My Point Exactly: Let the river be what it is

My Point Exactly: Let the river be what it is
It’s not a popular view to hold in row crop country, but the facts become plainer with each flood year along the 2,000-mile-long Missouri River Valley, a region embracing more than a half-million square miles.
It’s time to let the Missouri River be what it is, an unstoppable force of nature that will defeat all human efforts to tame it.
The Missouri flooded during six of the last 10 years, three times in 2019 alone. Flood damage for the year along more than 500 miles of river valley will cost billions of dollars to fix. There was reportedly $1 billion worth of damage to levees alone, many of which are still under repair.
And while farm-belt politicians and farmers pooh-pooh the notion, the lion’s share of river management professionals, planners, engineers and scientists — people who peg their careers to verifiable and repeatable research rather than finger-pointing — predict that continued frequent and severe flooding is a good bet going forward.
Farmers with land along the river, and residents and business owners in the mostly small towns dotting the valley, place the blame on environmental activism. They particularly fault the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers for supposedly favoring policies emphasizing wildlife preservation over production agriculture.
That’s nonsense. The Missouri floods because the Corps and other entities have sought to dam and levee it into submission, not the other way around. Attempts to dam, channel, narrow, shorten and control the river have been going on since the late 19th century and roared into high gear during the 1950s. Yet flooding continued and worsened. Recently what used to be classed as a 100-year deluge occurs about every other year.
The biannual devastation ought to speak for itself. We’re living in a new reality when it comes to climate, and all the dams and levees in the world won’t change that.
A while back the Omaha World-Herald reported that such increasingly common events as “bomb cyclones” and record snow runoff have drastically swollen flow volumes well beyond the capacity of what is already a massive amount of infrastructure.
In more than 120 years of record keeping, four of the highest Missouri River runoff years have occurred during the past decade. We can dam and levee to our heart’s content, but a growing number of banking and insurance interests are joining scientists in realizing that no amount of dirt and concrete is going to stop the next “100-year flood.”
I know this angers farmers, who have become fond of suing the Army Corps and issuing headline-friendly ultimatums like “farms not fish.” Having grown up in an old farm family that lost its land, I’m sympathetic to the real pain, emotional and financial, those who work the fields suffer when they have to give up even an acre of black dirt, let alone hundreds of thousands of acres.
But it is what it is. We can control Missouri River flooding, but only by allowing the river to be a river, not a giant drainage ditch. The Missouri must be allowed to recreate its old channels, slews, towheads, oxbows, lowland timber stands and wetlands. That is the only approach that will temper the kind of massive devastation we’ve seen over the past decade.
It defies common sense to say widening the river causes more flooding. We’ve been narrowing the river since at least the 1940s, and the incidence of devastating floods has only increased.
The Missouri is 30 to 50 percent narrower today than it was 150 years ago. We channeled it not to save farmland, but to create acreage that never should have been put into production in the first place.
I am not suggesting that all artificial flood control is bad. The carefully engineered use of dams and levees is prudent and feasible. But given the high odds of continued multi-billion-dollar disasters, allowing the Missouri to reclaim a few hundred thousand acres of bottomland as a buffer is a small price to pay.
It will be painful. Towns will have to move or even die, and a fair number of farms will shrink or cease to exist. But that’s going to happen anyway as banks, insurers and the government finally decide to quit throwing good money after bad.
In its report, the World-Herald quoted Robert Criss, a Washington University hydrologist, who said — much better than I can — that the real problem is our failure to learn to live with the river in all its complexity and power.
“We are fighting the natural (tendencies) of the river,” Criss said. “We might as well fight the craters on the moon.”
Anthony Brown is a retired newspaper reporter and editor who lives in Maryville. His column appears in the Forum four times each month
© Anthony Brown, 2020. All rights reserved.
