Column: Why my preseason MIAA poll is the way it is

Skye Pournazari
Jon Dykstra Managing Editor The Maryville Forum
I’ve given you all this speech before, but I’ll do it again. If I’m voting in a poll, I better be able to explain my vote.
I obviously understand why this gets released on the morning of MIAA Media Day, but I always look back on it afterwards with my opinions slightly different based on what the coaches say and, honestly, some unspoken vibes.
This gets more difficult every season with the transfer portal, but here’s my ranking going into the season.
1. Central Oklahoma
Last season: 12-2; 8-1 MIAA
Coaches: 1; Media: 2
The Bronchos are an example of how the transfer portal changing a team significantly at any time. Terrill Davis (1,609 yards, 15 touchdowns) was the best receiver in the country last season and remained a Broncho until April 9. After announcing his intent to transfer, he was quickly scooped up by Oklahoma State.
Despite not having Davis, the offense is still loaded with unanimous First Team All-MIAA running back Jaylen Cottrell and Second Team All-MIAA quarterback Jett Huff. Tulsa transfer Ashton Schumann is a name to watch in his second year in Edmond after 731 yards and seven touchdowns as a freshman last season. The team also added Arkansas transfer Emmanuel Crawford at running back.
The defense is what held UCO back last season, but with the return of First Team All-MIAA linebacker Jack Puckett and Third Team All-MIAA linebacker Connor Johnson, that unit should improve.
2. Fort Hays State
Last season: 8-3; 6-3 MIAA
Coaches: 3; Media: 3
Fort Hays State was among the best teams in the country last season once Caleb Heavner took over as the team’s starting quarterback. In six starts to end the season, Heavner and the Tigers went 5-1 with the lone blemish being a 1-point loss at Pittsburg State. The wins included a 36-7 thrashing at Emporia State and a 31-21 win over Central Missouri.
Heavner threw for 1,649 yards last year with 13 touchdowns and only two interceptions. The 6’2, 220-pound quarterback ran for 353 yards and five touchdowns.
The Tigers are replacing their running back Shane Watts and top receiver Jayden Horace, but return their next two receivers with Jabari Lewis and Ryan Allen as well as one of D-II’s top tight ends in Cale Cormaney.
Defensively, Chris Brown is one of the top defensive coaches in the MIAA and linebacker John Johnson returns to lead that unit. Defensive lineman Parrish Terry earned Third Team All-MIAA as a freshman in 2023, but the 6’6, 245 pound defensive end suffered a season-ending injury in the fourth game last season. He returns this season.
3. Pittsburg State
Last season: 8-3; 7-2 MIAA
Coaches: 2; Media: 1
Boy, the Tom Anthony era in Pittsburg started with a bang. All eyes in Division-II were on Pittsburg in Week 0 last season as Ferris State visited The Jungle. The Gorillas flexed on the Bulldogs in a 19-3 win.
That propelled Pittsburg State to a third-straight playoff appearance, but they were rudely dispatched in the first round by Harding, 48-3, in The Jungle. Ferris State responded from Week 0 and won their third national title in four seasons.
Now Pittsburg State has some holes to fill. Quarterback Chad Dodson Jr.: gone. Running back Noah Hernandez: gone. Top receiver Jack Roberts: gone. Linebacking trifecta and top three tacklers Jack Barkley, Alex Gaskill and Thomas Cook: gone.
The Gorillas will look different. The key returners offensively are running back Cleo Chandler Jr. (483 yards, 4 touchdowns) and wide receiver Kuron Parchmon (502 yards, 3 touchdowns).
Defensively, the Gorillas have the best secondary in the country. Senior corner Jaylen Fuksa had 13 pass breakups last season while Antione Nunn Jr. is back for a sixth season — after injuries have derailed him following an MIAA-leading five interceptions in 2023. Kristian Cross also returns after an All-MIAA honorable mention campaign. The safety duo is elite with All-MIAA First Teamer Jordan Rogers combining for 10 interceptions the last two years and Ryan Medeiros back with him.
By the way, the first four weeks for the Gorillas — at Ferris State, at Central Oklahoma, versus Grand Valley State and versus Fort Hays State. We are going to learn a lot about the Gorillas real quick.
4. Northwest Missouri State
Last season: 6-5; 5-4 MIAA
Coaches: 6; Media: 5
I try not to be a homer with this stuff — in fact, it more often than not goes the other way in an effort to overcompensate. Northwest, by its standards, was a disaster last year, missing the playoffs for a second-straight season.
They were also very young, which is why — to my surprise — they return as much as anyone in the league in terms of statistics outside of Central Oklahoma and Fort Hays State.
Offensively, senior quarterback Chris Ruhnke is back after 2,848 yards and 19 touchdowns as a first-year starter. Top receiver Luke Mathews returns after 727 yards last season. Senior running back Jadon Brady is back after an injury-plagued last two seasons. The offensive line returns three starters.
Turnovers plagued the offense last season and reducing those will be the key with new coach John McMenamin taking over.
Defensively, the strength is up the middle with Clayton Power and Nile Schuett anchoring the defensive line, Parker Bowen and All-MIAA First Teamer Carter Edwards are back at linebacker and the safety duo of Shane Fredrickson and Holden Zigmant also return. Building out the defensive line rotation and figuring out a new corner room will be the key for new play-caller Chad Bostwick.
5. Central Missouri
Last season: 9-3, 6-3 MIAA
Coaches: 4; Media: 4
Things I know about UCM: No one has been better calling an offense than Josh Lamberson the past two years. No one has been better than Rich Wright at calling a defense the last decade and a half.
Things I don’t know about UCM: Who is going to be running those plays.
This is where the coaches have the advantage in these preseason polls. They know a lot more than the media does when it comes to who snagged the best recruits and transfers.
