Skip to content

Column: Jon and Anthony debate 8-man rankings

JON DYKSTRA/THE FORUM
Bo Collins and the Worth County Tigers hoist the championship trophy last fall at Missouri Western.

It was evident the moment last season’s state semifinals ended — there wasn’t going to be much imagination required at the top of the preseason 8-man football poll this year.

Bo Collins is back. Jack Meyerkorth is back. Cole Ruby is back. Brock Holmes is back. Hayden Sanders is back. Gabe Gebhards is back. Jude Archer is back.

Safe to say that Worth County and Rock Port are geared up to make another run at getting to Spratt Stadium.

I’ve run these summer 8-man top-10s for a few years now, but this year is the first that sports editor Anthony Crane and I will go back and forth, and with me releasing my top-10 and Anthony coming back at me on each pick explaining why he agrees or disagrees.

So let’s get started with the defending champions.

1. Worth County (GRC)

Last season: 13-1; state champions

Jon: Its not like the Tigers didn’t lose anyone. Sawyer Thurman, Brayden Stevens, Brayden Combs, Wyatt Hill and Lucas Frisch were all key contributors last season.

The Tigers return six starters and four on defense. Those four on defense include all three of their defensive line and State Defensive Player of the Year Bo Collins, who along with fellow returner Jude Archer, completely wrecked Rock Port in the second half of the state title game.

The offense is loaded with Sanders at quarterback, Archer and Ruby at running back, Caleb New and Collins at tight end. The wild thing is if another team had their second-string skill guys with Brock Healy at quarterback, Archer at running back, and Dylan Smith and Wyatt Scadden at tight end then they’d be a top-10 team on this list.

Anthony: (Worth County #1)

Congratulations to the Tigers on back-to-back state titles. The state is very top heavy this season and Worth County carries most of that weight. When you go position-by-position, the Tigers have very few weaknesses and with that same exercise you’ll find players that a lot of them rank near the top at their position.

Ruby alone makes a good backfield, but as we saw in 2025, the backfield’s depth is better than any we’ve seen over the last few seasons. Defensively they lose pieces, but the head coach knows how to coach a defense and the talent won’t be lacking on that side of the ball even with those losses.

2. Rock Port (275)

Last season: 13-1; state runner-up

Jon: The team with the skill guys at the top-end to match the Tigers are their state finals opponents and Week 1 opponent. Jack Meyerkorth is the best player in the state not named Bo Collins. He’s a basketball player at heart, but that speed and athleticism translates to the football field.

Its a pretty nice luxury when a 2,900-yard rusher is second on the scouting report. Brock Holmes had an incredible season. Wes Amthor is back at quarterback. He threw for 961 yards last season with 721 of those going to Meyerkorth.

The concerns for the Jays are at the line of scrimmage where Ryder Herron is not an easy 270-pound monster to replace. Gabe Gebhards is back, but losing Quentin Jackson and Herron is tough. The Jays depth also is less tested with Holmes accounting for 345 of the team’s 399 rushing attempts.

Anthony: (Rock Port #3)

Ryder Herreon is a big fella and the hole left by him will be even bigger. As Jon pointed out, Holmes carried the ball far too much last season. Take away an all-state level lineman and those carries become a little harder.

Rock Port is going to be very good this season, but I believe they need to become an offense that can go to three-to-four guys if they want to win a state title.

3. North Shelby (CRL)

Last season: 9-3; lost in state quarterfinals

Jon: The fighting Bowens are the safest bet in the state to be undefeated with the playoffs arrive. Gannon Bowen returns after fittingly earning First Team All-State Athlete. Wildly, Bowen led the team in passing and rushing, and finished second in receiving last season.

Bowen is the guy who has an argument with Collins and Meyerkorth as the top returning player in the state. North Shelby lost by just two points to Worth County in the quarterfinals after beating them two years ago in that round.

North Shelby loses most of their statistics around Bowen though with Bo Bacon, TJ Belt and Cole Browning. After seeing Drake Prange in track, I’m predicting a break-out season as a senior.

Anthony: (North Shelby #2)

Gannon Bowen has been the best player in the state for most of his high school career. Few have the ability to do everything on the football field, and he can. Find the best player, and you’ll find the team capable of winning a state title.

The Raiders have also shown the ability to give Worth County all they can handle. The two teams have met in the playoffs in three of the last five seasons with two of the three decided by two points.

North Shelby also loses some talent from 2025, but the mixture of talent in the senior and sophomore classes should fill those holes. If the Raiders stay healthy, it should lead to another great quarterfinal matchup in Grant City this year.

4. Norborne-Hardin Central (CRL)

Last season: 10-1; lost in district championship

Jon: Brody Fifer is back at quarterback for the Aggies and one of those players that many reading this probably haven’t heard of, but he threw for 1,384 yards as a junior and ran for 938 with 45 total touchdowns.

Sam Barnett is back as Fifer’s favorite receiver while Jagger McNelly leads the defense after 101 tackles and 17 tackles for loss this season. Losing guys like Gage Smith, Zach Deitch and Jace McNelly will hurt this season.

