Skip to content

The Cobbler: Royals fans’ standard for greatness is too low

Phil Cobb

I saw a tweet a couple of weeks ago that said something to the effect that the Kansas City Royals need to make Eric Hosmer the next George Brett.

I’m assuming they meant by signing Hosmer who is a free agent and making him a Royal for life.

I couldn’t disagree more.

If the Royals could sign Hosmer for somewhere around $15 million a year for five or six years then sure, do it.

But they can’t, so let’s move on.

Back to the Brett comparison.

Let’s get something straight … on a scale of greatness, the distance between Eric Hosmer and George Brett is roughly the distance between their two hometowns.

Hosmer grew up in Miami.

Brett grew up mostly in El Segundo, California.

Some perspective…

In the Royals’ nearly 50-year history they have technically had a grand total of five players who have been inducted into the Hall of Fame.

They are: Harmon Killebrew, Gaylord Perry, Bob Lemon, Orlando Cepeda and Brett.

Brett is the only one who can truly be considered a “Royal.”

At the time of his induction, Brett had the fourth-highest percentage of votes of any player in the Hall’s history.

The three players ahead of him: Nolan Ryan, Ty Cobb and Tom Seaver.

In comparison, unless Hosmer’s career trajectory takes about a 45-degree upward turn, he has absolutely no chance of even making it into the hall of fame.

He will no doubt make it into the Royals Hall of Fame, but I don’t even think he’ll get his number retired by the team, not even a statue.

That is why I say that, as Royals fans, our standard for greatness is way too low.

We just haven’t seen that many “great” players.

Hosmer is a very good player who was part of a magical time in Royals history.

He was center stage for some of the team’s biggest moments.

But he is no Brett.

Brett had a competitive desire that I would put right up there with Michael Jordan.

And like Jordan, he had the rare ability to successfully manifest that desire.

In other words, if he wanted to beat you, he would find a way to beat you.

The three-run home run he hit off Rich “Goose” Gossage in Game 3 of the 1980 American League Championship Series was the epitome of that statement and right up there among the greatest moments in Royals history.

Brett’s 3,154 hits are the 16th most in baseball history.

He is the only player ever to win a batting title in three different decades, 70s, 80s and 90s.

He was the American League MVP in 1980 and flirted with batting .400 before finishing the season at .390 and leading the team past the Yankees and into its first ever World Series appearance.

He is one of four players in baseball history to amass 3,000 hits, 300 home runs and hit .300 or higher for a lifetime batting average (his was .305). The other players to do that: Stan Musial, Willie Mays and Hank Aaron.

I’m going to stop there on Brett, because the list of his accomplishments could go on for days.

Hosmer is certainly not void of accolades or accomplishments.

As does Brett, Hosmer has two World Series appearances and one World Series title to his name.

He was the All-Star Game MVP in 2016.

He has won four Gold Gloves to Brett’s one.

His mad dash home in Game 5 of the 1985 World Series, though ill-advised, helped seal the title for the Royals.

But he has never won a batting title, never been in the conversation for AL MVP, never even been the clear-cut best player on his own team.

Could Hosmer be the next George Brett if he somehow signs with the Royals?

Well, here’s the argument for that:

Hosmer has played a third as long as Brett did and has about a third the number of hits.

He has 127 home runs so far. At this point in his career, Brett had just 74.

His lifetime batting average is .284.

If he were to return to the Royals, bat over .300 for the next 14 years, continue to hit 20-25 home runs a year and lead the next surge of Royals talent to another World Series …

Ok, you got me.

But they still have to find a way to get him signed. I’ll believe it when I see it.

With the amount of money that has come into the game, it just seems unlikely that a player of Brett’s or even Hosmer’s caliber will stay with the same team throughout a 21-year career.

Leave a Comment