Column: MIAA Football Year in Review

Jon Dykstra, Managing Editor
The MIAA football season wrapped up this week with the playoff announcements where conference champion Northwest Missouri State and runner-up Washburn will be advancing. Central Missouri accepted a bid to the Heritage Bowl in Texas to play Southeastern Oklahoma State.
On Tuesday, the conference also released its All-MIAA awards and it was met with a fair amount of confusion from the those following the conference and the coaches themselves. So let’s run down the major awards and who received what and where I think they should have gone. Please understand that if I had someone else winning an award, it doesn’t mean that the actual award winner isn’t a great player or coach, I just believe that someone else’s resume was better this season.
To prove that point, let’s start with Coach of the Year where Northwest’s John McMenamin is now 2-for-2 on winning that honor. If I was starting a program today, McMenamin is the coach I’d want running it, but this season, that award should’ve went to Washburn’s Zach Watkins.
Nobody in the preseason had Washburn picked higher than eighth in the preseason and the second-year coach led the Ichabods to the playoffs. This award always goes to the conference champion, but I prefer to give it to the guy who exceeded expectations the most.
I think the conference got it right with the Offensive Lineman of the Year Kaleb McCullough of Northwest and the Defensive Player of the Year J.C. Heim of Washburn. There is an argument for Landon Boss as the Defensive Player of the Year, but I agree with Heim getting it.
The most shocking omission was Northwest running back Quincy Torry not being the Offensive Player of the Year. Not only did Torry lead the highest scoring offense in the conference, lead the league in touchdowns and lead the conference in yards per game at 103.3 yards, but he had the highest yards-per-carry by two full yards over the other running backs with 7.4 yards per carry.
Torry wasn’t even the First Team Running Back with that honor going to a great player and the best play on his offense DJ Brown of Central Missouri. But Offensive Player of the Year went to Jordan Pachot.
After Jackson Berry won the award last year and lost a quarterback battle in Hays this season, you’d think the league would have learned from just making Offensive Player of the Year a quarterback award. Torry is far and away the best skill player in this conference and the national awards will likely notice that better than whatever politics went on in the MIAA.
Defensive Lineman of the Year is tougher this season with a lot of the tackles for loss and sack statistics going to linebackers this season, but no one opened up more space for his defensive to make plays than Zylen Saddler-Robinson, the nose tackle for Northwest, which gave up 13.6 points and less than 300 yards per game. No other defense was close to those marks and that deserves to be recognized in the postseason accolades.
The final individual award was Freshman of the Year, which was won by running back AG Floyd of an underachieving Fort Hays State team. Floyd had a great season and is built like a tank, but the leading tackler on that Northwest defense that dominated the league was freshman Eli Bertz. Bertz also returned one of his two interceptions against Pittsburg State for a touchdown.
By the way, the Tigers list Floyd as a sophomore, so that just adds to this confusing list.
But the teams have no time to focus on the rights and wrongs of the All-MIAA squads. While Northwest and Washburn prepare for the playoffs, the other eight teams are in transfer-portal season. Here is the final power rankings for the year with an offseason outlook for each team:
Playoff teams
1. Northwest (9-1; 8-1 MIAA)
The Bearcats lose their starting three interior offensive linemen, their blocking tight end, a corner and linebacker. Other than that, the entire starting unit is set to return. Barring a massive transfer exodus, they will be scarier next season.
2. Washburn (8-2-1; 7-2 MIAA)
Second in the MIAA is no small feat under second-year coach Zach Watkins. The ‘Bods are set to return nine starters on offense and 10 on defense. The future is extremely bright in Topeka.
Near misses
3. Emporia State (8-3; 6-3 MIAA)
This season will haunt the Hornets for a while. After rolling into Maryville with a chance to secure a MIAA title, they lose their last three and finish two games back of Northwest and miss the playoffs after being a top-10 team. The Hornets lose the heart of their defense with linebacker Landon Boss and safeties Clem McCullough and Tyler Schultze, but the offense is set to return a lot around quarterback Jamison Sarver.
4. Central Missouri (7-4; 6-3 MIAA)
The Mules looked like a playoff squad potentially all the way until losing at Pittsburg State a couple weeks ago. The Mules had an all-senior offensive line, a fifth-year quarterback, a senior running back, and three of their top-4 receivers are seniors. Defensively, eight starters are either seniors or fifth-years.
The eligibility rules are complicated these days, but there will be a big-time changing of the guard in Warrensburg this offseason.
Time to reset
5. Pittsburg State (4-7; 4-5 MIAA)
Tom Anthony was relieved of his head coaching duties Sunday. With that comes a completely new roster more times than not. After the Anthony hiring was quick, Gorilla fans want a real national search this time. I’m guessing they try to go down the path they went for Anthony’s predecessor Brian Wright, an offensive-minded coach from the D-1 ranks.
6. Central Oklahoma (5-6; 4-5 MIAA)
The Bronchos have been in the coaching market for a while with Adam Dorrel’s mid-season dismissal. Cody Swanson finished decently, but with the money around Edmond, the thought is that they go big-game hunting which may result in a total roster reset.
7. Missouri Southern (4-7; 3-6 MIAA)
The Lions were playing like one of the top teams in the league to end the season for the first time in most people’s memories. So of course, the next most logical step is to fire one of the most well-liked coaches in the conference.
The portal is already filled with Lions. Missouri Southern will be shopping in a different aisle than Pittsburg State and Central Oklahoma in terms of resources, facilities and likely pay. It’ll be fascinating to see who takes that challenge considering that seventh in the league and beating arch-rival Pittsburg State wasn’t good enough for a Lion alum Atiba Bradley to keep his job.
The Bottom
8. Fort Hays State (4-7; 3-6 MIAA)
If AG Floyd and Major Cantrell return, the offense has some pieces despite losing their top receiver and half the offensive line. The defense is a completely new group going into next season. Chris Brown is a veteran coach with a lot of wins, but this will be a major task to replace a lot of talent from a team that still only managed four wins, but flashed against teams like Northwest and Emporia State.
9. Nebraska-Kearney (2-9; 2-7 MIAA)
The Lopers have the excuse. The preseason MIAA Offensive Player of the Year favorite Isaiah Harris missed part of the year and wasn’t himself for the rest of it. Their defense was still middle of the pack and with tailback like Harris, you can see a world where the whole team is in the middle of the MIAA.
But next season, Harris is definitely gone, so Ryan Held is going to have to find a way to score some points without him.
10. Missouri Western (3-8; 2-7 MIAA)
In 2024, the Griffons matched the team’s worst record since 1990 with just four wins. In 2025 and 2026, the team set a new mark since that 2-8 1990 campaign with back-to-back 3-8 seasons. On Monday during the Griffon Sports Insider show, Voice of the Griffons Tommy Rezac told Fenwick that if he didn’t show up to the radio show, it would tell him something, but since he was there, he assume he was still the head coach. Fenwick cut him off with “as far as I know, yes.” Later that day, Fenwick fired his defensive staff.
The offense made strides this year and the defense was far and away the worst in the MIAA. Discovering complementary football will be key next season.
With the transfer portal climate, preseason polls are impossible, but based on who is coming back and projected spending power, here is my way-to-early projected order for next season: 1. Northwest, 2. Washburn, 3. Emporia State, 4. Pittsburg State, 5. Fort Hays State, 6. Central Missouri, 7. Central Oklahoma, 8. Nebraska-Kearney, 9. Missouri Western, 10 Missouri Southern.

