Skip to content

Forum Editorial: Moratorium on data centers is right choice for all

EDITORIAL MUG: Editorial art Vertical

Determining where you stand on the White Cloud Acres data center project comes down to balancing the concerns raised by those against it with the tax benefits. The problem is, we’re working with incomplete information.

Scale Microgrids, the project’s developer, estimates that over the next 35 years, the project will generate more than $1.1 billion in tax revenues at a 50-percent property tax abatement. To be in favor of the data center is to say that the concerns about the data center and accompanying natural gas power plant are outweighed by the money set to be raised.

But at the moment, there is no real plan about what that money will do for us.

Will it all go to regular taxing districts, like fire protection, the township and schools? The county commission has indicated it would like to at least spread the money that would go to schools to all the county school districts. We think that is certainly a reasonable thing to do.

We are, though, in the midst of a historic population decline. In the last U.S. Census, Maryville saw its largest population drop ever, and fewer people were living in Nodaway County than in any Census in history.

What good will seven palatial schools be in 15 years if our population continues to disappear? Who will the best-paid rural teachers in the state be teaching?

It’s no secret where our community is struggling to attract families of the future. Just last year, two studies commissioned by the city of Maryville pointed to a critical lack of affordable housing and an acute lack of childcare options as two of the top issues limiting economic growth in Nodaway County. Without addressing both those issues, it will remain challenging to fill the jobs currently available, much less new ones.

Those are some steep challenges for any community.

Now give that community $1.1 billion.

How much money do we need to do something truly transformative that will secure our county’s future?

If being in favor of the data center means being in favor of transformative revenues for the county, then none of us — whether we oppose the project or cheer it on — should allow anything less than transformative results if the project proceeds.

We believe being in favor of the data center would be a lot more popular prospect if someone, anyone, had a compelling plan to use the projected revenues to put Nodaway County on a better, sustainable path for the future. How many of those challenges could we tackle with half that money? With a third? How much money would we need to fund all the cemeteries in the county for the next century? How much to make Nodaway County the home of the best mental health professionals in the state?

Scale estimates the center will generate more than $336 million in tax revenues over the first five years alone. How quickly could we jumpstart that better, sustainable path?

We face generational problems. So we do not blame those who see the generational opportunity dropping into our collective lap and want to leap at it. But if we are not solving the problems that threaten our future, what does it matter?

That’s why we support a countywide moratorium on data center development, which the county commission is considering.

Even if you are in favor of the data center, our elected officials simply do not have enough time to ensure that we are getting the best deal possible from the richest companies in the world. A moratorium of a reasonable length would give the county time to consider its options and hear from constituents in a less charged manner, and for the developers to clear away much of the ambiguity that has made so many in our county feel they are being left out of the loop on a decision with far-reaching consequences.

Most importantly, a moratorium would give us time to decide what kind of future we want our county to have.

And how we want to get there.


CORRECTION: The original version of this editorial incorrectly stated that property tax revenues go to the ambulance district. That is incorrect. The Forum apologizes for the error.

Leave a Comment