Forum Editorial: Take a lesson from McCollum – exercise patience

EDITORIAL MUG: Editorial art Vertical
Minnesota State men’s basketball coach Matt Margenthaler said it last year when his team beat Ben McCollum’s Bearcats in the regional final on a last-second shot, “We don’t want to play like that, they do. They’ve been successful doing that. I wouldn’t even want to coach that.”
He and his players then burst into laughter and he continued, “I wouldn’t. I wouldn’t. That’s not fun for me. I’m just telling the truth. I know you (talking to guard Kyreese Willingham) wouldn’t be here if I coached that way.”
‘That way’ worked well for McCollum with an unprecedented three-straight national titles at the Division II level and now in his first season at Division-I, has the best season in Drake history with a 30-3 record and the intense loyalty of four players — Bennett Stirtz, Mitch Mascari, Daniel Abreu and Isaiah Jackson — who followed him to Drake and all started on the Missouri Valley regular-season and tournament champions.
While Margenthaler’s comment comes off as disrespectful to what McCollum has done and its highly unlikely anyone around the Northwest program would ever want McCollum to take advice from Margenthaler, the question exists — is McCollum a one-of-one at the Division II level.
Statistics say, absolutely. No coach at the Division II level has ever accomplished three national titles in a row. No Drake coach has ever won 30 games in a season, in fact none had won 29 either.
McCollum was a once-in-a-generation coach for the Bearcats and they are very unlikely to ever have another with his resume — which is fine because no one else in Division II will either.
That left one of McCollum’s closest friends, Director of Athletics Andy Peterson, with an impossible task — find McCollum’s successor.
The staff consisted of two very young coaches with former players Xavier Kurth and Jaran Richman, who both eventually ended up staying loyal to McCollum and going to Drake. So an in-house hire was out of the equation.
Other recent McCollum assistants during the championship years were Austin Meyer, who told the Forum early in the process that he was very happy as the Bearcat women’s basketball coach and wasn’t looking to change jobs, and Zach Schneider, who got out of coaching after his run at Northwest and also told the Forum he wasn’t interested in a return.
That left Peterson with a decision. Try to copy a one-of-one coach’s style or just look for the coach that the former Northwest player and coach himself feels is the best coach.
Peterson opted for the latter — hiring a coach who’s motto is ‘Play F.A.S.T.’ Just as Peterson had an inevitable job, Matt Keeley’s was even harder. He inherited a roster built for McCollum’s deliberate pace with all five starters from the previous season gone.
The transfer window had also already been open for some time when he took the position, so the talent pool was limited.
While Keeley will tell anyone, he didn’t expect this season to go as poorly from a wins and losses perspective as it did, it shouldn’t have been as surprising as it did. Peterson and Keeley embarked on a strategy to completely change the style of the greatest dynasty in Division II basketball’s history.
It is a calculated risk with the inarguable premise that nobody does Ben McCollum’s style as well or anywhere close to as well as Ben McCollum. Margenthaler stated that loud and clear for everyone to hear.
Peterson could have tried to find a coach with a similar style to McCollum, but that hire would never be McCollum and while it may have been more successful with McCollum’s returning recruits in Year 1, as Margenthaler and Willingham said a year ago, it is hard for anyone to recruit to that style if you aren’t Ben McCollum.
Keeley is losing seven players off this season’s roster — at a minimum as the transfer portal continues to churn. The Bearcats undeniably started from the ground floor this year with a skyscraper in the rear-view mirror.
As the roster becomes more ‘Play F.A.S.T.’-centric, the next few years will determine if Keeley and Peterson’s risk will pay dividends, but judging a transition like that based on one year was always going to pale in comparison to the past.
The Bearcats will be looking to play fast moving forward, but Bearcat fans need to take a page from McCollum’s playbook and look for the best shot, not the first shot.
