Participation trophies and safe spaces

Tom Pinney
I am growing weary of arguments with past generations, because somehow it always goes back to how criminal it was that I got a participation trophy in T-ball.
I’m getting ahead of myself, so let me back up: Gen-Xers love to say that millennials are so emotionally fragile because we were never taught how to lose.
I see this multiple times a day. Memes and shared news articles talking about how “we didn’t need safe spaces when (insert President) was elected.”
Pictures of crying millennials with the caption: “What happens when you give a generation a participation trophy.”
It looks like it’s time for a history lesson, because people are forgetting just how millennials started getting participation trophies.
Participation trophies started because parents decided it was criminal that everyone didn’t get a trophy for all their hard work throughout the season.
When I was in city league T-ball at six years old, my team sucked. I sucked. We were terrible. We had the worst record in the city because we couldn’t hit the ball or stop a ball that was hit.
The previous year, a mom had made a stink that it was ridiculous how everyone paid a registration fee, yet only the winning team got trophies at the end. As a result, we all got participation trophies.
Mine was destroyed within the year because I wasn’t careful with it.
Three years later, I was in city league baseball. We sucked for almost the exact same reason, but with the added complication that we didn’t have a pitcher that could get it anywhere close to the plate.
We all got participation trophies. I had lost mine before two months went by.
In middle school, I won my school’s science fair and went on to win districts and regionals to make it to State.
Those trophies stayed intact through two cross-country moves. The participation ribbon I got from the state competition didn’t.
Through an 8-year competitive career in speech and debate spanning both high school and college, I earned more than 100 trophies, plaques, and medals for breaking to out-rounds in my events. I still have many of those trophies, because they all point to a time where I won.
But every participation trophy I had as a kid disappeared before six months had passed.
The people that wanted the participation trophies were parents.
We didn’t give a rip about them.
Kids aren’t stupid: they aim to win, and when they get a trophy for not winning, they start to question why we give out trophies in the first place. They start to question why we play in the first place.
Imagine a world where all 32 NFL teams were given Lombardi trophies at the end of the season. It would make the Super Bowl (can I say that?) worthless, wouldn’t it?
The whole “participation trophy” culture was created by our predecessors, and now we know why. The only reason participation trophies existed at all was so that you could throw them back in our faces when we tried to do something to better the world.
But I can stomach the argument because at least the stereotype is, even if only a tiny bit, true, though you are the ones who started the trend. What I can’t stand is the fact that you completely misconstrue the purpose of safe spaces.
Safe spaces were established to make sure people in marginalized communities knew they weren’t alone, because no matter how bad “political correctness” got, people still used terms like “gay” and the N-word as pejorative. (Also, newsflash – they still do.)
They were never so that “snowflakes” and “cupcakes” (creative insults, by the way) could go cry about their feelings. But boy, Gen-Xers sure love to say they were.
Being a millennial is a daily, sometimes hourly, exercise of cognitive dissonance, because everytime we think we’re doing what you told us to do, every time we follow your directions on how to exist in this world, you change up the standards without telling us and then chide us for not meeting the standards we weren’t aware of.
Take a look at yourselves, Gen-Xers. Now look back to us. (Old Spice.)
You told us to be good humans, then you told us to vote for one of two people which represent the scum of the earth.
You told us that we needed to learn to win or lose, then you gave us participation trophies when we didn’t. Then you chided us for getting said participation trophies.
You told us to be tolerant, then insulted us when we created spaces of tolerance.
YOU set us up for failure.
Let me explain it this way: it’s like we’re playing football, and we have a chip-shot field goal to make which will end the game. There’s no wind, the clock is showing zeros, and the stadium is perfectly quiet.
The snapper snaps the ball, we kick it … and you move the goalposts 20 yards to the right and fire us for missing the game-winning kick.
That’s where we have to draw the line.
Gen-Xers, find a goal you want millennials to reach and stick with it. But don’t fault us when we follow your directions and come up with an answer you don’t like.
Because maybe, just maybe, that means your initial answer was wrong.
