Skip to content

Council sends UTV ordinance back to drawing board again

FORUM FILE PHOTO
Maryville Council file public safety building

MARYVILLE, Mo. — Maryville City Council members on Monday rejected a new draft of a utility vehicle ordinance that they felt was too burdensome, sending it back for more revisions.

City Manager Ryan Heiland presented the new draft Monday that incorporated council members’ feedback collected during the Sept. 8 meeting. The new draft lowered the proposed fee for a permit from $250 to $75, removed the requirement for operators and passengers under 18 to wear a helmet, and moved the yearlong permit expiration date from Sept. 30 to Dec. 31. It also included penalties for violating the ordinance, which were not included in the first draft:

  • First offense – Minimum $225 fine
  • Second offense – Minimum $225 fine, UTV permit suspended 90 days
  • Third offense – Minimum $225 fine, UTV permit suspended 1 year
  • Fourth offense – Minimum $225 fine, UTV permit permanently revoked

However, council members were dissatisfied with the new draft, primarily because they felt some of the requirements were too burdensome and sometimes unclear. While council member Erin Allen acknowledged that city staff have been working hard on the ordinance, she told Heiland that she believed he and his staff were intentionally making the requirements needlessly complicated because city staff are against allowing UTVs more widely on city streets.

“I feel like you guys have worked too hard on it, because it seems like we’re trying to get this to where staff, who didn’t want it, is happy with it because they don’t want it,” Allen said. “And I don’t think that’s how we make good policy.”

REQUIRED UTV FEATURES

Note: The below are from a draft ordinance discussed Monday and could change before approval. Not a complete list.

  • Headlights, taillights, brake lights and turn signals
  • Service brake and parking brake
  • Driver’s side mirror and passenger-side or interior rearview mirror
  • Appropriate reflectors
  • Functioning horn
  • Muffler/exhaust system
  • Seat belts or approved restraints for every seating position
  • Manufacturer-installed rollover protection
  • Safe tires
  • Safety glass, windshield or appropriate occupant eye protection
  • All original manufacturer safety equipment
  • Current city permit decal

In August, Heiland said city staff recommended against expanding UTV use, agreeing with the police department. Police Chief Mike Stolte has said that although his officers will implement whatever policies are approved by the council, he believes legalizing widespread UTV use could lead to more injuries or deaths. Additionally, his department will be responsible for not only enforcing regulations that can be difficult to spot on the streets, but also will conduct every inspection required to obtain a permit.

Allen questioned why the permit fee was still as high as $75, though later backed down after the other council members said they had no problem with it. But council members largely agreed with other issues Allen raised. The draft ordinance, for example, specified that any UTV with a suspension modification that materially increased the original ride height or ground clearance would be ineligible for a permit. The ordinance later specifies that increases of three inches or more aren’t allowed.

“So are police following ‘three inches?’ Are they following ‘material increase?’ Are we following ‘modification’ at all?” Allen said. “The state of Missouri doesn’t seem to have very strict restrictions on raising a vehicle, but the city of Maryville seems to have his carveout that’s really important to us — not modifying a UTV.

“And I think it’s pretty common that people put new tires on a UTV to make it more accessible to things that are off-road. I’m concerned that our citizens, for the majority, will have UTVs that exceed this and we’re going to have a problem everywhere.”

OTHER UTV REQUIREMENTS

Note: The below are from a draft ordinance discussed Monday and could change before approval. Not a complete list.

  • Cannot go faster than 30 mph
  • Cannot drive on city street with speed limit higher than 35 mph
  • No passengers in cargo beds or areas not designed for passengers
  • Occupancy limited to manufacturer-designed seating
  • No towing persons, animals, bicycles, skateboards or similar devices
  • All occupants must use manufacturer-designed seating and restraints
  • Child restraints must comply with Missouri law

Council member Bryan Williams, a firefighter and paramedic who has been categorically against an ordinance allowing expanded UTV use because of safety concerns, later said the height restriction is likely because an increase in height could shift the vehicle’s center of gravity and make it more prone to rollovers.

Another issue that staff will tackle is when UTVs are allowed on city streets. The draft ordinance stipulated that UTVs could only be driven between 6 a.m. and 10 p.m. However, Allen said those hours seemed to be arbitrary and wasn’t sure why any time-of-day restriction would be necessary in the first place since the permit process required UTVs to have operational headlights.

Other council members did not seem to have an issue with the time-of-day rules, but seemed to reach a consensus around allowing UTV operation between sunrise and sunset, though not every council member voiced a preference.

Williams, though he reiterated his opposition to any version of the ordinance, pointed out that a common use for UTVs within city limits is for snow removal, which often takes place outside of daylight hours. It was also a specific use that a local property owner asked the council to make explicitly legal during a public comment period in August.

Council members had no solution for that issue. They also had no solution to a problem they had identified last month: The language of the ordinance would not allow golf carts to legally cross any road to the country club.

“I don’t know how we carve out the snow removal, but that is certainly a concern,” said council member Dannen Merrill. “It’s happening now already to probably no major incident, otherwise we would have addressed it previously.

“I don’t like that we necessarily have to just rely on discretion around the country club, but I do agree that it could be pretty hard to carve that out. But that does leave it open to say, ‘Well, if you don’t enforce it there, why does it get enforced elsewhere,’ right? But I don’t have an answer for that, necessarily, just given the way our town lays.”

City staff will now rework the ordinance and bring it back before the council for consideration again at a future meeting.

Strategic goals

Also during Monday’s meeting, the council adopted six strategic goals for FY 2027, which began Oct. 1:

  • Guide strategic growth and housing
  • Strengthen downtown and community destinations
  • Invest in infrastructure and community assets
  • Advance economic development and workforce opportunities
  • Enhance quality of life through parks, recreation, and neighborhoods
  • Deliver high-quality municipal services

Other City Council notes

  • The council approved a $906,166 agreement with Schneider Electric Buildings Americas for HVAC and infrastructure improvements to Mozingo Lake Recreation Park Event Center. In a presentation to the council, Schneider Electric representatives said that a comprehensive audit of the building’s HVAC systems revealed multiple problems with the original construction and installation, resulting in persistent humidity issues in the eight years since the Event Center was built. Part of the problem, city officials said, stemmed from firing the architect late in the process after the original designs resulted in over-budget bids that had to be value engineered.
  • Council members approved a $73,512.80 increase in a contract with White Cloud Engineering and Construction for remaining design-build work on the north RV park expansion at Mozingo, bringing the project total to $683,512.80. White Cloud had originally bid $562,222 to complete the base project, so city staff added an alternate bid option to construct a new two-stall shower house as part of the project that would still come in under the amount approved by the council. However, unexpected cost overruns ballooned the cost. Council member Allen admonished Mozingo Park Director Jordyn Greenhaw and city staff for making the decision to add the shower house without returning to the council. “That is an elected body decision in scope and procurement, and it needs to flow that way,” Allen said. “So I’m supportive of this change; I want to make sure we do better next time.”

Leave a Comment