Letter to the Editor: Propane versus electric buses
Worth County R-II School District was recently awarded federal transportation funds totaling $1,725,000. The EPA Clean School Bus Program intends to help districts replace diesel buses with cleaner units. However, the intention fails to achieve results. Perhaps the EPA should go back to school.
Math Class: $1.725 million will purchase only five electric buses. The EPA intentionally skews decisions by awarding huge sums to districts that opt for electric buses. Yet the higher grant award limits the number of buses a district can actually afford to operate.
For the same $1.725 million, Worth County School District could have acquired 57 propane buses, producing 11 times as many new, safe and efficient buses that could transport more students in our state.
Science Class: It’s also true that the propane units would run cleaner. Propane is a hydrogen-rich, ultra-low carbon fuel. Missouri’s electric grid is powered primarily with coal.
Comparing the carbon intensity of propane versus Missouri’s electric grid is shocking: Propane is almost three times less carbon intensive, scoring 79 g/MJ to the grid’s 238 g/MJ.
Economics Class: It takes nearly four times the energy to generate one unit of battery power due to losses in production, transmission and storage. This makes electricity both inefficient and expensive. Propane buses boast the lowest total cost of ownership of any school bus option.
Steve Ahrens
Jefferson City, Missouri
Steve Ahrens is the chief strategy officer of the Missouri Propane Education & Research Council, a not-for-profit organization based in Jefferson City.
