Skip to content

Grandson seeks info about relative who rode Orphan Train

By SKYE POURNAZARI The Forum
Bob Schwarz drove from Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, to Maryville last weekend to attend Jon Rickman’s presentation Railroads of Nodaway County and seek out information regarding his relative, Harry Hayward. If anyone has information about Hayward, please contact Schwarz at 918-455-7250 in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma.

MARYVILLE, Mo. —The following events occurred in Nodaway County between 1895 and 1900 as reported by The Nodaway Democrat, Oct. 3, 1895. These facts represent a mystery for the grandson and descendants of Orphan Train rider Harry Irving Hayward (1884 to 1955) and they beg assistance in finding a solution.

Harry was born in Brooklyn, New York. He was orphaned at the age of 4. He came to the attention of the Children’s Aid Society and rode one of the famous “Orphan Trains” to Nodaway County, Missouri, on Oct. 2, 1895, along with 15 other children.

He was taken home by L.T. Martin from Orrsburg from the courthouse Oct. 2, 1895. However, it is understood that Mrs. Martin would not accept the situation of another mouth to feed and an additional child to raise and had Mr. Martin return Harry to Children’s Aid Society administrators in Maryville.

The Nodaway Democrat published the names of the children and the families on Oct. 3 but did not specifically name what family Harry was finally placed with on the 4. There is a chance he was accepted by H.B. Phelps, but Harry was not specifically named as being accepted by the Phelps family. His new family wanted to adopt him but he still had a grandmother in the East and she would object.

They had him all set to attend the U.S. Military Academy at West Point when he graduated from high school, but his grandmother sent for him. She wouldn’t hear of him going to the Point. He had no say in the matter as he was not yet 21, so he had to be returned to his grandmother who finally took him.

Harry was an avid reader and Bob Schwarz, his grandson, suspects he may have recorded some of his life events in his Bible, but it is not to be found. Since Harry later earned many medals in military service as an expert marksman, it is suspected that he was taught to hunt at an early age.

He grew to love yucca plants when he was growing up in Missouri so much so that he took one back to New York with him on the train and always had them in his garden and shared them with his descendants.

Schwarz, who has lived in Oklahoma for 51 years has been trying to find any of his history involving the kindness of the family and time he lived in Nodaway County, which had a defining influence in his life. H.B. Phelps could not be located in any census records of the time. Perhaps some of the Phelps family still living might shed some light here.

If anyone has information about Hayward, please contact Schwarz at 918-455-7250 in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma.

SUBMITTED PHOTO
Harry Hayward is shown at the age of 13 either in Holden, Missouri, or by a photographer from Holden, Missouri.

Leave a Comment