COLUMN: Five things I want to see from the McMenamin first year

Skye Pournazari
Jon Dykstra Managing Editor The Maryville Forum
Coaching changes around Northwest Missouri State are a rarity and when they do happen, it has usually been due to a promotion or retirement. That wasn’t the case last November when the Bearcats moved on from coach Rich Wright, who had been on staff for 21 seasons — serving under Mel Tjeerdsma and Adam Dorrel before becoming the head coach.
In December, former Bearcat quarterback John McMenamin was named Wright’s successor.
The advantage that McMenamin walks in with is that the program is far from broken. The remarkable playoff streak ended two seasons ago, but the winning-record streak goes back to 1994, the first year of the Tjeerdsma era — essentially the modern era of Bearcat football.
This is the first coaching change for Northwest during this transfer-portal, NIL era. Transfers have become common place even without coaching changes, but it feels automatic now when the guy who recruited them moves on. McMenamin and his staff did a good job keeping a lot of the core of the returners, but it is naturally a very new roster.
So what should fans be wanting to see out of the first year of the McMenamin era? Here are my top five keys for a successful 2025.
5. Elite play in the middle of the defense
Despite the struggles of last season overall, the Northwest defense still led the MIAA comfortably (by 33 yards a game) in total defense. They were the only unit in the conference to allow less than 300 yards per game.
The returning strength of that unit is right up the middle, led by First Team All-MIAA linebacker Carter Edwards. Parker Bowen is another returning starter on the second level.
The unit returns both starting safeties with Shane Fredrickson and Holden Zigmant. On the line, Nile Schuett and Clayton Power are the most experienced returners.
The spine of the defense should allow some of the youth around it to grow under first-year play-caller Chad Bostwick.
Continuing to build up defensive line depth will be important as it was always a strength under Wright, but former Bearcat national champion defensive lineman Roberto Davis will have the opportunity to continue that after serving on Wright’s staff since 2021 after coming back to Maryville from Wayne State where he worked under McMenamin.
4. Easy buttons for the quarterback
Chris Ruhnke was loyal. With a completely new offensive staff and with the harsh criticism from fans at points last season, it seemed unlikely that the 2,848-yard passer from last season would chose to be back in Maryville from an outside perspective, but Ruhnke has a previous relationship with McMenamin and the new coach was able to keep last season’s QB1 in town.
They also kept young quarterbacks Hayden Jay, Cael Turner and Zechariah Owens, but added to the room with junior Mason Shorb and freshmen Trevor Grant and Kelan Bohlen.
That makes for a lot of competition in the fall as McMenamin was very clear at the end of the spring that he wasn’t naming a starter any time soon.
Ruhnke’s numbers were good last season and the Bearcats also return his favorite target with Luke Mathews, but interceptions and untimely mistakes derailed the Bearcat offense too many times last season.
Ruhnke or whoever the quarterback is will need to cut down on the 14 interceptions from last year and that is an entire offense stat, but it starts with play calling and putting whoever it is in position to succeed. McMenamin has proven he can do that.
As the pass-game coordinator at Tulane, he helped Michael Pratt lead the team to a 12-2 record while throwing for 3,000 yards with 27 touchdowns and only five interceptions. In 2022, Nick Bohn led Wayne State to a 9-4 record with 2,246 yards, 19 touchdowns and 6 interceptions — after 1,921 yards, 14 touchdowns and five interceptions as a freshman.
At Central Missouri, it was Brook Bolles, who threw for 4,290 yards, 42 touchdowns and 15 interceptions as a senior and 3,766 yards, 23 touchdowns and 12 interceptions as a junior. He had Garrett Fugate throw for 3,657 yards, 31 touchdowns and nine interceptions as a senior and 2,613 yards, 18 touchdowns and six interceptions as a junior. In 2018 when Bolles was hurt in the season opener, McMenamin took backups Kyle Bradley and Jeremy Hunt and they combined for 2,988 yards, 26 touchdowns and 10 interceptions. After McMemamin left, Bradley had a chance to start and threw for 441 yards, two touchdowns and four interceptions before conceding the starting spot.
