Skip to content

Kansas City’s Gordon purgatory

Matt Slocum
Kansas City Royals’ Alex Gordon hits an RBI single during the fifth inning of Game 4 of the Major League Baseball World Series against the New York Mets Saturday, Oct. 31, 2015, in New York. (AP Photo/Matt Slocum)

It took less than 48 hours for Royals fans to shift from enjoying the first world championship in three decades to wallowing in the self-pitying sorrows of small-market free agency.

In case you need a reminder, Kansas City clinched the 2015 World Series on Sunday, Nov. 1 with a 7-2 victory over the New York Mets. By Tuesday, Nov. 3 — when players, coaches, and front office staff cruised slowly down Grand Boulevard showered by the screams and waves of a victory parade — Royals fans were already talking “next season.”

Maybe that’s the social media age, an era of living in the next moment instead of the one flashing by, always wanting the future to be now. Or maybe it’s the hunger of a fan base satisfied by one championship but always searching for another.

For the sake of staying positive about the state of the modern sports fan, let’s go with the latter.

Either way, the pressing issues of a small-market baseball franchise trying to stave off the death of its championship core are here and now. At the forefront of those issues stand a left fielder wading into the free agency pool, testing an ever-growing market with a résumé that includes four Gold Gloves and three straight All-Star appearances.

Let’s talk about Alex Gordon.

If Gordon signs with another organization, it’ll be incredibly hard to fathom him wearing another jersey. This much is inarguably true. He’s been part of the organization for a decade after Kansas City selected him second overall out of Nebraska in the 2005 amateur draft. Since that time, he’s led the complete turnaround of what was possibly the saddest franchise in professional sports.

In nine Major League seasons, Gordon transformed himself from an underperforming third baseman to an All-Star left fielder and perhaps the best defensive outfielder in the sport. At the plate, he went from wannabe slugger to on-base machine. In the clubhouse, by all accounts, Gordon developed from golden boy to emotional leader.

And that’s exactly why Kansas City shouldn’t re-sign him.

For months now, my opinion hasn’t changed. Unless the market changes drastically, the Royals can’t and shouldn’t shell out the payday Gordon deserves.

It’s the ultimate debate and debacle for all small-market teams in baseball: Draft and develop great players, wring every affordable ounce of production from them, and watch them drive off in a dump truck full of money.

Step three is where Gordon now waits. With Jason Heyward signed for a megadeal with Chicago, the first domino has fallen for free agent outfielders, meaning news on Gordon could happen virtually any day now.

Jon Heyman of CBS Sports reported last week that Gordon’s “camp” informed the Royals they had no shot at bringing him back. On Tuesday, that report was refuted by the Omaha World-Herald, which quoted the All-Star outfielder as saying, “The Royals are still in the mix.”

Whether or not Gordon has crossed Kansas City off his list isn’t actually all that important. Had he truly counted the incumbents out, it would take the pressure off Royals GM Dayton Moore to stay in the mix until Gordon signs elsewhere.

Simply put, Gordon might be worth five years and $100 million to an MLB organization. KC can’t afford that, and shouldn’t try. In just two years time, the Royals face the same free agency monster for Alcides Escobar, Lorenzo Cain, Mike Moustakas, and Eric Hosmer, among a couple others.

Want one or more of those cornerstones to stay in town? Then it’s time to wish Gordon the best on his way out.

The problem now is that KC has to play the waiting game. Say, for instance, Justin Upton and Yoenis Cespedes sign with the final remaining teams searching for a big-name outfielder, leaving Gordon as the odd man out in a game of monetary musical chairs. That would bring his value back down to earth, allowing the Royals to possibly sneak in the backdoor for a reasonable contract.

If, in this scenario, Moore fires his bullets now and pulls the trigger on Gerardo Parra and/or Dexter Fowler, that leaves no roster space or payroll room for Gordon to come back, even if the Royals hit the jackpot and Gordon is forced to sign cheap.

So this is the purgatory Kansas City finds itself in. Judging by what Moore has said in interviews throughout the last two months, he understands the Royals can’t compete for Gordon on the open market. He also knows he can’t afford to miss out on bringing back the face of the franchise if pieces break a certain way.

None of this is a “good riddance” to Gordon. He’s been one of the best players in franchise history and, on the off-chance he finishes his career as a Royal, would surely have a bronze statue sculpted in his name as he rides into the sunset.

What this really amounts to is a friendly, understanding goodbye. Goodbye to one of the best players in Kansas City history, and good luck throughout the rest of your career. (But please don’t sign with the Tigers.)

Dalton Vitt

Leave a Comment