Skip to content

Alone, not lonely, on Thanksgiving 2017

Tom Pinney

I was not invited to a Thanksgiving dinner this year, and it was awesome.

There is no sarcasm in that statement, either. I have been dreading getting invited to Thanksgiving dinners since the beginning of the month, and last week, I thought I had gotten a text message inviting me to spend Thanksgiving with one of my friends.

Thankfully, he was just asking me if I could watch his dog and his house over the holiday. I accepted wholeheartedly.

To be fair, I have to address something here. Last year, around Thanksgiving, I wrote about being alone during the holiday and how it really isn’t that fun for me.

After that, I received several emails from readers telling me that, if I ever needed a place to spend Thanksgiving, I could spend it with them.

I’m very thankful for the consideration you have shown. But I couldn’t accept any of them because none of them would ever be the same.

My family’s Thanksgiving celebrations were always the same, such that we had it down to a routine that started the day before. Around 3:30 p.m., my mother and my younger brother, Tobi, would prepare the turkey to go into the oven and put it in to cook overnight.

At 7 a.m., Mom, Tobi, and my little sister D’Ann would go to the kitchen, get the turkey out of the oven, and prepare the rest of the feast. By 9 a.m., my dad, my older brother Tim and I were up and helping in any way we could.

Unfortunately, neither Tim nor I were any good in the kitchen, and by that point, all that was left was nitpicky stuff. Within about 15 minutes, both of us got booted out of the kitchen for something.

We didn’t mind. Tim and I are much better eaters than we are cooks.

At around 11:30 a.m., the house would be full of hearty smells from the kitchen, a swirl of turkey, green beans, noodles, mashed potatoes, turkey gravy, stuffing and corn. Meanwhile, Tobi and D’Ann would be preparing the different pies while Mom would check on everything and make sure it was done to perfection.

At noon, we would gather around the table to pray, each one of us thanking God for something in our lives. Finally, dinner was served, and all six of us would fill our plates with a little bit of everything and head to the living room to enjoy a movie.

By about two, the film was over, everyone was stuffed, and it was naptime. The nap wasn’t required, but if you weren’t napping, you had to be quiet out of respect to those who were.

At 4:15 p.m., everyone was over the turkey coma, and we watched the Cowboys. And that was Thanksgiving.

That, all of that, is why I prefer not to go visit someone else’s family or spend time with other people on Thanksgiving. Every family has its own traditions, its own quirks, and none of it will ever feel right to me.

The first time I spent Thanksgiving alone was in 2011, just after my family moved from Ohio back to Texas while I was still in college. I spent it alone, house-sitting in my then-girlfriend’s apartment while she was in Japan and her roommate was in Dayton.

In 2012, I spent it in my own apartment, having turned down an invitation from my then-girlfriend to spend it with her family because it wouldn’t be the same.

In 2013, my first Thanksgiving in Maryville, I spent it alone in my apartment, having turned down about six invitations. In 2014, I went with friends to St. Joseph, and I was right; it wasn’t the same.

In 2015, I tried to spend it with friends again, and the same result. So, in 2016 I turned down about four invitations, and this year, I spent it house- and dog-sitting for a friend.

There was nothing inherently wrong with those celebrations. There was a lot of love in those households, the food was good, and it was an objectively good time. It just wasn’t the same.

Now, yes, it’s true that I don’t like Thanksgiving because I spend it alone, but if I spent it with people, I would just be reminded that those people aren’t my family. And with my family broken and spread out like an egg in a frying pan, it may never be the same again, and neither will Christmas.

But not only have I come to terms with that, I’m excited for the next step. Soon, I’ll be creating new Thanksgiving traditions with a family of my own.

I’ll be raising a new generation of Cowboys fans who will enjoy the pre-Turkey Bowl nap. I’ll hear the pitter-patter of little feet excitedly running into my room and jolting me out of my sleep excited that Santa came the night before. I’ll be able to make both of these holidays new and improved.

For now, though, I push through Thanksgiving and count down the days until Christmas, when I can see my family again.

(As a side note, for those of you still hanging around: When the Forum becomes a weekly, Pinney for your Thoughts will move mostly online. The column will run in print once a month, but will run regularly on the Forum website.)

Tom Pinney is a writer for the Maryville Forum.

Leave a Comment