Skip to content

Scammer captured, returned to Maryville

NODAWAY COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE
Jeffrey T. Rogers

MARYVILLE, Mo. — Convicted forger Jeffrey Thomas Rogers, 57, of St. Louis, was arraigned in the Fourth Circuit Court on Friday morning in Nodaway County and is currently housed in the local jail due to felony charges surrounding a theft of more than $11,000 from a local auction held in early November.

Rogers has been charged with class D felony stealing $750 or more, class D felony forgery and Class E felony passing a bad check.

Detectives Sgt. Adam James and Sgt. Ryan Glidden with the Maryville Police Department have been working with law enforcement from throughout the state and the Midwest to identify Rogers, whom they allege has used multiple sets of fake identification with different names and the same photo in order to steal coins and precious metals from auctions and estate sales.

“We have linked him and helped agencies in Iowa, Illinois, Tennessee to get criminal charges on him,” Glidden told The Forum on Friday.

Working with the Missouri State Highway Patrol, the Aurora (Missouri) Police Department and the Greene County Sheriff’s Office in Springfield to set up a sting operation, Rogers was taken into custody and extradited to Maryville.

According to the probable cause statement, James wrote that during the “Alloway Coin Auction,” held at Younger Auction, Rogers won 18 lots containing various precious metals and coins worth $11,880. Some of those items included: a 1908 Double Eagle $20 gold piece valued at $2,900, a 1908 Double Eagle gold piece valued at $3,100, a 2005 $25 Gold Eagle First Strike valued at $1,550, a 2019 $25 Gold Eagle coin valued at $2,000 and 10, 1-ounce fine silver bars valued at $450.

During Rogers’ time in Maryville, he was caught on video outside the auction business and at another local business getting into the passenger side of a vehicle, which James wrote in the PC statement indicates a second person involved.

While at the second business (likely Casey’s on South Main Street, according to the probable cause statement), the second person entered a phone number into the business’s system to accumulate reward points. After receiving that phone number and finding the location from which it hailed, James said he contacted police in Aurora, Missouri, and began the process of identifying the suspect.

“I mean, it’s obvious who it is,” James told The Forum on Friday.

Glidden explained that they began sending out information all over the Midwest through “fusion centers” which help distribute information to law enforcement.

“Then we started getting information,” he said.

Law enforcement agencies from Tennessee, Iowa and Illinois reached out and are working with MPD for identification and to bring their own criminal charges for crimes those agencies believe Rogers was also responsible for.

As the local investigation continued, James said they were able to deduce the bad check passed in Maryville originally belonged to an account of Rogers’ late stepfather, James Smith, and mother, which had been closed after Smith’s death. Because of this, the check was unable to be cashed by the auction business and is what originally kicked off the local investigation.

Since then, James has learned of at least four other checks written from Rogers’ stepfather’s account. One was written in Illinois for $20,300 for coins and precious metals. A photo from that event allegedly linked Rogers. Another check was written at an Iowa auction in the amount of $10,267.50 for coins and precious metals. Two other checks were written in Republic, Missouri, at a grocery store and an auto parts store.

Glidden said that the charges for those checks are also felonies and eventually Rogers will face extradition to face them, too.

“So he essentially would be making his way through the criminal process for some time,” he said. “We’re talking four states at the moment here.”

According to the probable cause statement, Rogers has at least 16 convictions for forgery between 2004 and 2022. His three most recent felony convictions were for stealing on July 8, 2022, theft of property $5,000 to $25,000 in June 2017 and identity theft in February 2017.

“Sometimes I don’t think that the people in the community realize what comes and goes out of our community and he’s a prime example,” Glidden said. “He showed up, committed his crime — which is pretty extensive — and was just gone. He’s been in prison for this before and he knows what he’s doing.”

According to court documents, Rogers is currently on parole through the Missouri Department of Corrections for stealing $750 or more and forgery and on field supervision through August 2024.

As a prior and persistent offender, Rogers could be punished with an extended term of imprisonment having been found guilty of two or more felonies committed at different times, noted online court documents.

The range of punishment for a class D felony is imprisonment in the custody of the state Department of Corrections from 1 to 7 years or a fine not to exceed $10,000 or both.

The range of punishment for a class E felony is imprisonment in the custody of the state Department of Corrections from 1 to 4 years or a fine not to exceed $10,000 or both.

Rogers’ bond review hearing is scheduled for 9 a.m. on Tuesday, Feb. 20, in Judge Robert Rice’s courtroom.

Leave a Comment