Soler’s power or Whit’s hits, who is Kansas City’s MVP?
Fox Sports Kansas City personality Joel Goldberg posted on Twitter this past week a poll asking, “Who is the Royals Player of the Year?”
Goldberg provided two options: Whit Merrifield and Jorge Soler.
My first response was, “Are you freakin’ kidding me?” How could Soler, who can’t play defense, be included in the same sentence as Multi-Hit Whit, who has now led all of baseball in total hits two seasons in a row, while playing above average defense at multiple positions through all 162 games?
Toward the beginning of this season I wrote a column insisting that judging the value of major league baseball players does not have to be complicated. All you have to do is add up the number of points (runs plus RBI) the player accounts for and that will tell you all you need to know.
If two players are virtually equal in runs scored, you simply choose the one who is the better defender.
Well, here’s how that turned out for the Boys and Blue this summer:
Jorge Soler, 212; 2. Whit Merrifield, 179; 3. Hunter Dozier, 159; 4. Alex Gordon, 153; 5. Adalberto Mondesi, 120 (missed 60 games)
Based on that simple formula, Soler was easily the most valuable offensive player for the Royals, plus, after 51 seasons of the franchise, Soler has finally given the team a respectable home run record — 48. Previously, KC was the only major league team with a home run record in the 30s, Mike Moustakas’ 38 in 2017.
The basis for my formula is that the object of the game, as is the case for most competitive contests, is to score more points than the other team. Therefore, the player who scores the most points — runs — either by crossing the plate himself or by causing another player to cross the plate is no doubt the most valuable offensive player.
Here’s where it gets more complicated: Obviously scoring points is not the only method of impacting the game for your team.
There also has to be consideration given for how many points you prevent the other team from scoring.
I’d like to think that if a player makes it to the major leagues, he must be a pretty good defender, therefore the difference in defense would mostly be negligible.
As we witnessed in the National League Wild Card game between the Milwaukee Brewers and the Washington Nationals Tuesday night, that’s obviously not the case.
What should have been a routine single did not even touch Brewers right fielder Trent Grisham’s glove as it scooted past him, allowing the tying and winning runs to score and killing his team’s postseason chances.
Likewise, Soler’s defense so negatively impacts the team that the Royals have opted to make him their full-time designated hitter.
Whereas Merrifield is one of the better defenders on the team and can play just about every position at a major league level.
But, is Merrifield appreciably better defensively than any of the other guys that can be put in those spots? He’s not as good of a second baseman as Nicky Lopez, not the shortstop that Mondesi is, not the left fielder that Gordon is, not the centerfielder that Brett Phillips is, not the right fielder that Bubba Starling is, etc.
So, how valuable is defense? It’s impossible to measure.
Consideration also must be given to the number of Soler’s RBI that were the result of Merrifield getting on base and how many of Merrifield’s runs scored were the result of Soler driving him in.
Fortunately for Soler, the American League still uses the DH and the Royals look like they have identified their DH of the foreseeable future.
All of this said, I’m still giving the MVP to Whit, but it’s a lot closer than I initially thought. I wouldn’t even complain if the team decides to go with a co-MVP.

