Skip to content

Grading the Chiefs’ draft week

Jon Dykstra

The craziness of the NFL offseason is nearly over after the NFL Draft concluded on Saturday. This offseason has had the Chiefs in a different position than they have ever been in my lifetime. They are building around a franchise quarterback.

Having the NFL MVP under his rookie contract gives the Chiefs the most valuable asset in the NFL and the cheapness of Patrick Mahomes’ contract gave the Chiefs more flexibility than most.

With that in mind, let’s recap how the Chiefs used their draft to improve the team.

The Trade:

The draft for the Chiefs began last Tuesday with the team dealing for Seattle defensive end Frank Clark for the No. 29 overall pick, a second-round pick next year and a swap of third-round picks this year.

At first look, the price for Clark seems high considering Dee Ford was traded earlier this offseason for just a second-round pick next year, but the Chiefs are shifting to 4-3 defense next season under new defensive coordinator Steve Spagnuolo and Ford is unproven as a defensive end while the 6-foot-3, 265-pound Clark fits and has 35 sacks in his career including a career-high 13 this year.

The other advantage of Clark is that he is only 25 years old so despite being a proven contributor, he still has most of his prime in front of him.

On the field, Clark seems like the perfect leader for the pass-rush unit and an absolute terror next to Chris Jones. Off the field, there are questions though.

Clark was dismissed from the University of Michigan in 2014 after he was arrested on charges of domestic violence (later reduced to disorderly conduct in a plea deal). He hasn’t had any issues with the Seahawks and spent time during his introductory press conference to address the issue.

Clark has had a rough upbringing and spent time homeless as a Los Angeles youth. He appears to have matured since his college days and hopefully he won’t have any Tyreek Hill-type headlines in his future.

Grade — B-

Mecole Hardman:

With the 24th pick of the second round, Kansas City selected Georgia wide receiver Mecole Hardman.

It is hard to miss the similarities that the 5-foot-10, 187-pound Hardman shares with the 5-foot-10, 185-pound Tyreek Hill. Hardman turned in a 4.27 40-yard dash (according to Chiefs GM Brett Veach) while Hill was recorded at 4.28 when he came out of West Alabama.

While I like some other receivers available more, the role Hardman fills is extremely important. With Hardman, the Chiefs have made sure that they will keep a speedster on the outside for Mahomes when the team (hopefully) cuts ties with Hill.

The greatest difference in Hardman and Hill is that Hardman is known to be a great teammate and has excellent intangibles. That is something this Chiefs team could use from a PR perspective.

Grade — B+

Juan Thornhill:

With the 31st pick in the second round, Kansas City selected Virginia safety Juan Thornhill.

Before the Hill fiasco, the defensive backfield was clearly the top need for the Chiefs entering the draft and while Tyrann Mathieu is a big-time playmaker, the other safety spot was up in the air.

The Thornhill selection gives the Chiefs a younger version of Mathieu to give the Chiefs the most versatile safety duo in the league. Like Mathieu, Thornhill played both safety and cornerback in college.

He is a good run defender and a ball-hawk after six interceptions as a senior. He showed his explosiveness at the combine with a 4.42 40-yard dash and a 44-inch vertical.

Grade — A

Khalen Saunders:

With the 20th pick in the third round, Kansas City selected Western Illinois defensive tackle Khalen Saunders.

This pick was a classic “building on a strength” type pick. With defensive tackles Derrick Nnadi, Xavier Williams and Chris Jones along with defensive ends Clark, Alex Okafor, Emmanuel Ogbah, Breeland Speaks and Tanoh Kpassagnon; the Chiefs seemed pretty loaded in the front four. But Saunders was just too good to pass up.

As a 324-pounder, he looks like the type 1-technique tackle that you want next to a 3-technique penetrator like Jones. Where he separates himself from Nnadi and Williams is his remarkable athleticism.

Saunders tore up the combine with his athletic testing. As a small-school prospect, he may need time to develop, but Nnadi and Williams can give him that time.

The Eagles showed everyone two seasons ago how important a defensive line rotation can be. The Chiefs should have one of the deepest in the league this year and the future starting four of Clark, Jones, Saunders and Ogbah is certainly fun.

The only question I have is that the Chiefs desperately needed a cornerback, but with Justin Layne going to the Steelers a pick earlier, the value simply wasn’t there for corners.

Grade — A-

Rashad Fenton:

With the 28th pick of the sixth round, Kansas City selected South Carolina cornerback Rashad Fenton.

The Chiefs definitely have a type in the secondary. Fenton has experience at safety, cornerback and nickel back at South Carolina and profiles as a future nickel option. Fenton has plenty of physical gifts, but his NFL future will depend on his ability to read and process plays.

Fenton seemed like a reach when the team drafted him as a player most didn’t think would be drafted, but Kansas City simply had to address the cornerback spot eventually. I would have preferred Texas’s Kris Boyd or James Madison’s Jimmy Moreland, but at least the Chiefs got someone behind the Kendall Fuller, Charvarius Ward, Bashaud Breeland and Tremon Smith.

Fenton should be a fixture on special teams and that is where he is likely to make an impact as a rookie rather than on defense.

Grade — C-

Darwin Thompson:

With the 41st pick of the sixth round, Kansas City selected Utah State running back Darwin Thompson.

This was my favorite pick of the sixth and seventh rounders. Thompson is an undersized (5-foot-8, 198 pounds) scatback and can fill a role in an NFL offense. He was a 1,000-yard rusher and had 14 touchdowns at Utah State last season.

While he will never be a bell-cow type runner, he gives Andy Reid and Mahomes another toy to deploy and should contribute on special teams as well. There were other interesting running backs available though like Georgia’s Elijah Holyfield, Michigan’s Karan Higdon and Washington’s Myles Gaskin.

Grade — C

Nick Allegretti:

With the second pick of the seventh round, Kansas City selected Illinois offensive lineman Nick Allegretti.

The most under-talked-about position of need for the Chiefs is center. Mitch Morse and Jordan Devey each left in free agency and it is tough to see who will replace them. Austin Reiter, who was cut by the Browns this offseason is the leading contender, but behind interior linemen Cameron Erving, Laurent Duvernay-Tardif and Reiter, the depth is lacking so Allegretti will certainly have a chance to make the roster.

All that said, Allegretti simply wasn’t on the radar of many scouting analysts and wasn’t even ranked on many draft websites. So while he fills a need, I would have preferred an option like Stanford’s Nate Herbig or Wisconsin’s Beau Benzschawel.

Grade — D+

Overall:

I wasn’t super-thrilled with how the Chiefs handled the back-end of the draft, but I was a big fan of the top three selections and the Clark trade definitely helps the defense. I’m just glad they didn’t have another Breeland Speaks-style second-round reach.

Overall Grade — B

Leave a Comment