Fugate, Bohn, Pratt and Bolles all became All-Conference quarterbacks under McMenamin while Fugate and Bolles earned All-American honors.
Whoever the quarterback is should have the chance to continue McMemamin’s terrific run of quarterbacks.
3. Offensive line growth
Northwest finished eighth in the MIAA in rushing offense last year — only ahead of Missouri Southern and Emporia State. They were tied for sixth in sacks allowed.
The offensive line was clearly a priority for McMenamin when he was hired. From the beginning, it was obvious that McMenamin would be coaching quarterbacks and calling plays himself. That left the offensive coordinator role to be a non-traditional one without play-calling.
And maybe this is just my way of thinking and not reality, but when I saw the hiring and knew that, I told people, they should use that offensive coordinator title to lure the best offensive line coach they can — because I believe that if you have a good quarterback and offensive line, the rest of the offense takes care of itself.
Maybe I’m not as crazy as previously thought, because McMenamin went out and got Collin Prosser, who was the offensive coordinator and offensive line coach at Wayne State and before that the held both titles at different points at Minnesota State.
Prosser does not inherit an empty roster as Wes Merriman, Harrison Merriman and Ewan Mills all have experience on the interior. Jack Gogue has starting experience at tackle and Pierce Wand was another part of the two-deep all last season.
They have plenty of new faces coming in as well to challenge for spots. Finding the right five and growing that group will determine this offenses ceiling in Year 1.
2. Keep the defensive identity
Scott Bostwick, Rich Wright and Chad Bostwick — if there was a Mount Rushmore of Bearcat defense, despite two of those men not playing a snap on it, they would surely be on it.
Scott Bostwick built the defense that helped turn the program around in the Tjeerdsma years then named Wright his successor as defensive coordinator. Wright took that defense to as high as levels as has been seen in Division-II while working under Adam Dorrel. The defense has not been the problem even during the recent downturn in wins and losses.
Now Chad Bostwick, who has coached at Northwest and waited for 15 years, gets his chance to call the defense. The former Bearcat linebacker was the co-defensive coordinator under Wright, but Wright called the plays.
The evidence of the talent of the defensive staff was on display last season with long-time defensive backs coach Brandon Clayton going to run the defense at Saginaw Valley State and turning that unit into the third best defense in the GLIAC, only behind Grand Valley State and Ferris State. They were the best run defense in that conference, a long time staple of Bearcat defenses.
It is impossible for a first-time defensive play-caller to have a better resume coming in than Bostwick does. Now, he gets his shot.
1. Align Bearcat Nation
The Northwest social media feeds became a toxic place to look the last couple seasons. The anger for a group not used to losses was clear and most of the frustration was taken out on Wright.
The anger toward Wright, which got fairly dark at times, justifiably angered Wright’s friends, former players and people that just hated that his family had to deal with that. So anger was the theme on both sides of the debate — as is the case with most things these days.
When Wright was fired, those social media complaints didn’t go away with many turning towards the administration either advocating for Wright or just complaining in general as the basketball season didn’t continue to spoil the fanbase.
Social media is the loudest and often times minority of fans, but it is a key for McMenamin in Year 1 as so much about college football, even at the Division-II level, has become a game of who has resources. For years, Northwest had more resources than most, in large part due to the fans.
That is not the case anymore currently as the NIL era continues to envelop college football everywhere. But Northwest is attempting to close that gap with some of the big spenders, and fan engagement drives that.
That doesn’t necessarily mean NIL contributions, but it needs to start with full stadiums on Saturdays.
If McMenamin’s crew can accomplish 2-5 on this list, fun football should follow and No. 1 should take care of itself, but step one from the fanbase is uniting behind the vision.