One thing I’m fairly certain about is that the next quarterback at Central Missouri will not be to the caliber of Zach Zebrowski, a two-time Harlon Hill winner. Lamberson will have to adjust there while also breaking in a load of new faces around him.
The defense in Warrensburg has been a punchline in recent years, but Lamberson went back to his Northwest roots and brought in Wright to try solve the problem. It will take time for Wright to get his system rolling like it was in Maryville, but there is not a better hire that Lamberson could have made.
Fifth in the league feels right with all the mystery here, but if Lamberson and Wright have the pieces, this could easily be way too low.
6. Emporia State
Last season: 7-4; 5-4 MIAA
Coaches: 5; Media: 6
We remain in the ‘I can’t put this coach any lower’ portion of the rankings. Emporia State also had a lot of turnover this offseason, but Garin Higgins has been doing this for two decades for a reason and it’s because the man can coach some football — specifically offensive football.
Higgins will be breaking in a brand-new quarterback again this season with both his signal callers gone. He is replacing a First Team All-American wide receiver and his three-year starter at running back.
But Higgins always finds a way. Junior receiver Trenden Collins appears poised to be a star after 76 catches for 791 yards and four scores as Tyler Kahlman’s partner in crime last season.
Everyone will be wondering about the quarterback and Higgins has a pair of Division-I transfers in Ben Harris and Todd Drummond.
Defense is always the question for the Hornets. Junior defensive back Tyler Schultze is back after finishing third on the team in tackles last season, but it will be a new look on that side of the ball.
7. Nebraska-Kearney
Last season: 5-6; 3-6 MIAA
Coaches: 8; Media: 7
The Lopers were the surprise of the MIAA last season with a 5-win season. I’m sure coach Ryan Held has higher aspirations than a 3-6 conference mark, but the growth the program showed in his second year at the helm was impressive nonetheless.
The engine of most of that offensive success is back with senior running back Isaiah Harris (Second Team All-MIAA) after a 825-yard, 8-touchdown season.
The defense loses its engine with one of the MIAA and nation’s breakout stars in unanimous First Team All-MIAA defensive end Quillan Felton. The departure of Q leaves some more questions throughout the defense.
The Lopers have plenty of changes this season, but with the upstart season a year ago, Held is another coach who has earned the benefit of the doubt.
8. Missouri Western
Last season: 4-7; 2-7 MIAA
Coaches: 7; Media: 8
The Griffons lost six of their final seven MIAA contests last season, but that was deceiving at times. They played an overtime game against Central Oklahoma, lost by one to Nebraska-Kearney, and lost one-score games to Washburn and Emporia State.
They upset Central Missouri. But when three of your four wins are Northeastern State by two, Missouri Southern by eight and Quincy by 15, coach Tyler Fenwick knows he has work to do.
Quarterback Branden Berwald played well for stretches last season in Western’s competitive losses and in the win over the Mules.
There may not be a player in the MIAA who more neutral fans are pulling for than Brandon Hall. The running back came to Western in 2020 and won MIAA Freshman of the Year despite sharing the backfield with future All-American Shen Butler-Lawson Jr., but Hall was easily the more effective player with 93 carries for 627 yards while Butler-Lawson had 100 for 427 before transferring to Minnesota State where he ran for 1,446 yards and 16 scores.
Hall hasn’t been able to reach his freshman season numbers as injuries have derailed him. Last year, he appeared to be back on track with 67 carries for 557 yards in four games, but he never got to play a fifth with a season-ending injury.
If the Griffons get a healthy Hall, the entire ceiling for the offense shifts.
Defensively, cornerback Desmond Green is as good as there is in the MIAA. Linebacker Kienen Gaskin was a leader for that unit on the second level.
9. Washburn
Last season: 3-8; 2-7 MIAA
Coaches:9; Media: 9
The Ichabods are another mystery for me in Year 1 under Zach Watkins.
Keller Hurla made three starts and split time at quarterback. He threw for 812 yards and five touchdowns while running for 332 yards and five more touchdowns.
Junior receiver D.J. Bell was electric as a freshman, but had his numbers cut in half last season. He will be looking for a bounce back.
The defense returns its top three tacklers from last season with safety Jordan Finnesy, linebacker L.J. Minner Jr. and defensive back Julius Jackson.
The Ichabods have talent and are not in a dissimilar situation to the other team with a new head coach up in Maryville. But while last season was disappointing for the Bearcats, it got off the rails for the Ichabods.
Watkins will have the opportunity to re-energize a proud program in Topeka, but it is hard to predict a 1-year fix.
10. Missouri Southern
Last season: 2-9; 1-8 MIAA
Coaches: 10; Media: 10
Speaking of not a ‘1-year fix.’ Atiba Bradley has made tremendous strides in Joplin, but last season was an unquestioned step back.
The Lions currently have three quarterbacks on their roster, a remarkably low number for a college program. One has taken a snap at Southern with senior Isaac Kittrell throwing eight passes in 2023 and not taking a snap last year. Chris Donohue is a transfer from Assumption where he was 19-for-47 in 2023 with one touchdown and four interceptions. Logan-Rogersville product Thessen Prenger has yet to take a snap.
Similar to Brandon Hall at Western, injuries have unfortunately defined the last couple years for Southern running back Nathan Glades. He ran for 737 yards as a freshman and 855 as a sophomore, but injuries plagued his junior season and caused him to miss 2024 entirely. The rushing attack could be powerful with his return alongside top rushers from last season Victor Chionuma and De’Shawn Larson.
Draper Parker leads the receiver group after 744 yards and five touchdowns as a junior.
Linebacker Colton Bass and defensive backs Mason Rumsey and Diego Oliver return as the team’s top tacklers last season.

