Skip to content

Those ‘Know-Nothing’ ideals still resonate with some voters

Richard Fulton

In the middle of the 19th century in America the political order was fragile and open to movements attacking what they perceived to be significant problems within American society.

Slavery, of course, was a major issue splitting the country apart.

But there was another issue that caused significant conflict that has echoes within today’s fragmented politics.

That issue was the surge of immigrants entering the country and how America should react to that condition. Immigration is a significant issue in our politics today, of course, which is what makes this history lesson relevant.

The political party system was falling apart in the mid-1800s. The Jacksonian Democratic Party was healthy, but the Whig Party was slowly disintegrating. One of the offshoots of that disintegration was something called the Native American Party. A rather ironic title since its adherents were largely white protestants, not Indians.

As the party became active it changed its name to the American Party. It’s platform was based on four keystones: American nationalism; anti-Catholicism; republicanism; and nativism.

I should note that Wikipedia is a good source for history, so I used that as a source for much of this history.

You can see my point coming.

Today’s political movement that has spawned the rhetoric of Donald Trump, Scott Walker, Ted Cruz and a variety of the other Republican candidates for president have significant echoes of the ideas of those 19th Century movements called, even in their time, Know-Nothings.

The American nationalism plank is reflected today in the views expressed as American Exceptionalism: that America is better morally, and in many other ways, than other nations.

The message is that our present government is anti-American because it does not project more American power and does not control world events as it should.

Often this comes with nasty rhetoric.

The anti-Catholic plank is echoed by today’s Know-Nothings by simply substituting Muslim for Catholic. They are all terrorists and/or at least have an anti-American bias.

The republican plank is reflected in a view that is regional and took the form of what present Know-Nothings refer to as “states’ rights.”

The national government is overbearing and dictatorial and states need to control their destiny. This view was championed by the South during the civil war, of course.

Today’s Know-Nothings want more power devolved to the states, but strangely still want all the money that the federal government provides. That government should balance its budget, but still give states up to half of their budgets in grants.

Most egregious is the anti-immigrant stance of today’s Know-Nothings.

The 19th century group claimed that these folks were voting illegally and riots even broke out in Louisville, Baltimore, and elsewhere over the issue. They railed against crime and welfare costs. Businesses and even governments refused to hire Irish and other Catholic immigrants. This in the Chicago and Boston governments, for example.

Don’t be fooled, these movements attracted voters then, they will attract voters now.

Mayors in Boston, Philadelphia, Washington D.C., and elsewhere were Know-Nothing candidates. Alabama and Ohio had Know-Nothing governors. Presidential candidates, however, did not get very far and the movement petered out after 1860.

Abraham Lincoln, in a private letter, noted the American creed of “all men are created equal” and commented that if Know-Nothings got control that would read: “all men are created equal except negroes, foreigners, and Catholics.”

Substitute in Latin Americans and Muslims and you have today’s Know-Nothings.

Leave a Comment