Two sides to everything
Sunday, the St. Louis Rams football team crushed the Oakland Raiders, 52-0, in St. Louis. Monday, the talk wasn’t about the lopsided win, but over a protest by five of the Rams players.
The five football players raised their hands in the “don’t shoot” sign that has become the symbol of those protesting the police shooting of Michael Brown in Ferguson, Missouri, a St. Louis suburb. The police representatives from the St. Louis area demanded an immediate apology from the football Rams for the players’ protest.
With all that said, I don’t have an opinion one way or another about what is happening in Ferguson. Did the police overreact? Did Michael Brown threaten the police the night he was shot? I don’t know, but it’s not the first time athletes have made statements about controversial issues.
Many times, the athletes’ protests came under immediate criticism. However, after a time, their protests proved to be ground-setting that helped bring about reforms.
Probably the most famous protest came during the 1968 Olympics in Mexico City. Tommie Smith and John Carlos had been part of a winning relay team. As the Star Spangled Banner was played after the medals were awarded, the pair of runners raised their fists in the air as a salute to Black Power.
They were expelled by the Olympics and sent home. The image of that protest did not fade away. Recently, Sports Illustrated announced it was the most reproduced image in Olympic history. Smith and Carlos were considered front-runners in the fight for equal rights.
The Olympics are supposed to leave politics on the sidelines. That has seldom been true. As far back as 1908, Ireland boycotted the Olympics in London because the British refused to grant the Irish independence.
One of Jimmy Carter’s most unpopular decisions was to boycott the Olympic Games in Moscow in 1980 because of their policies in Afghanistan. Of course, the Russians followed the lead of the United States by boycotting the 1984 Olympics in Los Angeles.
Not all protests by athletes are near as famous as Smith and Carlos’s in 1968. There aren’t many Jewish baseball players. For the players who are Jewish, a dilemma faces them in September. Yom Kippur, the holiest day on the Jewish calendar, usually falls late in the baseball season.
Shawn Green, an excellent outfielder for the Los Angeles Dodgers, among other teams, refused to play on Yom Kippur. The most famous Yom Kippur absence was Sandy Koufax, another Dodger player, in the 1965 World Series against the Minnesota Twins. The Dodgers lost that game, but came back to win the World Series.
Muhammad Ali used his conversion to Islam as a refusal to be inducted into the Army in 1967. The war in Vietnam was raging and the draft had selected Ali to serve. He refused on religious basis and was jailed. He didn’t fight for three years, but won his heavyweight crown back in 1971. His refusal is now considered one of the most courageous decisions any athlete has ever made.
Sometimes, athletes protest during times of conflict, but opposite of Ali. After the attack on the twin towers on 9/11, Pat Tillman turned down a $3.6 million contract with the Arizona Cardinals and enlisted. He was sent to the Middle East to fight the Taliban. He was killed by friendly fire in 2004. Tillman’s patriotism is still celebrated in the National Football League.
Sometimes the hot topics of the day filter into sports. Immigration reform is a constant battle between President Obama and the Republican Congress. Arizona is ground zero for the immigration debate.
In 2010, the Phoenix Suns wore jerseys that had a protest statement about the Arizona immigration laws. The owner of the Phoenix Suns, Robert Sarver, thought the law discriminated against Mexican immigrants. He was four years ahead of the real debate.
This is just my opinion, but the greatest sports political protest of all-time occurred in 1946. You might have guessed, Branch Rickey signed Jackie Robinson, an African-American, to a professional contract. After a year with the Montreal Royals, Robinson broke the Major League Baseball color barrier.
In 1947, most baseball fans thought Rickey was out of his mind to allow a black man into Major League Baseball. Robinson was the perfect player to be the one to break into the all-white baseball ranks.
What Branch Rickey did with a sports format is amazing. He signed Robinson eight years before Rosa Parks refused to give up her bus seat to a white passenger. Rickey was 10 years ahead of Martin Luther King, Jr. breaking into national prominence. He was 21 years ahead of the Smith and Carlos Olympic protest for black power.
I don’t know if those five St. Louis Rams players should have held up their hands protesting the shooting of Michael Brown. I know I won’t jump to a quick conclusion. If history has taught us anything, there are two sides to everything.

