuant to a specific Sunshine Law exception. Many of these minutes on their face document discussion that would not fit under any Sunshine Law exception.”
In an email Wednesday, Henry said the city wanted more time to look into the closed meetings, but did not address any of The Forum’s questions about the process of how the city closes meetings.
“The City of Maryville maintains a longstanding commitment to transparency and takes any questions regarding our public processes very seriously,” Henry said in the email.
SUNSHINE LAW
Missouri’s Sunshine Law, its open records and meetings law, requires that all meetings of government bodies be open to the public except in specific circumstances that are laid out in statute.
According to meeting minutes approved by the council, many of the city’s closed meetings featured discussions that appear to have a questionable relationship to the statutory reason for closure.
For example, several meetings were closed under the exception for the “hiring, firing, disciplining or promoting of particular employees by a public governmental body when personal information about the employee is discussed or recorded.” But some of those meetings do not appear to have included any discussion of a particular employee or any employee at all. Instead, the city appears to have used the exemption to discuss descriptions of open positions, like assistant city manager or finance director, even when the positions were vacant and no specific candidates were under consideration.
Others seemed to have an even more tenuous connection.
On Feb. 10, 2025, the council discussed a request from the St. Francis Foundation to provide a $10,000 contribution at its annual fundraising gala for a women’s health clinic. The council had provided a similar contribution a year earlier.
In closed session, the council discussed the proposal and voted to contribute. The session was closed to the public under the exception for “legal actions, causes of action or litigation involving a public governmental body and any confidential or privileged communications between a public governmental body or its representatives and its attorneys.”
That particular exception has been used by the council to close meetings on an array of topics.
On April 14, 2025, the council used the legal actions exception to close a meeting in which “Interim City Manager Ryan Heiland presented updates to the manufactured homes code amendment. The Council discussed the proposed changes and outlined next steps, including holding a public hearing and scheduling a Planning and Zoning Commission meeting for consideration.”
The council had approved a four-month moratorium on factory-built homes in January 2025 after hearing from dissatisfied neighbors of a new manufactured home. The new ordinance would eventually be passed on May 12, 2025, without any public discussion by the council.
On April 28, 2025, the council again used the legal actions exception to close discussion about a proposed code amendment concerning drive-thru liquor and marijuana regulations. According to meeting minutes, Heiland “explained that Constitutional Amendment #2 requires municipalities to accommodate marijuana-related provisions,” and the council discussed interest expressed by a business that wanted to offer drive-thru liquor. “Council engaged in discussion regarding both amendments and their potential implications,” the minutes stated. The code amendment would also be approved on May 12, 2025, with little public discussion by the council.
After that May 12 meeting, minutes show that the council yet again held an executive session to discuss legal actions, this time so the council could talk about the possibility of adding a second school resource officer to the Maryville R-II School District. The school board discussed and approved the addition in open session.
And, a year later, it was the legal actions exception that the council used to hold a closed-door meeting to learn more about the White Cloud Acres data center project.
DATA CENTER
There is scarcely a public official in Nodaway County who hasn’t felt increased pressure and scrutiny since The Forum ran a story in April about the proposed White Cloud Acres data center project. The City Council has been no different.
The data center project, though, is centered about eight miles south of Maryville — well outside city limits. So the City Council has not been directly involved, a fact often repeated by City Council members and City Manager Heiland since even before the April story in The Forum.
But that didn’t stop members of the public from packing the first council meeting following The Forum’s story to voice their frustrations and ask for the council’s help in stopping the project. City officials reiterated at the meeting that the city would only be involved with possibly providing water for the facility, but said they had few details.
On May 11, the council apparently tried to rectify that, calling in Josh McKim, head of Nodaway County Economic Development, which has helped to facilitate the project’s location in Nodaway County. According to meeting minutes, the council met with McKim to talk generally about water usage by data centers. The meeting was closed under the exception for legal actions.
The original meeting minutes, unanimously approved by the council, said that McKim “shared information about the project based on his understanding and personal experience, including visits to similar data center facilities” and “discussed the potential economic impact and operational aspects of such developments.”
In a phone conversation later, Heiland told The Forum that the meeting met the statutory requirements for closure because the discussions involved the city’s contract with Public Water Supply District No. 1. The city provides water to PWSD No. 1, which would likely provide water to the data center project. In a later public meeting, Heiland said that the contract allows PWSD No. 1 to draw up to a million gallons of water per day from the city, though it only draws about 600,000 — perhaps giving a window into how the contract related to the May 11 data center discussion.
Curry, the press association attorney, told The Forum that at least the threat of litigation must be present to close a meeting.
“The legal proceedings exception is applicable when there is real or threatened litigation,” Curry said in an email after reviewing the meeting minutes.
When Heiland was pressed for more information on how the May 11 discussion actually met the standard for closure — and how the rest of the apparently broad discussion with McKim did the same — he refused to answer any more questions on the record and sent a statement to The Forum that referred all future questions to Henry, the city’s general counsel.
The statement said that Henry and the Missouri Municipal League had conducted a “legal review” and found that the May 11 closed meeting had been conducted in compliance with the law. The statement from Heiland also seemed to indicate that the city’s legal counsel determines when a topic can be discussed in closed session.
“Policy discussions for city business are conducted in open session unless legal counsel determines that a specific statutory basis exists for a closed session under Missouri law,” Heiland said in the email.
Henry did not answer questions from The Forum about how the legal review was conducted, how the city decides to close meetings and if council members receive any guidance on the limits of discussion while in closed session.
No council member responded to emails from The Forum with similar inquiries, and over the course of a month, Mayor John McBride did not respond to several sent to him, Henry and Heiland.
