Skip to content

No on Prop A

I would like to offer some fact to counteract the letter of July 23 from Joe Cornelison, who tries to encourage voters in Missouri to cast a misguided yes vote on Proposition A on August 7.

First, the name “right to work” is a lie. People in every part of the United States already have the right to work, as guaranteed by the Taft-Hartley Act of 1947. It forbids forcing people to join unions, just as it forbids preventing people to join unions. It would be silly to cast a vote for a right we already have.

The fact is, people in right to work states like Kansas suffer under the law. Case in point, highway construction workers. The U.S. Department of Labor reports in Nodaway County, a construction laborer working on a state, county or federal highway project will earn a minimum of $26.16 an hour, plus $14.47 in fringe benefits. That wage is paid to any construction laborer – union or non-union.

In Doniphan County, Kansas, the same laborer doing the same work is paid $12.26 an hour with no fringe benefits. Any insurance or pension that worker wants will have to be paid out of that low wage, in addition to their housing, food, transportation and other costs of living.

How is that better? Why would we want that for Missouri? Who benefits? Since Mr. Cornelison stoops to name calling with the pejorative term “union bosses” (whatever that is), we can say that the people who benefit are the corporate “fat cats” and “greedy CEOs.”

Seriously, who’s in a better position to contribute to a community, the person earning $26 an hour, or the person earning $12 hour? Who’s spending more, helping to support their local economy? Who’s generating more income tax revenue for their state, helping to pay for important state services like road construction and maintenance? Who’s in a better position to buy a home and pay property taxes to support their local school district?

Construction laborers in Iowa also earn lower wages and benefits than in Missouri.

Why should we settle for less? Why would Mr. Cornelison or anyone else want anyone in Missouri to work more for less?

The fact is, people voluntarily join unions to get better pay and benefits. Contractors voluntarily hire union workers to get the best-trained, safest and most skilled workers in their craft. Don’t want to join a union, join the 90 percent of the working people in Missouri who don’t. But don’t punish the people who do, and who help raise the pay scale for everyone in the state.

Vote NO on Proposition A.

–– Scott Howell

Laborers Local 663

St. Joseph

Leave a Comment