Column: MSHSAA’s new system is ultimate lose-lose

Jon Dykstra Managing Editor
With my new role at the Forum, I unplugged more from MSHSAA sports and the day-to-day sports news than I would have normally over the summer. So when “MSHSAA Board Meeting Summary: June 14-16” email dropped into my inbox, I figured that I’d dive into it at some point.
The first subhead of the email was “Championship Factor Update.” Looking through the pile of numbers on the screen, again, surely this isn’t going going to severely change how the high-school postseason play works in the state of Missouri.
Well, I was wrong. And most to my surprise, the first parent complaint I heard about the new system wasn’t from one of the public schools I cover. It was from the program that is the overwhelming favorite to win a state title in Class 3 football this season thanks to MSHSAA changing the rules.
A St. Pius X football parent passed along that the players and coaches for the Warriors were extremely upset about being moved down because of the new system. St. Pius X recruits the top athletes in Kansas City.
The Warriors feature a team full of next-level talent led by 4-star University of Missouri commit Kyler Kuhn. The newly-minted No. 1 team in Class 3 — because of course they are — visited Class 6 Rockhurst, a 9-3 program last year, and beat them last Friday night.
St. Pius X has no desire to play a Class 3 team and their schedule shows it as they’ve become a football factory under the direction of Anthony Simone and his 16 assistant coaches. They don’t schedule Class 3 opponents for that reason. They are trying to compete with the Rockhursts of the state, not the Camerons.
And the public schools certainly don’t want them in Class 3. Forget the top-end talent mismatch, St. Pius X has 111 Warriors on its roster. Maryville and Macon both are roughly half of that with roster sizes in the 50s, and Cameron, Chillicothe and Richmond all have rosters in the 40s.
Classifications are designed to protect public schools from the recruiting behemoths in Kansas City and St. Louis who are playing a different game than the rest of the state.
“The other piece is to keep things fair and competitively equitable,” MSHSAA Executive Director Dr. Jennifer Rukstad said on the most recent MSHSAA All-Access Podcast. “The main tool that really our association or any state association uses to address competitive equity is classifications.”
If that is the case, then MSHSAA is failing its student-athletes.
The last year St. Pius X was in the Midland Empire Conference (2024), a league made up of Class 3 and Class 4 schools who have had a lot of state level success, the Warriors won their six conference games by a combined score of 364-29 — an average of 61-5.
So who are we helping? The kids and coaches at the private schools don’t want to be moved down and the kids and coaches are the public schools want to feel like they have a chance with the right group of youngsters who have come up through pee-wee football together and have finally got to high school.
But MSHSAA says no, because your district is going to include teams hand-picked from cities with over 2 million residents.
And the point can be made that not all private schools recruit. Our two closest private schools are St. Joseph Christian and Bishop LeBlond. Those schools aren’t recruiting football players, but they also weren’t being moved up with the previous championship factor system. This system doesn’t affect them. It does affect the football factories of Kansas City and St. Louis.
Congratulations to MSHSAA, you managed to create a system that everyone agrees on. They agree it is worse than the previous system.
