Skip to content

Don’t call me heartless just because we disagree

Matt Pearl

I have grown pretty disenchanted over time with the folks who would label me heartless any time my heart bleeds differently from theirs.

I went through it in the first round of Obamacare, when I was approached by a gentleman who asked me, “What’s wrong with you? Do you want to see little kids going untreated because their parents can’t get insurance?”

Because I disagreed with the specific means by which the national healthcare initiative was executed, I was instantly morally accountable for sick kids and the plight of the poor.

The same gentleman informed me that I was overreacting anyway, because my taxes were already funding Medicare and Medicaid — so he let me know that I was already paying for healthcare for low income families.

My reply: “And I’m fine with that. So you’re saying when Obamacare is enforced that my taxes are going down when my insurance premiums go up?”

He knew as well as I did that no such thing would happen.

So we stopped talking: he still believed that I didn’t care about kids needing operations, and I still believed that an insurance mandate might not be the most efficient way to help those kids.

So because my mind didn’t reach the same precise solution that President Obama’s think tank designed, I get to be the heartless conservative.

But when I suggest that abortion might be the real, quantifiable, systematic killing of humans, I’m a radical.

My bleeding heart for the unborn, evidently, is equally wrong in the eyes of the American liberal. I guess I’m just a hateful right-winger approaching middle age when my morals don’t guide me in precisely the direction that the White House suggests.

I’ve tried to be moderate. I have long believed that it is important to understand my fellow citizens.

But the struggle is tough: it appears that the American media only embraces one view of kindness, and that is one that caters to the whims of the Left and whatever its newest cause happens to be.

I’ll say this once, and maybe I won’t have to keep saying it again and again. Love me or hate me, at least anyone interested deserves to know where I stand:

I pray every day of my life for this country and its people. I am kind to everyone who allows me to be so. I am content to have friends in this world with contrasting viewpoints to my own, as long as we respect one another with some civility.

But know this: If I disagree with you, it can only be so because you also disagree with me. It’s not mean-spirited of me to hold my own values — values that do not encourage the persecution or hatred of anyone. I let you do so, and I demand the same.

In other words, I am under no moral obligation to fall in line with any media or partisan view just to prove I’m a good person.

We’re all Americans, and we don’t have to concur with one another’s beliefs. But don’t call me uncaring just because my heart bleeds for a different cause from your own.

Leave a Comment