Rural hospitals fight for viability
A lot of rural hospitals are in trouble these days, and that trouble runs especially deep in the 17 states — mostly in the Midwest and South — that have declined to expand Medicaid coverage in accordance with guidelines set forth in the federal Affordable Care Act.
According to a recent Associated Press report, hospitals closing their doors cite a combination of changing demographics, medical practices, management decisions and federal policies that have put financial pressure on facilities that sometimes average only a few in-patients per day.
Fifty hospitals in the rural U.S. have closed since 2010, according to the AP report, with more closures in the past two years than in the previous 10 years combined, according to the National Rural Health Association.
An additional 283 rural hospitals in 39 states are vulnerable to shutting down, and 35 percent of rural hospitals are operating at a loss, according to iVantage Health Analytics, a Portland, Maine-based firm that works with hospitals.
Most of the rural hospital closures so far have occurred in the South and Midwest. Of those at risk, nearly 70 percent are in states like Missouri that have declined to expand Medicaid coverage to individuals whose earnings total 138 percent or less of the Federal Poverty Level.
States implementing Medicaid expansion receive federal funding covering all increased costs through 2016, a declining share over the following three years, and 90 percent thereafter.
Michael Baumgartner, president of St. Francis Hospital & Health Services in Maryville, said that despite the politics surrounding the Affordable Care Act — referred to by opponents as Obamacare — expanding Medicaid coverage has allowed rural hospitals in other states to better fulfill their primary mission of providing quality care to everyone who needs it.
“I think we need to focus on the reason why we are here,” Baumgartner said, “and that is to care for our patients. That’s what (expanding Medicaid) does, and it does it very nicely. It helps on the business side of the model, too.”
As an example, Baumgartner pointed to Kentucky, which expanded Medicaid coverage beginning in 2014.
Since raising its Medicaid ceiling to include an additional 300,000 low-income residents, Baumgartner said the number of hospital patients forced to pay medical bills themselves without assistance from insurance or government programs has decreased significantly.
A study by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, the nation’s largest health philanthropy, suggests expanding Medicaid carries benefits for participating states as well.
According to Stateline, a state government news site operated by the Pew Charitable Trusts, the RWJ report surveyed eight Medicaid expansion states: Arkansas, Colorado, Kentucky, Michigan, New Mexico, Oregon, Washington and West Virginia. The study estimated those states will save or collect a total of $1.8 billion through Medicaid expansion by the end of this year.
But expanding Medicaid is not necessarily a cure-call, and Baumgartner said the reasons many rural hospitals struggle are varied and complex. Other factors include limited access to physicians, particularly specialists, a “payer mix” that includes too many people lacking coverage, and the fact that programs such as Medicare and Medicaid reimburse hospitals at a lower rate for routine as opposed to specialized care.
For many rural hospitals, routine care is most of what they do. But that doesn’t mean such treatment, however much needed by patients, is good for the bottom line.
“I think everyone agrees that we need to provide better access to health care,” Baumgartner said. “The struggle has always been the financial model that goes with that. The Affordable Care Act is one viable option.”
Rural areas tend to “have older, poorer, sicker populations,” said Michael Topchik, senior vice president of iVantage, who was quoted in correspondent David Leib’s Associated Press Story.
That means, Lieb wrote, that such institutions often have a higher percentage of patients covered by Medicare and Medicaid and have been particularly hard hit by federal budget cuts and provisions in the 2010 federal health care law that reduced charity care reimbursements.
Lieb also quoted state Rep. Warren Love, who recently helped lead a failed effort to save the Sac-Osage Hospital in the small western Missouri town of Osceola.
“Everything has evolved to the-big-gets-bigger and the littlest disappears,” Love said, “and that’s really what’s happened with these hospitals.”
