Leeter to the Editor: White Cloud Acres and White Cloud Ordinance
I attended the “informational” meeting sponsored by the Nodaway Says No Group in Graham a few weeks ago. Informed decisions are a good thing. I expressed my concerns and asked questions about unintended consequences of the restrictive ordinance White Cloud Township was heralding. After only a couple minutes I was told “we don’t want anyone to dominate the meeting.” I found out afterwards a White Cloud township resident was told the same thing after a couple of minutes when expressing legitimate concerns about the property rights being stripped from the homeowners, landowners and residents within the township. However, one county resident was allowed to bloviate for what seemed like 10 minutes on the virtues of how easy and “simple” county zoning would be and at the end tried to goad a current commissioner in attendance into a verbal discourse. He didn’t take the bait. Pretty much the low point of the evening. Anyone that thinks about that for more than 10 seconds can conclude it is neither simple nor easy to have countywide zoning.
The No group originally had some legitimate questions and concerns about White Cloud Acres Data Center, as we all did. The commissioners asked the health department about health risks. Health department Director Tom Patterson did a comprehensive look into that and presented the findings at one of the commissioners’ meetings. His unbiased findings challenged the rumors that have been spread on sound, distance and effects on livestock. Only a couple of people besides the Maryville Forum asked for copies. Extensive studies have been conducted on sound and livestock by universities in Wisconsin and other states. One of the major concerns cited by the No group is stillborn births of calves. As a farmer, I would very much agree with this, but a simple search comes back with there are “no independent veterinary records, laboratory tests or peer-reviewed scientific studies linking data center noise or data center EMFs” to such effects.
Louden County, Virginia, has been mentioned many times. They have 233 data centers operational and will have 250 soon. Doing a search on health-related lawsuits, it might surprise you to know there were zero directly health-related lawsuits in the 30 years since the first one was built. The obvious conclusion is that it is a non-issue.
The economic reality is that several major employers in Maryville no longer exist — Eveready, NEBS and others. If other industries leave, and past statistics show it’s a possibility, what does that do to the tax base? How high will taxes have to be for basic services without the data center — 10, 12, 15% more? In Maryville the current tax rate is already 9.1%. Blake Hurst, former Missouri Farm Bureau president from Tarkio, had an informative op ed article this past August in the Wall Street Journal for those interested. He points out, among other things, that in just the last 15 years, Nodaway County has lost about 14% of its population. Less folks to cover the basic service needs.
Here are my objections with the White Cloud ordinance. First, there is no written ordinance to vote on. Just “hope” that it works out. Their words, not mine, and for whom? Just vote yes and trust what we put in it. That practice didn’t and doesn’t work very well at the federal and state level. Do you really think it will at a local level? Having a central committee of five appointed township residents coming up with business regulations? Why rush it? We vote on actual wording of statutes all the time. Ask yourself: Why not this time?
Second, by having “informational” meetings outside of White Cloud Township, the No group appears to want this type of ordinance countywide, which I am very much opposed to and the reason for my not staying silent. They are endorsing a candidate to push this business-restrictive ordinance to the county level to be the presiding commissioner. There are almost 2,000 businesses in the county, about 500 of which employ people, and the other 1,500 are sole proprietorships. Does anyone really think that is a workable course of action? His social media last summer is in favor of Andrew County supplying the water for the data center generators. Since I have heard almost everyone say White Cloud Acres is going to happen, how about we keep more revenue for Nodaway County?
Finally, do we want a couple handful of activists to dictate and regulate how the 21,000+ county residents are to think and act? For the stability of the county my vote is for CHRIS BURNS.
I admit I used Google Assistant and an evil data center for some of the facts above. It took about 10 seconds. This is important for the future of the county. Please spend a few seconds and do your own research. Don’t take mine or anyone else’s word for it for any of it.
Please vote Tuesday, Nov. 3.
Mike Rosenbohm, Graham
EDITOR’S NOTE: Mike Rosenbohm is a member of the Maryville Forum’s Editorial Board, which advises on topics for editorials that appear on the Opinion page.
