Letter to the Editor: Local letter writer responds to columnist look at Trump
Dear Editor,
I was happy to see Larry Anderson’s column of October 10, 2024. We share much. We are both retired English teachers with a belief in the power of the press and the opportunity a free press gives us to carry out political dialogue from widely different viewpoints in print
Anderson has focused his argument on three specific points; not surprisingly these points are standard Republican issues: immigration, the economy, and a dismissal of anything else as “anti-Trump indignation in the liberal vein.” I’ll address them in order.
Immigration: Anderson says “literally millions” of illegal immigrants have been admitted into the country. I will accept “millions” as a basis for argument even though different sources cite vastly different numbers.
Having conceded the point, I will write of “undocumented immigrants,” “refugees,” or simply “people” for “illegal immigrants.”
Anderson says that these people are “irrefutably” living at taxpayer expense.
No. In fact, more than 50 percent of undocumented immigrants have taxes deducted from their paychecks. These undocumented persons are paying billions of dollars in taxes each year (American Immigration Council). For example, Montana home to only 4,000 undocumented immigrants, collected $2.2 million in sales taxes, income taxes, and property taxes from them in one year.
The same population, because it is undocumented, avoids attempting to use welfare or Medicaid. Consequently, they are less a drain than the U.S. population.
While citing criminality of undocumented immigrants is useful in creating fear and panic, the facts say otherwise. “Of the 1.5 million undocumented persons, about 16,000 were of people with previous criminal convictions (0.010 percent) over 2/3 of those convictions for attempting to cross illegally” (BBC).
The fear that undocumented immigrants commit crimes once in the U.S. is fearmongering. The reality is that the crime rate for undocumented immigrants is 450 crimes per 100,000, for US born citizens it is 1300 crimes per 100,000, for legal immigrants 800 crimes per 100,000 (National Institute of Justice).
The bill that Trump instructed his minions to vote against was a Bipartisan Bill, sponsored by Senator James Lankford, conservative Republican from Oklahoma.
That “Illegal Immigrants” are being imported to vote Democratic is not only a lie, it shows a fundamentally misunderstanding of civics. In order to vote in the November 5, 2024 election, you have to be registered. To register, you must show ID, normally a driver’s license which you will need to show again when you go to vote.
To get a driver’s license, you must (in addition to other items) produce a birth certificate showing your date of birth and where you were born. If you were born out of the U.S. (as my father was), you will have to provide naturalization papers or your parent’s proof of citizenship (as Ted Cruz did). Fraud at the polls is not caused by non-citizens voting.
The Economy. I am not an Economist. I see prices for food going up. Things cost more. Will Tariffs solve this? Providing an extension of the Billionaire tax cut will make it worse.
Ninety-eight percent of economists say tariffs will make things cost more. CEO Budget & Economic Outlook forecasts extending the Trump tax cut will add 13,683 billion dollars to the deficit by 2027.
Harris puts forth a plan which Republicans question the cost and the national debt, but they neglect to compare the effect of Trump’s plan costs. The nonpartisan Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget published an analysis (October 7, 2024) of Harris and Trump’s economic plans.
Harris’ plan is estimated to increase the national debt over 10 years by $3.5 trillion. Even with $4 trillion in higher taxes on corporation and the wealthy.
Trump’s plan is estimated to increase the national debt by $7.5 trillion over 10 years. Even with $2.7 trillion income in tariffs.
Trump’s plan costs $4 trillion more.
Where is he going to find the money? See Project 2025. By cutting services we use: Obamacare, mental and health and disability services, education, FEMA, and (whisper) social security.
Dismissal: Anderson’s cavalier dismissal of the other objections to Trump I raised disturbs me. These issues are important to each of us and the future of our country. Consider your answer to:
Which candidate has shown maturity in making policy?
Which candidate is capable of focus in a stressful situation?
Which candidate keeps their cool (temper) better?
Who seeks to unite people? Who seeks to divide?
Can you name the candidate’s policy position on issues important to you?
Which candidate consistently supports reproductive health?
Which candidate supports our military?
Have you ever seen the candidate laugh with enjoyment?
Which candidate lies and whose lies hurt people?
The Carolinas are reeling from Hurricane Milton. Trump continues about the lack of federal response to the people of the Carolinas. A friend working in North Carolina today told me of an out-of-state relative desperate to get help to his brother. The brother would not accept the help he desperately needs because the “government will take his house.” Trump cares so little about suffering people that he lies without a thought, causing people to refuse help because they believe him.
Finally, which candidate can you trust to supports the U.S. Constitution?
Anderson says Trump is no pretender. But he sells Trump short. Trump is The Great Pretender. He pretended to be a successful businessman on reality TV. The reality was he went bankrupt running a casino (I would have thought that was impossible). He pretended to be a Republican. He is first, last and always, a MeFirster. He pretended to be a President. The reality is that Mexico didn’t pay for the wall and Russia invaded Ukraine. He LOST the 2020 election. And behaved (and still behaves) like a 5-year old deprived of his favorite toy.
The U.S. presidency and the Constitution are not a toy. America was unique and the envy of the world until January 6, 2021. From our country’s founding, we witnessed the peaceful transfer of power.
The losing candidate had the right to (and did) legally challenge the results of the election. But they did not try to coerce election officials to “find” votes (Raffensberger in Georgia), they did not try to get state legislatures to intervene (Rusty Bowers in Arizona and others), they did not try to turn the ceremonial counting of Electoral Ballots into a sham, a farce, and a riot as Donald Trump and his friends did on January 6, 2021.
Anderson uses the word “socialism.” The opposite of socialism is “fascism.” And between those two poles lies “democracy.” It is a delicate balance. Too far one way, and we face the mommy state. Too far the other way, and we face the holocaust. Democracy is the middle. It exists because people believe in it. It exists because people (and parties) can compromise. It exists because we do not overthrow the results of an election by stealth or by force. Trump is the true Republican In Name Only. He doesn’t care about fiscal conservatism or individual freedoms. He cares about power. Oh, and staying out of jail.
Karen Fulton
Maryville