‘THEY JUST SIT THERE AND STARE AT YOU’
The transparency issues come at a time when the council is already under fire for a perceived lack of transparency and engagement with the public over the data center.
During a June 29 council meeting, residents from both outside and inside city limits spoke for more than an hour in the public comment period and became increasingly frustrated that council members were not willing to answer questions.
One of the only times a city official did directly respond was when Mayor McBride told Maryville resident Shanda Keirsey that the city did not yet know anything about what an agreement might eventually look like with the data center. Council member Erin Allen reminded McBride that the public comment period was not meant as a back-and-forth.
“I just wondered if you could answer,” Keirsey said. “So you don’t think you can at this point?”
It was Henry, the attorney, who responded directly to Keirsey.
“No,” Henry said. “And we appreciate your comments, but we’ll take that down and evaluate that.”
The council’s reluctance to engage is a topic that has not been limited to City Council meetings.
During a county commission meeting the next day, multiple residents independently referenced the city’s unwillingness to talk with constituents and Henry’s unusual presence at the June 29 meeting, which she attended.
“They just sit there and stare at you,” Scott Wilson, a backup water operator in Bolckow, said about the City Council during the June 30 commission meeting. “They won’t answer a question. They act like they’re all lawyered up.”
Holly Caviness, a Burlington Junction resident who spoke during the council meeting, said at the commission meeting that “the City Council won’t answer any of our questions.”
“Yeah, I gotta commend you people,” added Mike Wilson, Bolckow city clerk, speaking to the commission. “At least you talk to us. I mean those people, it’s like, ‘No, we can’t answer any questions,’ and then the lawyer sits there and says ‘Yeah.’”
Jennifer Gillespie, a Nodaway County resident who owns a business in Maryville, was one of the speakers during the City Council’s public comment period on June 29. Increasingly frustrated as she spoke, she’d become incredulous when the council members observed her silently without responding.
“I guess people are just trying to figure out what the next steps are, and … everywhere we go, no one will talk to us,” she said during the June 29 council meeting. “So how are we supposed to have any questions (answered) when you guys won’t even look at us? I don’t even understand, I don’t understand what’s happening. As I told the rural water board, all you guys live here, and everywhere we go, you guys are acting like you guys don’t live here with us.”
The next day, she walked into the commission meeting after the other complaints about the City Council, but nonetheless brought up the same issue, saying that council members appeared to have “no emotion” and were “stone-faced.” Conversely, she thanked the county commissioners for engaging even though they didn’t necessarily have answers.
“Thank you for not having an attorney sitting here and staring us down,” she added.
CHANGING THE RECORD
After The Forum’s initial inquiries, Henry, who rarely attends City Council meetings, sat next to Heiland for the entirety of the subsequent council meeting, which was packed with attendees looking for answers about the data center. Specifically, they wanted answers about water usage — the kind of questions the council appeared to have been asking during the May 11 closed meeting with McKim.
But the council’s first order of business during that June 29 meeting was to amend the minutes of the meeting they’d had with McKim. The new minutes erased the previous description of the May 11 discussion and replaced it with one that said the “closed session was convened to discuss matters related to the existing water service agreement” between the city and PWSD No. 1, and noted that the council discussed “legal considerations and operational matters pertaining to the City’s water system and potential future negotiations and/or litigation with PWSD No. 1 regarding water service and related contractual arrangements.”
After the June 29 open session, McBride initially declined to talk about the May 11 closed session.
“I can’t really talk about that,” he told The Forum.
But when pressed, he seemed to confirm the general nature of the meeting’s discussion, saying that it was a “much more encompassing meeting.”
“The main focus of it was more the water and the things, you know, which I’m still hopeful we get actual numbers,” McBride told The Forum at the time. “Because it seems everything changes.”
At that point, city staff interrupted to direct The Forum to Henry. She had already left the building.
The new meeting minutes also showed one more change.
Originally, four council members had been recorded as present at the meeting and were noted as having voted. That version of the minutes had been approved by all five council members.
The new version showed that actually, only three members were present during the closed meeting.
ERRONEOUS RECORDS
The Forum compared closed meeting minutes for every closed council meeting since January 2025 against the minutes for the corresponding open sessions held immediately prior to the closed meetings. More than one in five meeting minutes documents appear to list at least one person who was not actually present, including some votes from absent council members. That includes the minutes for the May 11 meeting held to discuss water and data centers that had originally shown council member Benjamin Lipiec as present and having voted.
All meeting minutes are voted on by the council to attest to their accuracy.
In addition to absent council members, minutes for closed sessions on Sept. 8 and 9 of last year listed former council member Tye Parsons as present. Parsons resigned from the council in July of that year.
The April 14, 2025, meeting — closed to discuss the manufactured homes code — listed “City Manager Greg McDanel” as present, even though his last day with the city was March 7 of that year.
And while the council did correct the meeting held with McKim on May 11 to show Lipiec as absent instead of present and voting, two other closed meetings held immediately before and afterward show the same mistake. The council corrected only the minutes for the meeting The Forum specifically asked about in June.
At the end of the June 29 open session, council member Allen seemed to reference the change in minutes when she asked City Clerk Stacy Wood to begin providing meeting minutes to the council for approval at each following meeting instead of sometimes nearly two months after the meetings were held.
Heiland said the city’s system at the time was standard for many cities, and added that it also allows more time for the city clerk to prepare the minutes.
“I understand,” Allen responded at the time, “I’m just saying I’d like us to consider moving to that in the interest of us accurately approving them when they come before us and having to think back or review our notes from just the previous meeting versus potentially five weeks ago.
“I just think that would go a long way to promote us being accurate with the city’s records.”
At the most recent City Council meeting on July 13, the council unanimously approved meeting minutes from June, including a closed session held on June 8. The minutes included no description at all of what was discussed in the executive session, only the vote to enter and exit the closed session along with the statutory citation justifying the closure.
The meeting was closed under the legal matters exception.

