Skip to content

The Cobbler: Royals are in limbo land

Phil Cobb

The Kansas City Royals are in a strange spot.

For the most part, the offense and fielding defense is capable of competing for a division title, especially in a pretty weak American League Central Division.

However, the pitching staff would struggle to succeed even at the AAA level.

It’s a difficult spot for a general manager like Dayton Moore to find himself in — the team can score enough runs and the fielding defense can prevent enough runs, but unfortunately, the only real pitching in the Royals system is at least two seasons away.

By the time the pitching is ready to seriously compete, some of the offensive pieces, like Salvador Perez and Alex Gordon and maybe even Whit Merrifield, will be either retired or on their way out of the game.

That means that when pitchers like Brady Singer, Jackson Kowar, Daniel Lynch and Kris Bubic are ready to lead the pitching staff, they will need to be bringing some teammates with bats to replace aging veterans.

That must be what Moore and manager Ned Yost are counting on.

For Royals fans like me, that means we’re in for a couple of more tough years. … I’m now thinking that we might have to wait until 2021 for any real chance at success.

That got me thinking … what might that lineup look like in 2021?

Here’s an idea of what the batting order and defensive positioning could look like:

  • Adalberto Mondesi (CF)
  • Nicky Lopez (2B)
  • Hunter Dozier (3B)
  • Jorge Soler (DH)
  • Seuly Matias (RF)
  • Nick Pratto (1B)
  • Salvador Perez (C)
  • Khalil Lee (LF)
  • Bobby Witt Jr. (SS)

I know some of this is pretty far-fetched and I might be rushing Witt since he’s probably graduating from high school this weekend, but this has the potential of being an amazing lineup.

I haven’t seen enough to know if Soler will still be around, but even though he strikes out a lot, he is currently on pace to break Mike Moustakas’ single-season home run record.

Salvy will be in the final year of his contract and who knows whether or not his body will hold up, but M.J. Melendez should be ready by then if he’s not. I still say Salvy could move to first base or obviously, DH.

Putting Mondesi in center field is purely my idea. I haven’t heard anyone else float this out there yet, but there’s no reason why he wouldn’t be an above-average outfielder. If Witt (not Whit) isn’t ready, Mondesi stays there and maybe Bubba Starling is there … who knows.

One thing this exercise has told me is that short of a major catastrophe, the Royals offense should be pretty awesome — with plenty depth and options — by 2021.

Let’s look at the pitching staff. The story could be pretty much the same on the mound as well.

It’s pretty much impossible to predict who will be in the bullpen, because bullpens are typically made up of the guys who don’t make it in the starting rotation and guys who happen to get on a hot streak at the right time. But the Royals appear to be cultivating some options there with the likes of Richard Lovelady, Scott Barlow and others. I believe Danny Duffy will wind up here as well and very well could extend his career if he embraces a reliever role.

The starting rotation is a little easier to predict and that’s where the real difference can be made for this team.

We could be looking at a starting rotation that is made up from among the following:

  • Jackson Kowar
  • Daniel Lynch
  • Brady Singer
  • Brad Keller
  • Jake Junis
  • Kris Bubic
  • Jorge Lopez
  • Arnaldo Hernandez

Of course, Duffy could still be here, as well. And there’s no guarantee that all of these young guys will make it that far, but if the 25-man roster looks anywhere close to this in 2021, it will be worth it to have suffered through the transition.

Leave a Comment