Skip to content

City defends closed-door meeting on data center

FORUM FILE PHOTO
Maryville Mayor John McBride did not respond to multiple emails from The Forum about a closed meeting held by the City Council on May 11 that involved discussions about the data center.

MARYVILLE, Mo. — The Maryville City Council last month held a private, wide-ranging discussion about the White Cloud Acres data center project behind closed doors, potentially in violation of state law.

According to meeting minutes approved during last week’s regular council session, the council and some city staff met with Josh McKim, executive director of Nodaway County Economic Development, during a closed session following the council’s regular meeting on May 11. The minutes state that McKim “shared information about the project based on his understanding and personal experience, including visits to similar data center facilities,” “discussed the potential economic impact and operational aspects of such developments” and told the council that Scale Microgrids, the data center project developer, was planning to hold a public open house on June 3.

The meeting was closed under the provision of Missouri’s Sunshine Law pertaining to legal actions or litigation involving the city.

City Manager Ryan Heiland told The Forum that the May 11 meeting was closed because it was related to a water use contract and the data center’s potential use of Maryville’s water or wastewater.

However, this appears to be a questionable interpretation of Missouri’s open meetings law.

Dan Curry, an attorney for the Missouri Press Association, said that under the provision cited by the city, public meetings may only be closed if the meeting pertains to specific litigation, either in progress or threatened.

Additionally, the general and varied nature of the topics discussed during the meeting, which Heiland confirmed, appear to go far beyond talk related to a contract.

After inquiries from The Forum, Heiland said in an email on Monday that the city had reviewed the closure of the May 11 meeting with city attorney Taryn Henry and counsel from the Missouri Municipal League. The review found that the closed session was conducted in compliance with the law, Heiland said.

“To provide additional clarity in the public record, the City Council may consider amending the meeting minutes at a future meeting,” Heiland added in the email.

Heiland directed all future questions about the topic to Henry.

In an email on Wednesday, Henry said the statute allows the closure of meetings related to potential litigation, but did not elaborate on how the May 11 meeting fell into that category. She did not respond to follow-up questions by press time.

The data center has been a sensitive issue for local officials as they have struggled to gather information about the project while facing increasing, significant pressure from residents strongly opposed to the development. Many of those residents have expressed mounting frustration that they feel left out of information-gathering and decision-making processes having to do with the data center. At the time of the closed meeting, information and context about the data center’s operations — topics discussed by the council during the closed meeting — were particularly scarce.

Scale Microgrids has made the use of Maryville’s wastewater to cool the data center’s equipment a linchpin of its plan, touting that the closed-loop cooling system would negate the need for using potable water for that portion of the center’s operations.

The council, though, has offered little in the way of public comment on the project: The council has never placed any item related to the data center on a public agenda, and, other than occasionally responding to residents’ questions during open comment periods, has not discussed the project during any open meeting. The only discussion the council appears to have had about the project is during the May 11 closed meeting.

According to the minutes, the motion to close the meeting passed unanimously. Council member Bryan Williams was absent with all others present.

No council member responded to emails from The Forum about this story.

GEOFFREY WOEHLK/THE FORUM
Members of the Nodaway Says No organization, which opposes the White Cloud Acres data center project, attended the June 8 Maryville City Council meeting. Outside of occasional responses during public comment periods, the council has not discussed the project in open session.

Leave a Comment