GEOFFREY WOEHLK/THE FORUM
Maryville City Manager Ryan Heiland, left, told The Forum in June that the city’s general counsel, Taryn Henry, right, took part in a legal review of a closed City Council meeting held on May 11. The review found that the meeting was held in accordance with state law, a statement from Heiland said. Neither Heiland nor Henry has elaborated on the legal review process or the city’s process for closing portions of meetings.

GEOFFREY WOEHLK/THE FORUM
Taryn Henry, the city’s general counsel, attended the June 29 Maryville City Council meeting, during which many residents shared concerns about the White Cloud Acres data center project. Later, some of those residents said they saw Henry’s presence as a sign the council was not interested in engaging with the public.

GEOFFREY WOEHLK/THE FORUM
Maryville Mayor John McBride has not responded to a series of email inquiries over the past month concerning closed meetings held by the City Council. “I can’t really talk about that,” McBride told The Forum about a closed session held on May 11 concerning the city’s water capacity and general data center water usage.

City erroneous records timeline

GEOFFREY WOEHLK/THE FORUM
Maryville City Manager Ryan Heiland, pictured during the June 29 City Council meeting, has not responded to any inquiries by The Forum about the city’s closed meeting practices since he directed all questions about a May 11 closed meeting to the city’s general counsel on June 15. After the June 29 council meeting, Heiland attempted to cut off Mayor John McBride from speaking with The Forum about the May 11 meeting.
