Skip to content

Neighbor opposes Elks Lodge zoning request

TONY BROWN/DAILY FORUM
Nicki Samson, standing at right, addresses the Maryville City Council this week to state her opposition to a request by the local Elks Lodge to move its headquarters to a former church, the parking lot of which adjoins Samson’s yard. The council, which includes two Elks members, tabled the lodge’s request for a special use permit until its next meeting.

In a City Council session this week fueled by alcohol-related issues, including a decision to proceed with a liquor license suspension/revocation hearing for The Palms bar, the city’s governing board tabled a request for a special use permit sought by the local Elks Lodge that would allow the organization to move its headquarters from a century-old building on North Main to a former church at 921 E. Third Street.

The request to locate the lodge in the residential neighborhood has been green-lighted for council approval by the Maryville Planning & Zoning Commission but is being strenuously opposed by neighborhood resident Nicki Samson, whose yard adjoins the church’s parking lot.

Addressing the council during a public hearing prior to Monday’s regular session, Samson said her primary objections to the Elks acquiring the Assemblies of God property include late operating hours and the group’s intention to serve alcohol.

While the Elks are considered by many to be primarily a service organization, the local lodge does operate a bar open daily to its more than 300 members.

Also, as Sampson pointed out, the Elks nationally have long been associated with alcohol consumption, and, according to the New York Times, were founded in the late 1860s as a drinking club in an effort to circumvent laws limiting business hours for public taverns.

Councilmen Tim Shipley and Jerry Riggs both stayed on the dais during Samson’s remarks after identifying themselves, at Samson’s request, as members of the lodge. City Attorney Taryn Henry was asked to render an opinion with regard to their presence, but said she was unable to call up the appropriate statute on her laptop computer.

Henry said a few minutes later that, without being sure exactly what the ordinance said, both council members should probably excuse themselves if a vote was taken. City Manager Greg McDanel further recommended that Riggs and Shipley leave the room during actual debate on the special use ordinance, which was scheduled to take place during the regular meeting following the public hearing.

In the event, the council elected to table both formal debate and a vote on the special use permit until the governing board’s next meeting in two weeks, by which time Henry is to issue an opinion on whether Riggs and Shipley should participate.

For her part, Samson argued that locating the lodge in her R-2M Single Family-zoned neighborhood violated the city’s comprehensive plan. She also said she was promised by a board member of the church that owns the building that the structure would only be sold to someone intending to use it for “God’s work.”

She said she recognized that the Elks often promote public service, various charities, and worthwhile community endeavors, but added that at least part of the lodge’s function is to serve as a place to drink.

“I know they do a lot of good things,” Samson said. “But I don’t want to live in a bar.” She described her bedroom window as being about 6 feet from the parking lot offering access to the church building’s main rear entrance.

“I don’t want to stay up with you all night, I just don’t,” Samson continued, pointing out that a special use permit is, in effect, permission from the city to conduct a land use in a location where such activities or facilities would not normally be allowed.

“Why do we have zoning?” she asked. “Why do we have rules? I don’t mind playing games if we all follow the same rules.”

Continuing on for some minutes, Samson concluded by telling the council she just wanted to be treated fairly and for the city to follow the zoning rules for her neighborhood as they already exist.

“If you wouldn’t want it in your yard, then your vote is pretty easy,” she said.

Maryville Elks Exalted Ruler John Nelson, who also addressed the council, said the Elks want to acquire the East Third facility because the lodge’s current home is not handicap-compliant and prevents the organization from hosting blood drives — a national Elks initiative — and other community-centered events.

He added that the current building, constructed in the early 1900s, is becoming too expensive to maintain.

In addition to accommodating twice-monthly member meetings, Nelson said, the church would allow the lodge to offer a more welcoming space for such non-Elks events as sorority and fraternity mixers, wedding receptions, and teen dances while providing easier access to older Elks with mobility issues.

Nelson also said that building a new Elks headquarters in a part of town zoned for such facilities is cost prohibitive, considering the size of the local lodge and “the amount of money we have in hand.”

In earlier statements before the Planning & Zoning Commission, which Samson attended and at which she also spoke, Nelson said the existing lodge, including the bar, opens at 4 p.m. and usually continues to serve members until 10:30 p.m.

If more than four members are present, or if the lodge has been rented out, the bar remains open until 12:30 a.m., Nelson said.

The Elks leader also presented a letter to the commission from Public Safety Director Keith Wood stating that the lodge has been the subject of only two police calls over the past seven years, one involving a stolen flag and the other relating to a disturbance that occurred when an outside group leased the facility.

During her remarks to the council, Samson indicated that one of her primary concerns was noise, and that she would drop her objection if the Elks would agree to close at 10 p.m.

Leave a Comment