Skip to content

Spike Speaks: Reacting to the Spagnuolo hiring

Jon Dykstra

Last week in this space, I wrote about the five priorities for the Chiefs this offseason and the moves they should make as a franchise to insure that they continue to improve as a team. Much of that column revolved around the defense and the first priority was to move away from Bob Sutton as defensive coordinator.

Kansas City executed that move before my column appeared in the paper. On Thursday, they named Sutton’s successor — former Rams and Giants head coach Steve Spagnuolo.

While my choice for defensive coordinator last week was a younger candidate who would have been a first-time coordinator — Ravens’ secondary coach Chris Hewitt — anyone other than Sutton certainly offers more excitement heading into next season.

The fact of the matter is that like most coaching free agents, there is a reason Spagnuolo wasn’t already with a team. Spagnuolo’s defensive reputation comes largely from one performance.

That game was Super Bowl XLII when the Giants shut down what was the greatest offense in NFL history to that point. The Giants held Tom Brady, Randy Moss, Wes Welker and that Patriots crew to just 17 points in the greatest upset in NFL history.

After another good defensive season with the Giants, Spagnuolo leveraged that success into a head-coaching job with the St. Louis Rams. He spent three seasons with the Rams before he was fired with a 10-38 overall record.

The New Orleans Saints then hired Spagnuolo as their defensive coordinator. He only lasted one year as the 2012 Saints were statistically the worst defense in the NFL history, breaking a 31-year total yardage-allowed record held by the Baltimore Colts.

The Giants brought Spagnuolo back to be their defensive coordinator after he spent and two seasons as a position coach with the Ravens, and in his first season back, the 2015 Giants finished last in the NFL in yardage allowed.

Spagnuolo-led defenses his last seven years have been 29th, 19th, 22nd, 32nd, 32nd, 10th and 31st in yardage allowed. When new Giants head coach Pat Shurmur took over the team before last season, he made the decision not to retain Spagnuolo.

While all that may paint a grim picture of Spagnuolo, there are obviously reasons the Chiefs picked him over some more potentially exciting names. The number one reason is Spagnuolo knows a guy and that guy is Andy Reid.

Before taking the Giants defensive coordinator job the first time in 2007, Spagnuolo was on legendary Eagle defensive coordinator Jim Johnson’s defensive staff in Philadelphia for five years. One could argue that Johnson was the last good defensive coordinator that Reid has had, so hiring someone from his lineage obviously appealed to Reid.

The biggest and most talked about element to the shift is what must be an organizational decision to shift away from a 3-4 scheme to a 4-3 which Spagnuolo has always coached. So let’s take a quick look at how the overall defensive unit, particularly the front-seven, figures to line-up in a 4-3 look.

The biggest key is in the middle where the best building block this defense has resides. Chris Jones will likely shift from a 3-4 defensive end into a three-technique defensive tackle (which generally lines up between the offensive guard and tackle) and honestly, I think Jones will be elite at both spots so he is the least of my concerns.

Next to Jones, at the one-technique defensive tackle (lining up between the guard and center) will be the familiar combo of Derrick Nnadi and Xavier Williams. An advantage to the 4-3 is that in a 4-3, one of them will always be on the field — where in a 3-4, the Chiefs tended to take them off the field in nickel packages and that hurt their run defense.

At linebacker, the switch may help because although there are technically more linebackers on the field in Sutton’s defense, Dee Ford and Justin Houston were nearly always rushing the passer in the Chiefs’ base defense, so in Spagnuolo’s base defense there will be three linebackers covering the ground that two were responsible for in Sutton’s.

As I referenced last week, the Chiefs are committed financially to Anthony Hitchens for at least one more year before its even possible he’s cut and they surrendered draft capital to get Reggie Ragland. Ragland is most likely to be the middle linebacker next season while Hitchens will shift to one of the outside spots, similar to where he played in Dallas.

An important spot to fill in the offseason will be the third linebacker spot where they need an infusion of speed. Dorian O’Daniel is the in-house candidate to fill that role, but names like Alabama’s Mack Wilson and Michigan’s Devin Bush would definitely be interesting on draft day.

The biggest question mark is at defensive end. The Chiefs can save $14 million by cutting Justin Houston and rather than ask the 30 year-old to play a position he has never played before, the Chiefs may want to use that money on someone else.

They face a similar decision with free agent Dee Ford. Ford could be a fit in the new scheme at defensive end, but it is also a risk to pay him the money he will command to play a position he has never played in the NFL.

Unless the Chiefs are counting on big leaps from Breeland Speaks and Tanoh Kpassagnon, it is very possible that the Chiefs will have two new primary pass rushers next season.

If the Chiefs cut Houston, they’ll have over $50 million in cap space this offseason, so while the move away from Sutton was a celebrated move for most of Chiefs Kingdom, it is just the start of the defensive overhaul. Spagnuolo alone certainly won’t fix the defense, but an offseason of adding talent on that side of the ball might and with a new coordinator and scheme in place, that process starts now.

Leave a Comment