Pearls: Charting our progress and failures

Matt Pearl
I tasked a few of my students last week with the reading of a popular excerpt from The Autobiography of Ben Franklin, a piece in which Franklin speaks about charting his weaknesses and keeping track of his bad behavior in an effort to become a better man.
So my high school juniors read the selection on their own, and in partners made ‘accountability posters,’ basically poster board-sized charts that detailed aspects of their life they would like to improve, with spaces to track their mistakes.
Now, the spirit of the assignment was self-improvement, and my students by-and-large embraced the project with (relative) enthusiasm. It’s high school English class, after all, so it might be difficult for much of what we do to get the kids too excited.
Still, they worked hard and got their posters done, and it was interesting for me to see the aspects of their lives upon which these young people wanted to improve.
Several of them had to do with general living: eat better, exercise more, sleep eight hours, etc. A couple of them were more sport/athletic specialized as well.
Regardless of the goals, the process was one and the same: find where you’re weak, keep track of your bad behavior and hold yourself accountable. I feel like I want to have my kids make one of Franklin’s posters and hang it on the walls of Congress. But that’s another commentary for another day.
Among the more interesting items students listed were improved organization, better time management and increased charitability. And by charting these positive goals, the students obligate themselves to take score of when they fall short of the mark.
Is it harsh? I don’t think so. Accountability is one of the most important hallmarks of maturity in my book. And if you are unwilling to deal honestly with yourself, why should anyone else trust you?
As far as 16- and 17-year-olds being required to demonstrate such a level of personal accountability, I think that they’re at the perfect age to put their noses to the grindstone. By the time you’re a high school junior, you’re generally driving a car, sometimes getting a job and often finding yourself responsible for yourself and others. The best way to learn to be responsible is to be given responsibilities, and then to uphold them.
So, charting personal progress (and mistakes) seems like a fair early step toward adulthood. Whether the project becomes a life-changing experience for them or not is immaterial in many ways: the important part is that they have completed an exercise in scrutinizing their behavior. When you write your mistakes down enough times, I suspect you get tired of making them.
What I, the teacher, took away from the experience was positive as well: my students know where they need to improve individually, as evidenced by the honest, high-quality virtues they listed on their charts. I teach good kids, and even the ones who struggle with attitude or effort occasionally surprise you with their intelligent insights.
The whole thing made me feel a little guilty that I don’t have a chart on the wall, one that I could use to hold myself accountable for my many shortcomings. For that matter, I probably should have done just that: I should have gotten out a piece of poster board and made my own character chart for the students to see. What’s good for them should be good for me, I suppose.
But where would I start? Organization, maybe? My staff would concur on that one. And if I had to chart all the bad food I eat or the days I fail to exercise, then such a chart would likely reveal that I often fall short of being the man I would like to be.
Perhaps that’s the very reason I ought to make such a poster. I might need to get started on that.
Matt Pearl owns and operates newspapers in King City, Albany and Grant City.
