Skip to content

Am I my brother’s keeper?

Matt Pearl

I read a story when I was younger about a man who killed his brother out of nothing more than petty jealousy.

When the man was caught, he asked a question that challenges our ideals of morality to this very day: Am I my brother’s keeper?

He doesn’t get his question answered in that moment, but most of the rest of the lengthy story that follows seems to address the issue head-on.

What troubles our world today pertaining to this question is to what extent we ought to ensure one another’s well being.

There seems to be extensive middle ground between killing our brothers — or allowing them to come to harm — and providing for them entirely. Exactly where within that space we ought to operate seems to be the issue, one that has divided public opinion for some time.

My brother is hungry — do I feed him? Most of us believe that we can aid him in overcoming his misfortune by offering financial assistance.

But what about when he’s gaming the system? Most of us find that to be dishonorable.

My sister is unemployed — do I support her? Yes. She and her children should, in a land of great abundance such as ours, have food to eat.

What, then, do we do when she remains unemployed because our charities are greater than her wages would be?

It seems that there is no universal, foolproof method for distributing public assistance money. How do we decide who gets what?

Some say the answer is to use the individual’s willingness to work as the test for welfare worthiness.

Others say drug testing of welfare recipients is the answer.

Both of these ideas work in email forwards and coffee shop politics, but I’m not sure either is the answer.

From what I have observed so far in this world, water always runs downhill, and people will go where opportunity presents itself. To minimize poverty and limit those using assistance programs, there have to be jobs.

When the government creates a job, Uncle Sam doesn’t end the problem. He sends it in a loop. Instead of receiving an assistance check, an individual works and receives the same check.

In terms of total work production, things appear to have improved. In terms of the economy, nothing has changed much.

When job growth occurs as the product of increased economic opportunity, jobs seem to follow. But how do you convince job creators to, well, create jobs?

In the coming months and years, we will likely continue to see the opposite trend.

The more astringent Affordable Care Act mandates on business are going to yield layoffs. A comparatively enormous percentage of the American workforce will find itself employed part-time, the most common way around Obamacare that corporations are likely to take.

Fewer jobs and stagnant economic growth sounds like the recipe for 2008 all over again.

Or 1930 for that matter.

Oh, and your health insurance premiums are pretty likely to jump 30 percent or so. That means you and I in the middle class are likely to see our standard of living plummet dramatically.

So I go back to that question, “Am I my brother’s keeper?”

My answer remains Yes. But it would certainly be nice to have my brother in Washington caring for me sometimes, too.

Leave a Comment