SPIKE SPIKES: Make MSHSAA Great Again

Jon Dykstra
Before coming to Maryville, I worked as the sports editor for a very similar coverage area in Iola, Kansas (congratulations on your baseball state championship Mustangs).
While the biggest difference between the two coverage areas is the opportunity to cover Northwest Missouri State versus covering a very small junior college in Iola, Allen Community College, the high school situation is extremely similar. Each has one Class 3 high school with Iola and Maryville while the Forum covers six Class 1 schools and the Iola Register covers a Class 2-sized school and four Class 1-sized schools.
The big high school difference, though, is the governing body.
While MSHSAA certainly has advantages throughout the year in nearly every sport. KSHSAA puts the different classes of their state championships in separate locations with basketball, football, wrestling, baseball and softball. This technique robs a lot of the atmosphere that Missouri produces at events like the Show-Me Bowl.
Even though most of the year I was loving how MSHSAA was handling themselves against what I’d seen with KSHSAA, but that flipped with the postseason for the spring sports.
It started in the district baseball playoffs. While Maryville played at Phil Welch Stadium and North Nodaway, West Nodaway and Platte Valley played at St. Joseph Christian, Northeast Nodaway wasn’t as fortunate with the field as they were assigned to Pattonsburg.
Pattonsburg has a pretty neat field as you drive up to it. It is in a natural bowl which makes for easy seating and it is relatively well maintained with its fences and dugouts, but the big drawback caught my attention through a coach for Green City.
I was waiting for the Bluejays’ semifinal to begin when I heard one of the Green City coaches using some harsh language with another adult in Green City gear. It was hard to avoid hearing what he was saying and I quickly understood that he was upset about the mound.
Not wanting to eavesdrop, I moved to a more secluded spot and didn’t really think much of it. I assumed it was just muddy or the wrong height or something.
Once the game started, I figured out what exactly the issue was. Pattonsburg uses an artificial mound which is closer to shag carpet than a normal pitching surface.
In the district championship game — a game featuring teams with a total of one loss — walks defined the game. Pitchers had to change into tennis shoes to pitch and complained of slipping on every pitch. The Bluejays had never pitched off an artificial mound before.
Two of the best teams in the state had what should have been an epic district final turn into a game decided in large part by walks and hit batters, because of a sub-par field.
Green City is a fantastic team and is currently in the state semifinals, so this isn’t saying that the Jays should have won the game necessarily, but an undefeated team’s season shouldn’t end on what could be considered a fluke.
MSHSAA shouldn’t rotate these sites, instead find the best field available for each district and host it there every year. If other schools want to host, then make their fields better.
That is my baseball complaint, now here is my track and field complaint: Kansas has all classes at Wichita State’s facility for a two-day event which is extremely hectic, but extremely fun with tons of fans and athletes. You have the opportunity to see all the top athletes in the state at the same time, it is the same pro-MSHSAA argument I made for the Show-Me Bowl.
While that is a model I’d love MSHSAA to adopt, my main issue from track and field is the manner the athletes were treated and herded around.
The state championships are a stage that most of these athletes have been striving for their entire careers, but MSHSAA robs so much emotion from the event with the way they handle the athletes.
Other journalists from across the state have raised examples this week of this overzealous behavior. One example was tweeted about by Greg Hall of Mo.Milesplit. Here is his tweet:
“MSHSAA hospitality. Brett Shaffer of (Chillicothe) wins the C3 110H. After crossing the finish line he spies a photog he obviously knows well and rushes to embrace him. The photog is immediately admonished by a MSHSAA official and told to not interfere w/ runners. WHAT?”
Shaffer provided some clarification by responding to the tweet which featured a photo of him hugging a photographer. Here is his tweet:
“Great photos as usual! Thanks for capturing the moment! That’s my grandpa Butch Shaffer, a photographer who’s been covering state track for 25 years. Apparently that’s still not enough to earn himself a hug from his grandson.”
MSHSAA was apparently very concerned with keeping things moving though and apparently a 15-second hug between a thrilled state champion and his grandfather is just slowing things up too much.
It wasn’t an isolated incident either as any emotion was frowned on by the MSHSAA officials. Maryville’s Caleb Feuerbacher was a victim as well.
Feuerbacher had just accomplished one of the biggest goals of his life by winning the state title in the 3,200-meter run. He was understandably elated.
The kids who had just run two miles were grabbing cups of water and talking off to the side — out of the way of everyone. The MSHSAA officials weren’t satisfied with that though and began yelling at the exhausted, but elated runners.
One official asked the runners if they wanted to talk or get their medals. Threatening your student-athletes probably isn’t the best choice.
MSHSAA, just to let you know, these events aren’t about you, they are about Caleb and they are about Brett. Letting your athletes take a minute to enjoy themselves after the ultimate highlight of their careers is the right move.
Missouri handles 90 percent of its business in the best way possible, but I sincerely hope they consider looking at these situations in the future. Sports are built on emotion and fair play. Time to protect both.

