Mickey and the Mustangs

Gene Steinmeyer
I love trivia, especially sports trivia. Do you know the fewest base runners ever in a major league game? The answer is two. The game was when Sandy Koufax threw a perfect game against the Chicago Cubs. The Cub’s pitcher, Bob Hendley, had a no-hitter until the seventh inning. The one hit he did allow didn’t even figure in the scoring, which ended 1-0.
Here’s another trivia question with more of a local favor. Which Maryville resident has sent 14 baseball players to major league baseball organizations over the past six years? Which Maryville resident (the same one) coaches a team which has an attendance 40 percent higher than the Northwest men’s basketball team’s attendance?
The answer is Matt Johnson, an instructor at Northwest Missouri State University. In the summer of 2007, Matt was living out a final dream of playing professional baseball for the St. Joe Blacksnakes, as a catcher and relief pitcher. The Blacksnakes folded after two summers and the St. Joe Mustangs came to life in 2009.
The Mustangs, a summer college wood bat team, hired Matt Johnson as their first and to this point, only coach. In the first five years of existence in the MINK League, the Mustangs have been a consistent power, winning the league title twice.
My favorite player as a kid was Mickey Mantle, a New York Yankee. As he was dying of liver cancer, he said “If I knew I was gonna live this long, I’d have taken better care of myself.” Mickey played at Phil Welch Stadium, the home of the Mustangs, as he was working his way through the minor leagues. So did Willie Mays.
Phil Welch has come back to life in the last five years. Thanks to owner Dan Gerson’s wise decision to hire Matt and some shrewd marketing creations, St. Joseph and northwest Missouri has embraced the Mustangs.
What Matt and the Mustang’s organization do isn’t easy. It isn’t like the MINK League chooses up sides and plays games. From what I can tell, Matt spends most of the winter finding players for summer ball. He has contacts from all levels of collegiate baseball. Players come from as far away as France and Rhode Island to as local as Missouri Western and Northwest Missouri State.
Some decisions the bigger NCAA Division I baseball teams make are hard to figure. A couple of years ago, Matt took a junior college freshman catcher by the name of Tanner Lubach. He was going to Nebraska in the fall, but the Nebraska coaches were just lukewarm about their new recruit. Tanner had gone to high school in Lincoln, Nebraska.
After a great summer with the Mustangs, Lubach started 46 games in his sophomore year and was a main cog on their regional-qualifying team in 2014. I was hopeful to see him back with the Mustangs, but Matt told me the Nebraska coaches probably wanted him to go to the Cape Cod League.
Here’s what doesn’t make sense. The Mustangs average over 2,000 fans. That’s always in the top 10 nationally for wood bat collegiate summer teams. Will more scouts see him play in the Cape Cod League?
Maybe, but the Mariners, Astros, Yankees, Brewers, Indians, Pirates, Phillies, Orioles, Tigers, Athletics and Padres have seen enough of Mustang players to sign them to minor league contracts. That’s just been in the last five seasons, plus part of a sixth.
My favorite story of a player getting signed was Chris Green. Green was Matt’s closer. They had just played their first game in the World Series in Wichita, Kansas, where Green topped 100 miles per hour on the radar gun. On the way to the bus, an Orioles scout stopped Matt to inquiry about Green signing with them. Green was out of the World Series and into an Orioles uniform, all in 48 hours.
Everyone in the MINK League can boast former players who have gotten a look from major league organizations. I doubt any have found such instant success as Matt. You have to give credit to his scouting staff of one, just Matt.
To me, the most amazing thing is the popularity of the Mustangs. The Blacksnakes played to hardly any size of crowd and soon was out of town. Somehow, Gerson and general manager, Ky Turner, have found the right formula for success. Their crowds most nights are more than the rest of the league’s games combined.
Just so you get an idea of how the attendance average of 2,000 compares to other venues, the Northwest Missouri State baseball team averaged 209 fans for home games in 2014. Don’t be critical of Northwest, the attendance away from Maryville was only 138.
No one can argue that Northwest men’s basketball is very popular. Yet the Bearcats drew 800 fewer fans per game than Mustang baseball and they won the MIAA championship. The biggest crowd of the year for the Mustangs is Northwest Missouri State University Night, which drew almost 5,000 fans. Phil Welch Stadium capacity is less than 4,000.
I asked Matt what accomplishments meant the most to him personally.
“The two MINK titles,” Matt predictably said. “Also the guys coming back and seeing them after they are all done and with families. The alumni game was so much fun with all the old stories and memories.”
That’s only five-plus years of memories. Matt actually sounds like an old-time coach that can’t wait to see the “old guys.” This is only his sixth year as the Mustangs’ coach.
The Mustangs currently have a two-game lead on the Chillicothe Mudcats with about two weeks left in the season. It’s worth the money to check the Mustangs out. Hot dogs are only a buck. How can you go wrong?
Maybe you’ll see another potential Mickey Mantle play.

