Skip to content

Pearls: Love is not approval

EDITORIAL MUG: Matt Pearl

One summer day years ago – maybe 1985 or 1986 – my mom drove into the driveway with me, my sister, and probably a kid or two she was babysitting. It was a hot day, and the vinyl seats in her 1970 model Chevy Malibu made sitting in the car feel something akin to resting my backside on top of an active volcano.

If ‘Lizzie,’ that old Malibu , had A/C, it hadn’t worked since we owned the vehicle, so the air around those blistering seats was also pretty tropical.

But we were home, and our house had central air conditioning. Finally, I would get to experience mankind’s greatest achievement regarding personal comfort. My agenda was to play outside for the remainder of the morning until lunch, but not before entering the garage-level door of our raised ranch home, strolling through the cool basement, plodding up the stairs, and feeling the cool air on the main floor before heading back out.

‘No,’ Mom said. (She said that all the time.) ‘Just go around the house to the yard if you’re going to play outside.’

I argued, but it didn’t work. ‘I don’t want you fanning the doors and letting a bunch of hot air into the house when all you’re doing is heading back outside anyway. Just go play.’

Insulted, offended – triggered even – I fired back with the line that now evokes jokes, teasing and laughter directed my way even to this day: ‘You don’t like me very much, do you?’ The next message she sent was not verbal, but rather consisted of a quick swat to my backside.

As it turned out, Mom did like me – and it bothered her immensely to have me suggest otherwise. But that spanking I got right outside our garage door let me know that while my mother liked me, at that moment she did not approve of my words.

Today, I again thought of a truth about which I must frequently remind myself: Love is not approval; approval is not love.

I can love you and disapprove of your actions or beliefs. You can agree with everything I write and dislike me as a person. Approval is not the test of our love one for another.

We saw the assassination a few days ago of a prominent political activist, Charlie Kirk. Regarding his views, you might have agreed strongly or disagreed entirely, and that is the most fundamental of your American rights. But chances are, unless you truly do struggle to empathize with the human race, that your heart went out to his family when he was murdered. Your sympathy for his wife and kids does not mean you loved the man – I doubt many (if any) individuals reading that had actually met and spoken with him.

Why is America seeing an uptick in violence toward prominent political figures? It’s a difficult problem with many answers, many aspects of our existence that we ought to explore. But I firmly believe that we have seen a mistaken conflation between love and approval. On the one side, we have those who believe that if we love someone, we must instantly approve of all aspects of their lives, all layers of their choices. And what’s the other side of that coin?

That we must hate anyone whose actions do not meet our approval.

Can we not see how isolating and polarizing the social media age of politics has caused us to be in our thinking? Will we ever return to a time when we debate issues without hatred, or continue to love those whose views don’t meet with our approval?

Do those of us with significant years of pre-smartphone living remember how important it was, if you were going to argue a political point to read up on the issue and know the major points of your argument? Now none of us has to know anything: we read a social media post we like, we generally skip any fact-checking, and we repost it as if we were experts on policy.

So the arguments break out more quickly and with higher frequency. We become polarized more easily. We divide more clearly.

Is this what we want? Is this what our freedoms have purchased for us – expanded opportunities to hate each other more quickly? I hope not. I pray not.

Matt Pearl owns and operates The Tri-County Ledger.

Leave a Comment