Skip to content

Just don’t call it a season

By PHIL COBB The Forum
Phil Cobb

I really hope Major League Baseball doesn’t bastardize the history books by coming up with some cockamamie plan to save the baseball season.

If it becomes safe to do so, I’m fine with whatever form baseball takes on for 2020, but I think — by the end of this pandemic — we will be at a point where calling it a season, or, at the very most, sitting it alongside most other seasons, would be a mistake.

The latest rumor I’ve seen included playing every game in Arizona with teams isolated from one another and from the world for about four and a half months. Games would be played in empty stadiums, void of fans, and I’m guessing without much staffing of any kind.

I’ve heard the idea of playing a half season, starting on the Fourth of July, which sounds pretty cool and all, but can we be sure — in time to lay out all the logistics — that it will be safe for the players, let alone the fans?

Whatever they come up with, I just don’t think they can treat it like a major league season.

I say treat it like Spring Training or the Arizona Fall League or something like that.

It would be a season set aside from all other seasons and the statistics wouldn’t count outside of it.

One of the biggest reasons why, for me, is there’s just no way to replicate a real-life baseball season with all of the travel and day-to-day ins and outs.

There’s no way the competition can be the same.

The pitching, for sure, won’t be the same — I’ve heard of rosters being expanded to 29 players to account for limited preparation for pitchers.

The rosters won’t be the same either, if for no other reason than geography and limited travel between wherever they play minor league games and wherever the major league games are played.

Will minor league games even be played? Where would those be?

If a player like a Whit Merrifield or a Salvador Perez goes down to injury, where does his replacement come from?

Sure, with 29 players, rosters could be beefed up a bit, but that pipeline that every team relies on for depth either won’t be there at all or will be limited at best.

I don’t know, I’m thinking this whole “season” might be best looked at like exhibition games, such as the All-Star Game for instance.

Play whatever games you can in whatever format you can, but let’s just look at it like an exhibition season — a great big Spring Training-like season where teams continue to develop talent as much as possible, the numbers don’t count and the winners and losers are contained within the capsule of The Season That Wasn’t.

It won’t be the first time there wasn’t a true season.

The 1994 campaign will always be remembered as the players’ strike, but at least that season started from the beginning when it was supposed to.

The 1981 season lost about 60 games in the middle due to a labor dispute, but it began and ended on time.

The 1942 through 1945 seasons were hugely impacted by World War II and the number of players who served in the military, but at least the games were played as scheduled.

Probably the closest comparison to what this season might end up being was in 1972 when the first ever strike cost the league about two weeks at the beginning of the season.

Although it was just two weeks, it was poorly handled and teams ended up playing an uneven amount of contests.

This was most highlighted by the American League East division, where the Detroit Tigers and Boston Red Sox went down to the wire before the Tigers were declared the winner.

Detroit, 86-70, played one more game than Boston, 85-70.

Red Sox fans, the ones who remember, still haven’t let that one go.

Those types of inconsistencies are what I’m saying need to be avoided this year.

What do teams do about the titanic loss of revenue? I have no idea.

What do they do about my season ticket money? Do I get a refund? Who knows?

I hope that somehow, some way, we get to watch real major league baseball in 2020, and if I’m being greedy, I’d like to do so in my seat at Kauffman Stadium.

But I can enjoy the game just fine without determining how this team or these players or this “season” stacks up alongside other, uninterrupted seasons.

Play the games, just don’t count the results.

Leave a Comment