Skip to content

If recycling is a good thing, using less is best

Jennifer Ditlevson Haglund

Growing up, I worked for an elderly couple doing odd jobs. I washed windows and baseboards, pulled weeds, and vacuumed. In the late summer and throughout the fall, I gathered corn, apples, asparagus, walnuts, green beans, and melons from their huge garden.

With one set of grandparents dead and the other living several states away, I adopted them as my stand-in grandparents. Like any child, I loved getting paid way too much for menial labor, but I liked just being there.

But sometimes it got weird.

I’ll never forget washing the living room walls and reporting to Ruth that I needed more rags. She walked upstairs, and in a minute returned with a ratty pair of her husband’s underwear and scissors.

After cutting off the elastic, she handed me the soiled skivvies.

At 12 years old, I couldn’t bring myself to protest. I looked into the dirty water in the bucket and shuddered, wondering what other things I’d had touched unknowingly.

They were a fascinating couple. While the world around them changed, they kept living like they were still on their farm.

Over 50 years, they sold plots of their land, which eventually created Franklin Avenue. On one end of it, a couple in their late 80s still raised crops, and a quarter-mile down the road there was a McDonald’s and a drive-through beer barn.

For 10 years, I watched them use and reuse everything — before it was cool.

When I lived in Waco, Texas, I could throw every clean recyclable item in a bin and forget about it. I could feel like a halfway decent steward of the earth for doing my part.

Remembering my days with John and Ruth, I have to think that there’s more to it than that. Recycling and reusing products is probably better than not doing anything at all, but when I went to visit NoCoMo Industries, Inc. recently, I couldn’t process the amount of waste sorted there.

Seeing the volume of disposable items convicted me.

The bigger problem is compulsive consumption. I have a friend who is a very conscientious activist with various causes in Los Angeles. She told me it’s unrealistic and unsustainable to tell people to consume less and to focus on finding more “ethical” means to produce, transport, and purchase goods to help the world.

I’ve found that researching manufacturers to discover their production practices is nearly impossible, and at least exhausting. It takes so much time to trace how many hands touch the goods we buy, if they’re children’s or slave’s hands, and in what condition these people must work. It doesn’t matter if it’s peanuts or rain coats. A lot of the labor is subcontracted and recontracted dozens of times across the globe before it ever reaches the shelves.

Yet John and Ruth didn’t have to think about where or how they got things because they weren’t buying much more than they needed.

They had a music room and trinkets from John’s days traveling around the world when he was a Navy Seal in the 1940s. But they spent time digging flower bulbs so they wouldn’t freeze instead of buying new ones. They canned their produce and wore clothes that were 40 years old.

I was born long after people returned soda and milk bottles for refills, and I don’t know how to sew much more than a button onto a shirt. By the time I entered kindergarten, breakfast for most of my friends meant unwrapping Pop Tarts and drinking a Sunny Delight. (I was the kid who got off-brand Cheerios).

This is why, despite my hopeful disagreement, my friend is probably right. From my parents’ generation on, the American public has been conditioned to consume cheap things and throw them away — at high and hidden costs to the environment.

I’m guilty of wanting too much, even when I try to live simply. But I want to do better. If my life permitted me to, I’d live like John and Ruth on land where I’d have a big garden. I’d make applesauce that turned pink because I’d leave the skins on.

That’s not going to happen. My husband is an academic, not a farmer. As many hard skills as I have, more of them are soft.

To do my part, I have to question every time I think I need a new shirt, candy bar, or a drive through McDonald’s for a coffee.

I am, however, still working on whether or not I’m ready to shred Tim’s underwear to clean our floors.

Leave a Comment