View from the Country: Let’s pretend a second

Richard Fulton
Say you are a member of a fairly prosperous, pleasant, community. You belong to various organizations in the community including the Paternal Order of Giraffes. Now one of your members, Ulysses Crain (his father was a civil war buff) has had a persistent problem with cancer. Part of his lung has been removed and recently an aggressive cancer has returned.
Naturally, the POG wants to help their beleaguered member so at a business meeting a motion was made and passed to help give a healthy chunk of money to Crain to help ward off that aggressive cancer. So the Benevolence Committee, headed by Dan Tramp, was charged with delivering the funds.
Now Dan Tramp was a business man and he called Crain to say that the POG wanted to give him some aide against his cancer. Dan was ambitious, he wanted to run for president of the POG in the coming club’s regular elections. Tramp saw an opportunity.
Crain was a popular guy and the members liked him. So when Tramp gave the message of financial help, he couldn’t resist indicating to Crain that if he would endorse him for president, the money would be coming that day, if not maybe later.
Now the cancer was pressing on Crain, it had already killed many of his cells since the last treatment, meaning Crain needed help fast—his doctors were pressing him as well as the aggressive cancer.
Crain held Tramp off. In the meantime, community members got wind of the scheme (the committee treasurer?) and alerted members of the POG. What to do? Tramp was popular amongst some and others knew he used his powers with a harsh hand.
Some said that Tramp should be relieved of his chairmanship, others that he should be kicked out of the club altogether. Others were his friends and attacked the treasurer who they said leaked the whole thing to the local newspaper.
Tramp denied any tit-for-tat arrangement, certainly he would never. But others said they heard Tramp on the phone and that he did, indeed, make the offer. The community was atwitter.
Some believed him, after all, they always did. He would not have been put in charge of the Benevolent funds if he wasn’t trusted, would he?
Some defended Tramp by misdirection. The head of the building and grounds committee kept saying that all this distracted from the fact that the POG needed to focus on repairs to the parking lot. Transportation was a key concern of the members and the potholes in the lot were vexing.
Oh, by the way, Tramp quietly sent the money to Crain saying that’s what he was trying to do all along if Crain would have just given him the address.
The POG was getting a bad name in the community so the members felt something had to be done. After all, Tramp not only bribed Crain, but with POGs money.
So, what would you have done? Defend your friend by saying this was a small thing to be concerning about, everybody does it? Attack Crain for faking the aggressive cancer’s return? How about firing the treasurer? Blame the press for stirring up the town?
Or one could vote to kick Dan Tramp out of the club.
The POG held the crucial meeting and they…well, this is a pretend problem so we shouldn’t have to dwell on the outcome. Anything could have happened after all.
I was just wondering what you would have done.
Richard Fulton is an emeritus professor of political science.