With no North Shelby on the schedule, I would predict NHC to run the regular-season table again. Look out for Week 7 against Polo though. I didn’t ranked Polo as a new 8-man school, but the Panthers were a .500 11-man squad last season.

Anthony: (NHC #4)

After the top three, things get really interesting. I really gave this one some thought because I think the talent of Fifer and Nodaway Valley’s Braxton McGinness are about as good as it gets quarterback wise.

But I think the Aggies return enough good talent and coaching to find themselves playing in another district championship game. After last season’s disappointing loss, I think the Aggies come into the season feeling they have something to prove.

5. Nodaway Valley (275)

Last season: 9-2; lost in district championship

Jon: Nodaway Valley had two losses last season, both to Rock Port, but were dominant in their other matchups. As a first-year quarterback, sophomore Braxton McGinness threw for 1,979 yards, 32 touchdowns and five interceptions. He ran for 463 yards and 12 touchdowns.

McGinness’ top-2 receivers are back as well with Tye Hoyt and Jax Cowden. The skill guys match up with any one on this list.

Similarly to 275 rival Rock Port, the Thunder lose their top lineman with Tyler Gray. They also lose their top three tacklers with Dylan Walker, Cooper Snodderley and Gray. McGinness, Hoyt and Cowden is a special group, but the ceiling of this team will be determined in the trenches.

The kids for Rock Port and Nodaway Valley shouldn’t be looking ahead, but just so fans know — Nodaway Valley at Rock Port, Oct. 16.

Anthony: (Nodaway Valley #5)

I don’t think you’ll find a more enjoyable experience watching a quarterback this season than you will watching Braxton. Only Landon Carlson of King City has an argument for being the best dual-threat quarterback in the state.

Tye Hoyt and Cowden make the best duo of receivers in the state. If healthy, the Thunder should have a passing attack that gives them a chance at a 275 title. Jon was somewhat right on the trench talk, but I think that is more about the defense and filling those holes. I think the athleticism on the offense and the fact they won’t see many teams with a lot of size, lessens the blow of those losses on the o-line.

6. Lockwood (WEMO adjacent)

Last season: 11-1; lost in state quarterfinals

Jon: I count Lockwood as a WEMO team even if they technically aren’t and they opened last season with a statement by beating Archie at Archie and that led them and Rock Port to basically be co-No. 1 teams all season. Just like Worth County got its revenge on Rock Port in the title game, Archie’s revenge came in the state quarterfinals.

Lockwood was slated to return its Landry Ogden and Sean Contreras backfield and that led me to rank them No. 4 in my initial rankings, but Devin Albertson reported that Ogden was injured during baseball season and is out. The team is also replacing four linemen including First Team All-Stater Miles Neely.

They return the best 3-headed rushing attack this side of Grant City with Oliver Boehne, Roper Gray and Contreras, but there are enough questions around them to bump out of the top five. Appleton City in Week 1 may tell us a lot before an Archie rematch in Week 2.

Anthony: (Lockwood #8)

Clay Lasater is the best football coach in the state that nobody talks about. Lockwood has won three-straight district titles and they’re the only 8-man team in the state to not have a losing record over the past 15 years.

Lasater is an incredible coach who just unfortunately has had to deal with Jacob Coffey, Briar McIntyre, and Tristan Leeper in his time at the 8-man level.

They’ll be talented again this season, but losing Ogden likely takes them out of contention for a title in 2026. But I expect the Tigers to contend as one of the best teams in the south this season.

(Lasater is also responsible for the best turf in the state)

7. King City (GRC)

Last season: 9-3; lost in district championship

Jon: I know this is higher than Anthony and Devin have the ‘Kats, but we are to the point in the poll where I am betting on players to elevate the cast around them. If you told me that Landon Carlson is the best 8-man quarterback in the state this season, I don’t think I’d be able to argue with you — depending on what position Gannon Bowen plays.

Carlson threw for 1,690 yards with 34 touchdowns and three interceptions while running for 689 yards and 17 touchdowns. So why aren’t the Wildkats higher? Cause Ryder Sample, Josiah Schellhorn and Graham Medsker were really good football players. King City replaces a ton of its supporting cast, but guys like Cayden Wainscott and Jax Jundy do give Carlson some weapons. Lucas Boone will lead the defense as well. The line will be the key, especially if they want to match up with Worth County.

Anthony: (King City not ranked)

Landon Carlson has already drawn the interest of D2 scouts. Carlson has good size, athleticism, and throws the ball well — has all the tools to be one of the best at his position. But outside of the quarterback, the team has far more questions than answers.

8. Mound City (275)

Last season: 7-4; lost in district semifinals

Jon: The Panthers are another purple cat that I am higher on than Devin and Anthony. They dominated everyone in the 275 except Nodaway Valley and Rock Port last season and gave the Thunder all they could handle the first time.

The Panthers lose their offensive leader with running back Creyton Roup, but Henry Smith looked ready to take on that role with his jump at quarterback. Smith threw for 573 yards and ran for 797 last season. He also has his best lineman back with Cade Gillenwater.

