Skip to content

Spike Speaks: Combating the ‘fake news’ tag

Jon Dykstra

Hardly anything gets me angrier than hearing the term ‘fake news’ thrown around haphazardly, especially when the term is used to describe stories and news broken by journalists who have clearly done their homework.

No journalist ever wants to have that annoying ‘fake news’ tag applied to them, but there is seemingly nothing that responsible writers can do to avoid it. At some point it gets posted to a piece for every journalist, regardless of if there is an actual inaccuracy, but more because the people posting the comment don’t want it to be true.

This column certainly isn’t going down a political road and I don’t really care who started this recent trend of using that phrase, it is really unfortunate that that phrase is now in the mainstream. I could write far too many words on that phrase, but this is not about that, it is about what quality journalists can do to battle against that phrase being relevant.

While in this age of social media, it is impossible to completely avoid the term, part of the rise in the ‘Fake News’ movement comes from the use of editorial and opinion journalism which used to be rooted in previously reported hard, confirmed news. Nowadays, outlets have become more relaxed on how they incorporate opinion into their news coverage. Disclaimer: this is an opinion piece, but I will strive to never include any opinions here that damage someone else’s reputation and that I can not prove as completely accurate.

In television, opinion coverage is often seen through the use of panels which normally include the extremes of the argument on each side, simply because people love to hate-watch.

This reliance on opinions to drive people’s eyes to a product has extended past television and into print media recently.

As a sports writer, I am rarely faced with anything that could even resemble fake news. When writing a game story, stats and scores are pretty straight-forward and impossible to claim as ‘fake.’

Reporting the news around sports often can dive more into the news side of the business than the more laid-back sports side, nothing is more in this category than when coaching changes.

Breaking news under the guise of an opinion column and editorial is a trap that one of the outlets which covers Northwest Missouri State athletics fell into this week with the retirement of longtime track and field and cross-country coach Scott Lorek.

The danger in publishing single-sourced information is real and only provides further ammunition for those who wish to tear down the credibility of serious journalism.

While I normally would always side with giving the public all the information and allowing them to judge those facts for themselves, it is a dangerous precedent to unload one side of a story in any piece — whether its an opinion piece or not — just because the other side is not able to comment at the moment.

The confirmed facts around Lorek’s retirement are that he had a leave of absence from the team at the end of the season which eventually led to his retirement at the end of the season. Another fact is that Interim Director of Athletics Andy Peterson told The Forum that Lorek called a majority of the team at the end of the season to inform them of his retirement, contrary to another outlet’s claims that he had no contact with student-athletes leading up to the retirement decision.

While it is great to be the first one to report a story, my belief has always been that it is better to be accurate with your reporting rather than simply be first. That is just the way I was taught by my journalism professors at Missouri Western (Please don’t hold that against me) and my mentors in the industry.

The Forum is dedicated to providing fair and accurate coverage to our readers. Although mistakes can happen, we will not report rumors and pass them off to our readers as fact. In that way, I believe we are providing our audience with the coverage it deserves.

Leave a Comment