Skip to content

The Cobbler: Royals’ Top 50 list is good for a laugh if nothing else

Phil Cobb

If ever there was an argument against fan voting for the Major League Baseball All-Star Game, or for anything for that matter, it’s the Top 50 Kansas City Royals list that the team has been releasing one member and one day at a time via Twitter for the past 27 days or so.

So far the team includes one non-player, former manager Whitey Herzog, so it’s not just players.

It only took one day for the list to be revealed as flawed, as Jarrod Dyson was announced as the No. 50 player in the team’s history. How can a player who was not even a starter be considered as one of the team’s best ever?

I would say that Dyson might be one of the personnel department’s top success stories, as he is quite possibly the most improved player in team history from where he started to where he finished.

Dyson was a slightly better baseball player than Terrance Gore when he was drafted in the 50th round of the 2006 draft.

Dyson rose to the level of fourth outfielder for the Royals, appearing in 120 games in 2014 because of Alex Gordon’s groin tear and is currently making $3.75 million as the centerfielder for the Arizona Diamondbacks.

It’s a great story and he shares a birthplace with my sister-in-law Dixie Davis, but none of that ranks him in the team’s Top 50.

I guess it should be noted that I have no idea what the criteria is for the list, I’m only assuming that the Top 50 list would include the 50 most significant figures in the team’s 50-year history.

I have no idea when or where the voting took place for this list, but I will point out that many Royals fans, a large portion of which have been minted within the past four years, can only draw from the name recognition of that small window of success and the big names like George Brett and Frank White, of course.

I’ve since found the link to the voting on the team’s website — not at all prominently displayed.

I’ll pause here to suggest some alternate names for this particular list. Here are a few that I feel would be more accurate:

Who are the most popular players on your favorite team?

Which of these names do you recognize?

Can you name 50 Royals players and/or coaches?

Today the team announced Freddie Patek as the team’s 23rd best player. Patek was a slick-fielding (not to the level of Alcides Escobar) and very light-hitting shortstop from 1971 to 1979. Patek was one of my favorite players from my earliest years of Royals fandom, but I have to question his inclusion in the Top 25.

Other than his glove, Patek was best known for his base-running abilities. He led the American League with 53 stolen bases in 1977, which also coincided with one of the best teams in club history. Patek hit .262 that year, driving in 60 RBI and scoring 72 times, certainly his best offensive season, but Top 25?

The same is true for Steve Balboni, ranked 26 by the fans on this list.

I think Balboni is here only because he held the team’s single-season record for home runs until Mike Moustakas broke it last season.

Balboni is 12th all-time in home runs for the team, stroking 119 between 1984 and 1988. He also ranks 25th in RBI with 318. That’s about it for “Bye Bye” Balboni.

Did he get that name because of his home runs or because he is 15th in team history in strikeouts with 568 in 1,999 at-bats? He struck out 28 percent of the time, but still finds himself at 26 on the team’s greatest players list.

Here’s where I’ll choose to insert Billy Butler and I’m sure this will get the biggest rise out of my closest Royals-fan friends.

I’ll just come out and say it.

Butler belongs way ahead of Balboni on this list.

Butler, although his lack of effort and selfishness drove me insane much of the time, belongs on this list.

I was shocked to see him come in at No. 37, I really thought fans would rank him higher than he deserves, but I’ll argue that Butler is actually too low on this list.

Like him or not, Butler is 8th in homeruns with 127; 6th in RBI with 628; 8th in hits with 1,273; 7th in doubles with 276; 7th in walks with 427 and 12th in runs scored with 502.

He is seventh in strikeouts with 697, but comparatively, he only struck out 16 percent of the time.

Butler is probably one of the top five pure hitters the club has ever had. His lack of any real defensive presence certainly sinks his status.

Another slight on the list is to another not-so-well-liked member of Royals alumni, Zack Greinke.

Greinke comes in at No. 36. Really? The guy has been one of the best pitchers in the entire game for the past decade-plus, but he’s only the Royals’ 36th-best player?

It’s easy to see why fans don’t like the guy, but come on, give credit where credit is due.

Grienke, who pitched for gawd-awful Royals teams from 2004 through 2010 did not stay around long enough to rack up career numbers, but if he would have, he undoubtedly would be at the top of most categories.

He put up his best numbers in 2009.

His 2.16 ERA from that season is second-best among Royals pitchers all time.

His 242 strikeouts that year are second-best as well.

He won 16 games that season, which ranks tied for 8th all time.

He also became just the third pitcher in team history to win the Cy Young Award.

Greinke is another player whose effort and attitude surely effected him negatively in the fan voting, as well as my memory.

It will be interesting to see how the next 22 players on the list turn out.

The higher it goes, the more I’m going to care and the more I’ll be mad if certain people don’t end up in the right places.

Just to be clear, here’s how the Top 3 should turn out:

1. Ewing and Muriel Kauffman

2. George Brett

3. Frank White

I’m not sure what’s worse about this list, Royals fans’ lack of knowledge about their own team’s history or the fact that coming up with a list of the Top 50 players is understandably difficult.

Leave a Comment