Skip to content

Tommy John changed ‘America’s Pastime’

Gene Steinmeyer

In 1989, Mark McGwire was in his third season with the Oakland Athletics. He was facing a pitcher that was attempting to finish his 26th year in the major leagues. The young McGwire had a good day getting two hits off the aging pitcher.

McGwire’s dad was a dentist in California. When that day in 1989 ended, the old pitcher told reporters, “When your dentist’s kid starts hitting you, it’s time to retire.” That pitcher was Tommy John. The same Tommy John that is noted more for his name on elbow surgery than his career.

Tommy John began his major league career in 1963 with the Cleveland Indians. He was a soft-tossing sinker ball pitcher when he tore a ligament in his elbow in 1974. That type of injury almost always meant the end of a promising career. In 1974, John already had 124 career wins. There probably wouldn’t be any more.

Dr. Frank Jobe came on the scene and offered John a revolutionary, new surgery. With the surgery, the torn ligament would be replaced with a tendon from John’s forearm. It took a year to recover, but starting in 1976 and lasting until 1989, Tommy John won another 164 games.

Why the history lesson? It seems there is an epidemic of Tommy John surgery’s in the major leagues this year. The latest count I have for 2014 is 39 major and minor league players that have gone under the knife, including Royals pitcher Luke Hochevar.

Some people think that all the added velocity on pitches is the cause. Others have blamed over-use as early as Little League for the problems. That caught my attention. I have been coaching my son’s baseball team since T-Ball. I can guarantee T-Ball didn’t cause any Tommy John surgery. It has driven many parents out of coaching their son’s team, however.

It’s anyone’s guess how much damage abusive little leagues can do to the elbows of aspiring pitchers. All Leagues have rules to safe-guard pitchers. Those rules are sometimes ignored by coaches who put wins over the safety of their players.

Sometimes the rules are at fault. There are many organizations for youth baseball. A few are Babe Ruth, Cal Ripken, Pony League and Dizzy Dean. The two I am familiar with are USSSA and Little League.

The pitching rules are different for both organizations. USSSA has an innings limit. The Little League organization has a pitch count limit.

USSSA’s inning rule can be abused the most. A pitcher might get three quick outs in 10 or less pitches. However, if walks, errors and hits factor into an inning, a pitcher can throw many, many more pitches in the same inning. Both types of innings are counted the same by USSSA.

Little League is what’s seen on television in August. They try to explain the pitch count during the broadcast, but it can be complicated. However, counting pitches does a better job of monitoring exactly how hard the youth pitchers are working.

All that’s pretty technical and arguments can be made by all youth organizations for the effectiveness of their pitching rules. The wild card is the coach. Rules can be bent or broken. It can happen anywhere.

A couple of years ago, one night I went from coaching my son’s team to watch my grandson play in a Little League game for 13-16 year olds. Jacob, my grandson, was 13. It was one of the first games he pitched from the major league distance of 60-feet, six-inches.

When I arrived, a parent of the catcher told me Jacob had already thrown over 100 pitches. It was one of his first pitching outings of the season. It broke the Little League rules and the coaches seemed not to care, even though the scorekeeper was keeping track of the pitches.

Fortunately, Jacob came away with no arm damage. However, if this had gone on all season long, who knows what could have happened. It sometimes hits close to home.

One of the best pitchers the area has seen in quite a while had surgery last summer. In 2013, Blake McFadden played a big role during his freshman season at Kansas State. The Wildcats won the Big 12 title. Unfortunately, McFadden missed his entire sophomore year with a fractured elbow. Was it just bad luck?

I have no solution and can’t point the blame at any one factor.

Yesterday, my son, Sam and I watched the movie, Field of Dreams. Can you believe it was made 25 years ago? That movie makes it clear why baseball has such sentimental value to American sport fans.

Football might be the “cash cow” of sports now, but baseball will always be America’s game.

Leave a Comment