Royals need not retaliate to HBPs

Dalton Vitt
Most people will never experience this sensation, thankfully, but let’s all assume getting socked by a 95 mile-per-hour fastball feels like a Mike Tyson right hook to the kidney.
Stop that. It’s hard to read when you’re wincing. The Royals are tied for Major League Baseball’s lead in hit-by-pitches with the Texas Rangers at 12. Only one of the unfortunate HBPs has resulted in anything more than a bruise –– right fielder Alex Rios hit the disabled list Tuesday with a broken left pinky after getting drilled by the Twins’ J.R. Graham.
While it’s perfectly safe to think Jeff Samardzija’s plunking of Lorenzo Cain on Opening Day may have had some intent, most of the early-season beanball has been nothing more than inside pitching gone awry.
Still, the question remains: should Kansas City retaliate against Minnesota, especially now that Rios will miss around a month of action?
And the answer should be clear: absolutely not.
Historically, baseball has undertaken the barbarian act of pitchers launching baseballs at opposing players who wronged them in some way. Boys will be boys.
Every once in a while, certain events call for a not-so-friendly seam-imprinting fastball to the gut. Your opponent took 45 seconds to round the bases after hitting a solo homer in a 10-0 game? Show him how you feel. A guy just stole second base while his team is whooping yours? Put one in his teammate’s ribs.
But in the Royals’ case now, there’s nothing to retaliate for. Only suspensions and further beanball war can come from Edinson Volquez or Jason Vargas sticking a Twin in the triceps.
There’s been speculation that teams are fed up with KC’s eagerness to pounce from the dugout for celebrations. It’s a bouncy bunch of players who aren’t scared to fist pump after a strikeout, point to teammates after a home run or gleefully tip their caps after a defensive web gem.
It’s really an attitude most fans wish all teams would embrace, but the “unwritten rules” and volume of veterans who came up through the game learning the ropes a different way won’t allow it to happen.
Regardless of the accusations against teams around the division and throughout baseball, the Royals have to find a way to ignore it all. There may come a time when standing up to constant hit-by-pitches becomes necessary, but it isn’t now.
The argument for returning serve and putting one in Joe Mauer’s hip is that, sooner or later, teammates will stand up for one another. Traditionally, a veteran hitter would approach a member of the pitching staff, let him know how his fellow position players felt and suggest a “solution” to the problem.
It’s an old-school train of thought, one that’s been widely accepted for a century in the game. Hitting one of Minnesota’s players might go unnoticed by the league (in the right situation) but certainly not by the Twins themselves. It’s highly unlikely Graham hit Rios intentionally, and his teammates probably share that sentiment.
If Volquez or Vargas nails a Twin Wednesday night or Thursday afternoon, sparks would fly. Minnesota would volley another five-ounce arrow, leaving the Royals out for more proverbial blood.
It’s early, Kansas City looks like the threat almost no national pundits thought it would be, and it doesn’t need Yordano Ventura or Danny Duffy or anyone else suspended for a start or two.
As hard as it may be for a team of 25 players to ignore their comrades being plunked day after day, the pitching staff has to find a way to turn its collective shoulder.
Barking from the dugout at opponents after their pitchers hit teammates is one thing, but the guy who throws the second punch always gets caught.
