Skip to content

The CFP is just the cherry on top

Image courtesy of ASSOCIATED PRESS
Boston College running back Willis against Maryland in the 2016 Quick Lane Bowl

When the NCAA caved to demand, dismantled the BCS, and installed a College Football Playoff system at the Division I level a few seasons ago, we should have seen this coming.

They say that the Penn States of the world are unfairly stuck on the outside looking in after winning their conferences, or that Big 12 teams are punished for not having a championship game as then-Baylor coach Art Briles sophomorically bemoaned two years ago. (Needless to say, Briles lost his job for reasons far separated from failing to finish top-four in the nation.)

These are very minor problems regarding the implementation of a four-team playoff mechanic in the grand scheme, because they are issues that the NCAA ultimately must have forecast before the post-BCS system was officially enacted. After all, the Big Ten champion is playing in the Rose Bowl as was the case for so many decades until the polarizing technological advent of the Bowl Championship System in 1998. Happy Valley’s and Waco’s are just sundry examples of programs under a bright enough spotlight without the aggrandizing stage that comes with qualifying for a national semifinal, and the only real tragedy is one that was much less predictable.

Entirely too many times throughout the Div. I season, many fans, pundits, and analysts alike made base claims that a team’s season was “over” after a single loss. When Louisville lost at Clemson 42-36 early in the season in arguably the best-played football game of the year, analyst Todd McShay unfairly speculated the Cardinals’ goose to be cooked, merely because their odds of entering the playoff were minimalized. I hardly believe that playing in the Citrus Bowl against Louisiana State on New Year’s Eve constitutes a failure of a season as McShay suggested – especially after quarterback Lamar Jackson collected the college’s first Heisman Trophy.

“Irrelevant bowl game” is, simply put, a three-word oxymoron. I will not take the time to argue that the glut of 40 total bowl games isn’t too many – that would be a bit of a stretch when the SEC’s Mississippi State defeated Miami (OH) in the St. Petersburg Bowl and still finished below .500. But what about teams like Boston College, just four years separated from a winless ACC slate, who bring home hardware in the postseason? That leaves a tremendous impact on a program and its fans.

To Mr. McShay, I would guarantee that there is not a single program in the nation that doesn’t have winning its bowl game as one of its foremost preseason goals.

In an era of increasingly exorbitant television deals and ‘round-the-clock coverage, we seem only to care about who the very best is – in other words, which of the 129 Div. I programs has the strongest recruiting pipelines with the best boosters. How many of these schools had a realistic shot, entering the season, of being selected as one of the programs with a possible two postseason games?

Quite simply, the literal answer is 64 – as Western Michigan’s improbable and magical 13-0 season proved, the selection committee pays only a token amount of attention to teams outside of what has been deemed the Power 5 conferences. The Broncos, out of the Mid-American Conference, earned a Cotton Bowl berth on Jan. 2 versus Big Ten power Wisconsin: a tremendous achievement for nearly any program. Western Michigan defeated five bowl-eligible teams throughout the course of the season, including two from the Big Ten.

Frankly, if head coach P.J. Fleck leads the Broncos to a victory over the Badgers, one could easily argue that given their fiscal and geographical resources, it would be the most successful season in all of college football.

This is not a knock against the four teams that qualified, as they have certainly had many entertaining, dominant performances throughout the year, and programs on the outside will always have a shot in seasons to come.

Unlike Week 17 NFL games between teams who are playoff-ineligible, these games are significant to programs looking to build, rebuild, or enter the national conversation in any capacity.

Old Dominion defeated Eastern Michigan 24-20 in a cooker. Old Dominion had never been to bowl game, and Eastern Michigan hadn’t been for decades. The entertainment is there.

To Mr. McShay’s point, I don’t disagree that the College Football Playoff is what we’re all waiting to see. But to Mr. McShay, I would say, “Bet you’ve been locked on ESPN all month anyway.”

Image courtesy of ASSOCIATED PRESS
Terrell, quarterback of Western Michigan. The Broncos completed a perfect 13-0 regular season and conference championship.

Leave a Comment