The defense returns its top four tacklers with John Gard, Scott Manly, Liam Derr and Gillenwater.

The Panthers have a back-loaded schedule with both Nodaway Valley and Rock Port in October. If they can get through a couple good non-conferences tests with Princeton and Pattonsburg, it could make for a fun finish in the 275.

Anthony: (Mound City NR)

I do not have Mound City ranked at this time, but they’re a team that arguably should be. In a 275 Conference that has Rock Port and Nodaway Valley, the Panthers are certainly in the mix for third in the conference.

Creyton Roup is not a guy you replace easily, but Mound City has always always always managed to run the ball well. It’s just what they do and pretty well across multiple sports.

Welcome to Mound City: Running is Life

9. Archie (WEMO)

Last season: 11-2; lost in state semifinals

Jon: This is the first surprise team for Anthony in these rankings, because I didn’t have them in my initial ones, but after some soul searching, I can’t leave them (and the WEMO) out. They were out cause the list of replacements is wild with Tristan Leeper, Peyton Himes, Tanner Thompson, Joey Dawson and Jackson Kash all gone.

But I predicted a drop off when Briar McIntire went to Missouri Southern as well, but Archie filled the gaps. If they find another McIntire or Leeper, buckle up. But even without a superstar, the Whirlwinds have earned some benefit of the doubt.

With Brecklen Marcks, Carson Houchen and Caden Baker, they have more experience than most in the trenches and that alone is worth a top-10 ranking. Westyn Bryant headlines the potential break-out skill players after 653 yards rushing last season.

Anthony: (Archie #10)

You may not always like them, but you will respect them. The Whirlwinds have been consistent winners since moving to the 8-man level and will be remembered as one of the best programs of this decade.

But regression comes for all dynasties and that’s what Archie will likely see in 2026. It won’t be a massive decline, but they certainly don’t have the high-end talent that we’ve become accustomed to seeing.

10. Concordia (CRL)

Last season: 9-4; lost in state semifinals

Jon: We got all the state semifinalists back in the top 10 with the Orioles rounding out the list. This is another bet on a team losing a lot but returning a guy who could elevate it all. Quarterback Nephi Hon threw for 1,008 yards last season and ran for 674.

He will be asked to do more this season without Lane Hass and Carson Droege beside him, but Aiden Frerking is back as an all-district running back. Brody Roepe and Brayden Frerking return as the team’s top offensive linemen.

Concordia’s defensive stats are famously a little off with the team crediting 151 tackles for loss last season, but Aksel Garcia had 129 tackles, 22 tackles for loss and 11 sacks last year according to the Orioles and will be set up for a big season again.

Concordia doesn’t play a team I have ranked all season, so don’t be surprised to see them rise as the season goes and they stack wins.

Anthony: (Concordia #6)

I know this team lost some really good players from last year’s team as anyone who was at this summer’s 8-man All-Star game could see. But the Orioles have done things the right way since moving down, and that’s building a culture.

It wasn’t immediate, but 26 wins and two district titles over the last three seasons was the fruit of that labor. As for why I have them ranked higher than most? Vibes. The Orioles, by all accounts, were the best team at last week’s camp and their schedule gives them a chance to have a lot of success.

Anthony’s conclusion

Rankings are just educated guesses and with fall camp still yet to start, there are a lot of pieces of the puzzle to sort through. Kids improve, kids quit the team, and injuries almost always play a role.

Where I differed from Jon in the poll was having Appleton City and Knox County in over Mound City and King City.

Another team that has had success since moving down from the 11-man level. Knox County and coach Vannoy have shown the ability to get the most out of their talent and will need to do so once again this season with the graduation of Cooper Clair. Clair was second in the state in rushing from the quarterback position, blessed with speed that few have at the 8-man level.

A player to watch in 2026 is senior Carrsen Hayes. Last season, Hayes finished second on the team with 789 rushing yards and 14 touchdowns, averaging a smidge under six yards per carry.

The Eagles also return their leading receiver and a small stable of younger players who gained some experience rushing the ball last year. Defensively, the team loses its leading tackler but returns its main core with Hayes, Henry, Karhoff, and Vannoy. Those four defenders combined for 266 tackles last season.

This is all to say that Knox County has to replace its best player on both sides of the ball, but the cupboard is far from bare. Like Concordia, the schedule early on will give Vannoy and the team time to figure those things out before matchups with North Shelby (Week 7) and Polo (Week 9).

The Appleton City Bulldogs will look a little different offensively in 2026 with the graduation of Cash Anderson. Anderson was 10th in the state in rushing last season and was the team’s best weapon for most of his high school career.

That position now lands in the hands of junior quarterback Beau Brownsberger. Last season, Brownsberger passed for 1,500 yards and rushed for 912. He’ll likely share the load with fellow junior Brycen James. James was third on the team last season with 393 yards on almost 11 yards per carry.

Most importantly, the team returns one of the best defensive players (possibly the best) in defensive end Weston Farmer. Famer was top 10 in tackles (124), tackles for loss (27), and 12th in sacks with nine.

Leave a Comment