Skip to content

Letter to the Editor: Understanding Missouri’s new A-F school report cards

 

EDITOR’S NOTE: The following is an open letter from the superintendents in Nodaway County to the community. It is signed by South Nodaway’s Dustin Skoglund, Maryville’s Philip Pohren, Jefferson’s Dallas Giedd, Nodaway-Holt’s Mike Hollingsworth, North Nodaway’s Chris Turpin, Northeast Nodaway’s Chaim Jenkins and West Nodaway’s Mitch Barnes. The Maryville Forum has run the letter in its entirity with light edits for clarity.   

 

To our Nodaway County families and communities,

Beginning in 2026, Missouri is introducing a new A-F school report card system assigning individual schools and districts an overall letter grade from A to F.

As public school superintendents across Nodaway County, we welcome true, transparent accountability. However, we believe our families deserve a complete picture of how this new rating system works, where its state-level formula falls short, and how our districts remain steadfastly committed to moving every child forward.

Following Governor Mike Kehoe’s Executive Order 26-01 in January 2026, the Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE) developed an A-F grading framework, which received State Board of Education approval in September 2026.

WHAT IS THE SCHOOL REPORT CARD SYSTEM?

In January, Gov. Mike Kehoe issued an executive order to implement an A-F report card system for all public school districts in the state by Sept. 30. Though the Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education was not legally obligated to follow the order, the State Board of Education opted to do so. However, the tight timeline was pushed back just before the deadline over significant concerns raised by school administrators that the grading framework isn’t consistent, won’t accurately represent district performance and could be confusing alongside other performance measures that already exist. Private schools are not required to take part in the system but can opt in.

The state’s rating formula relies on a points system (84 total points for K-8 schools and 96 points for high schools):

  • A: 89% and above
  • B: 76% – 88%
  • C: 63% – 75%
  • D: 50% – 62%
  • F: Below 50%

This calculation relies almost entirely on standardized test results — specifically MAP achievement, standardized growth measures, and a new growth-to-proficiency metric. At the high school level, four-year graduation rates and college/career readiness measures are also factored in.

Initial grade cards reflect baseline data from the 2024-2025 school year — information that is nearly two years old and excludes new literacy and Lexile metrics for grades first through eighth. School districts are currently reviewing draft scores, with formal, fully integrated grade cards not expected until September 2027.

While standardized test scores offer one dataset, a single letter assigned by a state algorithm contains structural flaws that obscure the true health and quality of our schools:

A-F grades vs. APR accreditation: This new rating system adds to our existing evaluations; it does not replace them. Missouri’s Annual Performance Report (APR) under MSIP 6 remains the official system for district accreditation. Because of structural differences in how the two metrics are calculated, a fully accredited district with top performance marks on its APR could still receive a “D” grade under the state’s A-F formula.

  • Shifting goalposts: The executive order calls for the state grading scale to become more difficult over time. If 65% of Missouri schools earn an A or a B, the cut score needed to earn each grade will automatically increase by 5 percentage points the following year. As a result, a school could improve its academic performance yet receive a lower letter grade simply because the state shifted the scale.
  • Lack of student demographic adjustments: The letter scale fails to adjust for special education programs, socioeconomic factors (free and reduced-price lunch rates), or English language learners. Because students enter school from different baseline points, measuring individual growth over time remains the true reflection of classroom progress.
  • Unfunded state mandates: Real accountability requires real support. While local schools are held to strict state algorithms, the state currently underfunds its own statutory education foundation formula, offering no new resources alongside this mandate.

Standardized test scores provide only a narrow snapshot in time. Public schools serve every child who walks through our doors regardless of their background or starting point. That mission is fundamental to who we are, and it cannot be reduced to an algorithm.

A letter grade can never capture:

  • The kindergartner who masters letter recognition for the very first time.
  • The middle school student who discovers a lifelong passion in fine arts, athletics, or student organizations.
  • The high school senior who becomes the first in their family to earn a diploma and move on to college, trade school, or the workforce.
  • The dedication of teachers who build safe, supportive classrooms and refuse to give up on a struggling student.

Our primary accountability is to you — our local families, taxpayers, and communities — not to a math formula in Jefferson City.

We encourage parents and community members to look behind the letter grade when state scores are released. The underlying data highlights where our schools excel in growth and pinpoints exact areas targeted for continuous improvement.

No state rating can replace the everyday educational experience dedicated to the personal progress of your child. We thank you for your continued partnership as we work together to build a strong, bright future for all Nodaway County students.

 

Sincerely,

The superintendents of Nodaway County:

 

Dustin Skoglund

South Nodaway R-IV

 

Philip Pohren

Maryville R-II

 

Dallas Giedd

Jefferson C-123

 

Mike Hollingsworth

Nodaway-Holt R-VII

 

Chris Turpin

North Nodaway R-VI

 

Chaim Jenkins

Northeast Nodaway R-V

 

Mitch Barnes

West Nodaway R-I

Leave a Comment