Skip to content

Why Friday’s executive order matters to us

Jennifer Ditlevson Haglund

Around the dinner table sat my family, and a group of missionaries from Cambodia. We were eating pizza quietly until the Cambodian mother laughed.

She told me she does that sometimes when she’s enjoying a big meal because suddenly she will remember catching scorpions in a bag with her brothers and sisters after they’d been orphaned during the days of Khmer Rouge. When the children couldn’t find scorpions to kill, they ate dirt and rocks to trick themselves into feeling full.

When it was raining like it was that day we ate pizza together, she said that after all the years she’s lived in the United States, she still finds herself catching whiffs of the damp earth and wanting to eat it.

A few years later during my time in northern Dallas, I got my hair cut in a strip mall shop run by Vietnamese and Cambodian women who barely escaped The Killing Fields. One day, while one of them was washing my hair, I heard that same random laughter coming from across the salon. The woman washing my hair explained that her friend periodically exploded like that because she remembered living where there was one kind of soap for every kind of washing and when they had no food. Now, they worked in a shop stocked with a wall of soap for hair only.

Since Friday’s executive order regarding immigration, I’ve thought of these women as I watched news outlets, bloggers, and friends respond. People protest in outrage by going to airports or writing letters. I’ve seen posts defending the president’s actions, and of course, there are those so tired of all the political conversation who dismiss the severity of such an order. As usual, I find little discourse and a lot of loud reactions. Still, I read, and I read a variety of things.

According to The Washington Examiner’s Senior Political Columnist Tim Carney, former President Barack Obama banned Iraqi immigrants for six months in 2011, so a temporary ban for people from countries that were deemed threatening isn’t anything new. Carney, however, also wrote that “demanding we do everything possible to prevent every potential terrorist attack requires we treat everyone as a potential terrorist,” which leaves “no room for privacy” or “room for refugees or immigrants.”

Although David French at National Review noted that the ban’s poor implementation left legal residents in an inexcusable lurch, he pointed out that capping the resettlement ceiling at 50,000 wasn’t extreme when considering that it was average for Obama’s term prior to 2016, when he dramatically increased refugee admission rates. French also claimed that the reaction to the order was grounded more in “hysteria” than fact.

On Monday, The New York Times published an article stating that the order leaves room for customs and border patrol “to improvise” enforcement, which has interrupted the lives of students and permanent residents trying to return to the United States. Within hours of the publication of the Times article, a report from The Wall Street Journal indicated that more than 100 State Department officials had signed a draft of formal protest to the executive order they determined to be “counterproductive” to keeping the country safe.

As I stated earlier, it’s obviously a colossal mess.

I’m going to keep reading coverage across the board as this plays out. I will read conservative takes, liberal perspectives, and articles by those who I have known to work hard to be objective.

All the while, I’m thinking of my college friend from Syria, and how I haven’t heard from her in more than a year. In my box of favorite letters, I keep a card she wrote to me before returning to her country. I hope she’s gotten too busy or annoyed with social media to bother with it anymore and that nothing else is wrong, because I know that as the order stands, she’s not welcome here. Her hijab betrays the fact that she doesn’t practice the right religion and her country is run by madmen, so she couldn’t get here if she needed to.

To me, that’s crazy.

But when I remember the president’s statement from 2015 about “a total and complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States until our country’s representatives can figure out what is going on,” I suppose it makes sense to him. It’s just business, nothing personal.

Jennifer Ditlevson Haglund is a former news reporter for the Maryville Daily Forum, now living and writing in New York City.

Leave a Comment