Finnegan needs to start season in Royals’ bullpen

Dalton Vitt
It’s amazing how quickly things can change in Spring Training. All it takes is one injury or minor transaction and the outlook on one faction of a team can be almost completely altered.
A couple weeks ago, I was firmly part of the camp of Royals fans that believed left-hander Brandon Finnegan needed to begin the season in Class AAA Omaha as part of the starting rotation. Kansas City didn’t select Finnegan in the first round of 2014’s Amateur Draft to be a seventh-inning reliever or a lefty-specialist out of the bullpen. The 21-year-old shined late last season in a relief role, becoming the first player to compete in the College World Series and the Major League equivalent in the same season.
Despite his success in 2014, the goal and ceiling for Finnegan is to become a top-of-the-rotation starter in the next couple of seasons along with fellow prospects Kyle Zimmer and Sean Manaea.
However, with the news of Tim Collins undergoing Tommy John surgery to repair a torn Ulnar Collateral Ligament –– which puts him down for all of 2015 –– I’ve jumped ship. Finnegan absolutely needs to be a part of the Royals’ bullpen when the regular season begins.
The reason is fairly simple: KC made the playoffs last season for the first time in 29 years. It bulldozed its way to the World Series and stretched the Fall Classic to seven games before ultimately coming up 90-feet short against the San Francisco Madison Bumgarners. Now is not the time to play passive with the young guns.
Kansas City didn’t make last year’s postseason run by hanging on to super-prospect Wil Myers and holding off his arbitration clock. It didn’t peruse through the American League playoffs by shipping off veteran pieces at the deadline in search of hoarding blooming minor leaguers. Dayton Moore –– for the first time in his tenure as Royals GM –– went for it all. It started with the Myers trade and continued with back-to-back trade deadlines of holding firm to valuable veterans. After that strategy clicked firmly into place in 2014, why back down now?
Baseball fans have become increasingly savvy in the last few seasons, learning the ins and outs of minor league options, player contracts, arbitration numbers, etc. Twitter is full of newborn analytics “experts” who will argue that playing for Finnegan’s future is the smart long-term move, that rolling the dice on relegating the young southpaw to the bullpen this season will jeopardize his potential starpower.
But when you’re paying Kendrys Morales, Alex Rios and Edinson Volquez a combined $23.5 million in base salaries for this season, pushing the rest of the chips to the middle of the table is wise. It’s not as if Finnegan can’t be stretched back out into a starter next season. Take a look at what the Atlanta Braves have done with Alex Wood in recent years.
Franklin Morales, another left-handed option for Kansas City, hasn’t allowed an earned run through six spring innings. But if Ned Yost and Moore’s plan to carry an extra bullpen piece at the start of the year holds true, another southpaw won’t hurt.
Statistically, it’s almost impossible the Royals’ bullpen repeats its 2014 success. Still, Yost having the ability to call on any of Greg Holland, Wade Davis, Kelvin Herrera, Luke Hochevar, Jason Frasor, Finnegan or Morales is frightening for any opponent that wants to score after the sixth inning.
The smart play is almost always to put your best 25 players on the Opening Day roster. As of now, Finnegan is part of that group.
Kansas City has shown it means business the last two seasons, and the talent appears to be aligned for another competitive summer. One wrong move, such as taking the “safe” route on Finnegan, can put a club well behind the eight ball.
Just remember how quickly things can change.

