Amending our Constitution
Our state Constitution has become like a Christmas tree on which numerous special interests seek to hang an amendment to advance their particular cause.
The process has gotten out of hand, in many respects asking the electorate to make decisions that more appropriately should be made by our elected state legislators.
It is time to reverse this trend.
In 1908, Missouri adopted a process allowing citizens to propose and vote upon amendments to the state constitution, one of 18 states with this process. Also, the General Assembly can propose constitutional amendments.
Together, these procedures have contributed to a Missouri Constitution, as amended, that is 136 pages long. By contrast, the U.S. Constitution, as amended, is 16 pages long. Since its adoption in 1789, the U.S. Constitution has been amended 27 times. According to a study by Dr. David Valentine of the Missouri Legislative Academy, between 1910 and 2012, there have been 232 proposed constitutional amendments submitted to Missouri voters by the General Assembly; 61 as a result of voter initiatives. Altogether, 147 were approved.
We were asked to vote on five amendments in August, and now on four more. The Legislature could handle the issues involved in the overwhelming majority of these proposals. Passing the buck to the general electorate is an abdication of responsibilities.
While giving citizens a voice and the right to propose amendments is generally a good thing, too often those amendments are to advance a special interest. Many of the issues involved are more complicated than a reading of the proposed amendment suggests, and most of us don’t understand the nuances of those issues.
Our legislators have staff to research the matters. They can hold hearings and debate them; they can hold public forums or send newsletters to constituents. They can vote their conscience on the matter. That is how representative government is to work, and it is the system that will get the best result.
A constitution should be limited to guaranteeing certain rights of the people, enumerating governmental powers, providing for elections, specifying how the Constitution can be amended, and little more. It should set a basic framework of government, not get into the minutiae of governing.
In August, we were asked about farmers’ rights and a lottery for veterans. In a few days, we will be asked about rules of evidence in certain sex crimes and performance standards and the length of teachers’ contracts. Perhaps the only real issue on the upcoming ballot worth constitutional consideration deals with the powers of the governor in proposing a budget and withholding money from an appropriation.
In principle, I am voting against everything else, even though I may be sympathetic to a particular issue. We elected the legislature to represent us in enacting laws. Let’s require them to do what they are supposed to do. And then, maybe we should have a ballot initiative to do away with ballot initiatives.
Joe Cornelison, Maryville
