District football playoff system does more harm than good

By DAVID MERRILL Sports Editor
What’s left of them
It’s an exciting time of year for football teams. With the playoffs now under way, a loss could send the team home for the season. Maryville dispatched of the Cameron Dragons 70-6 this past weekend, but with all due respect to the Cameron players, coaches, parents, and fans it was a case of putting the Dragons out of their misery.
Nothing about the game looked, felt, or smelled like a playoff atmosphere. Simply put- the game was a product of a playoff system that’s broken and needs to be fixed.
Maryville had already beaten Cameron 92-8 during the season and Friday’s game was essentially a rerun of the same movie that, as much as I love covering the Spoofhound football team and love my job, I didn’t want to watch again.
Taking a look at the stands Friday night, it didn’t look like many other people did either.
By the time Cameron limped (for some players literally) back to Maryville to finish out a season that all of them would want to forget, There were just 25 players in uniform and that may have included ones that were wearing jeans and/or had arms in slings.
I completely understand the angle of getting younger players more snaps and more playing time. That is only beneficial, but that was one of the few pros of a game that (aside from Maryville’s starters getting to score more touchdowns and pad their stats) didn’t really have any.
Up to a certain point, it stops becoming beneficial to the side that’s winning. More importantly it’s another game in which players on both sides risk injury.
There is no reason Cameron should have had to make the trip to Maryville — at least not a good one.
There’s a simple fix to all of this.
Give the No. 1 seed in districts with an odd number of teams a bye. For districts with an even amount of teams, such as the district Maryville plays in, give the top two seeds a bye.
I feel like they’ve earned that.
Some districts in eight-man and 11-man districts with an odd number of teams are already doing this and I think it’s the best way to go about things.
In 11-man football districts with an even number of teams, just eight out of the 76 games in which a No. 1 or No. 2 seed played, were decided by 10 points or less. In the districts with an odd number of teams, none of the four games fell into that category.
In all of 11-man football games played on Friday in which a No. 1 or No. 2 seed was involved, 12 of their opponents went winless on the year and five teams playing a No. 2 seed went in with a winning record. Three of them pulled off upsets.
Of the seven district tournament games in eight-man football, just two of them were close and there were no upsets.
Quite honestly, those odds just aren’t good enough for me to justify this system being the best fit.
Nebraska (my home state) goes almost too far in the other direction and leaves out some teams that have a winning record. A committee ranks the top 16 teams in each class. Out of the six classes in the state, four of the No. 16 seeds won at least four games. I still think 16 is too many, but for the most part, it makes sure that teams that haven’t had a good year don’t have to trudge their way back up to get fed to the dogs.
Kansas, from what it looks like, combines the Nebraska and Missouri formats as 16 teams make it per class. If a team wins its first “state” playoff game, it advances to a “regional” game, then “sectional”, then “sub-state” before getting a chance to play for the state championship, should they advance that far.
Teams who haven’t won a game all year still manage to get some sort of “postseason” game.
Iowa may have the best formula: 16 teams per class (eight on each side of the bracket) and you don’t see a team with a losing record. The worst record a team about to play a postseason game had, across six classes, is 5-4.
I understand that Missouri is trying to keep all sports the same by including everybody, but the fact of the matter is football carries the highest risk for injury compared to any other sport a kid plays. It should be handled differently.
I wouldn’t even mind seeing all the sports give the top one or two seeds in district tournaments opening-round byes. The teams will have earned it.
It’s time for playoff games — all of them — to have a better chance of having a playoff atmosphere and reduce injury risk in the process.

By DAVID MERRILL Sports reporter
Maryville’s Tyler McGary shoves Cameron’s Joseph Roach out of the way during a run against the Dragons on Friday. Maryville won 70-6.
