Skip to content

Column: Where do Bearcats find their coaches?

Skye Pournazari
Jon Dykstra Managing Editor The Maryville Forum

When the men’s basketball and baseball head coaching jobs open up in the same year, Northwest Missouri State fans will all have the tendency to become amateur search firms and have their personal wishlist of candidates.

Northwest and Director of Athletics Andy Peterson eventually settled on men’s basketball coach Matt Keeley and baseball coach Tony Jandron as the new leaders for each program. While the reception for each was overwhelmingly positive as fans got to know the hires, the initial response among many of the diehard fans whenever a hire is made seems to usually be — ‘Who?’

That ‘who’ is driven by the candidates that the Bearcats select. Of the 10 head coaches currently, four were promoted from within the university, two were head coaches at the NAIA level, two were Division-I assistant coaches without head coach experience, one was a Division-II co-head coach and one was a head coach at an MIAA program.

The head coach that Northwest plucked from Central Missouri is Mark Rosewell, who was hired as the Bearcat head tennis coach in 1984. While Rosewell has been incredibly successful and is a Bearcat legend, the state of hiring in college athletics has changed a lot in the past 40 years, so Rosewell’s hiring doesn’t apply much for this year’s searches.

Hiring from within

Northwest’s hires from within the athletic department are football’s Rich Wright, women’s basketball’s Austin Meyer, women’s golf’s Andy Peterson and volleyball’s Amy Woerth.

Wright and Meyer were internal candidates with suitors across the country. They provided the easiest of decisions for Mel Tjeerdsma, Peterson’s predecessor, as they were top assistants for national title teams.

Tjeerdsma also hired Peterson to lead the golf program. The lone internal hire that wasn’t by Tjeerdsma was the decision of Wren Baker in 2012 to make interim head coach Amy Woerth, the full time coach. Since then, Woerth has become the all-time winningest coach in the program’s history and a 2-time MIAA Coach of the Year.

Woerth didn’t have a winning MIAA season until her fifth season in 2016 and since then, they haven’t had a losing season in league play and won the MIAA Championship in 2022.

First-time head coaches

Peterson has made four head coaching hires since becoming the Director of Athletics. Three of those are first-time head coaches — Brandon Masters, Naomi Tellez and Jandron.

Masters and Tellez have proven to be stellar hires.

The resurgence of the track and field program under Masters has been obvious with two top-10 indoor programs this season and two top-15 outdoor programs. The Bearcats have had at least one national champion in the last five NCAA Division-II National Championships.

Tellez hasn’t had national success yet, but has been showing growth in the program through her first three years. In her first year, the team was 15-36, but have won 28 games in each of the last two years — a win total that hadn’t been reached since 2017.

Rising from the NAIA ranks

During the search for a men’s basketball coach, Peterson said that Northwest was looking for someone with previous head coaching experience — a change from his previous hires, but a method that has been proven to work for Northwest in the past.

Tjeerdsma’s final head-coaching hire was soccer’s Marc Gordon, who Northwest plucked from NAIA Ottawa University (Kansas). The Bearcats won two matches in his first year, six in his second season before breaking out with 34 over the last three seasons and the first two NCAA Tournament appearances in school history.

Peterson followed that model with the men’s basketball search and ended up landing another Ottawa University — but the one in Arizona — product Matt Keeley.

Best path?

What Northwest has proven over the years is that all these models have the ability to work. Not ruling out any path to find the right candidate has been the right way.

The truth is that the Bearcats currently have the winningest volleyball coach in program history, the only coach to ever lead a soccer team to the postseason, a track and field coach setting new high standards each season, a women’s basketball coach who brought the team back to the NCAA Tournament for the first time since 2011, and a seven-time regional tennis coach of the year.

The athletic department is as healthy as it’s ever been across sports and Northwest has time and again proven the ability to find program-builders across sports. Time will tell with the most recent hires of Keeley and Jandron, but history indicates that fans should be confident.

Leave a Comment