Still room for another pizza joint

Jason Offutt
If there’s one constant in life, it’s that city planners are under the undying assumption there’s always room in town for one more pizza restaurant.
My town is getting one, although we already have eight places that sell pizza.
Excited?
Just a bit (you see, I’m part of the problem).
So, before I set my taste buds upon our new offering, I thought I’d reminisce about the best pizza I’ve ever had — in Bemidji, Minnesota.
Bemidji, population 13,431, is known for three things: It’s the birthplace of movie actress and WW II pin-up hottie Jane Russell, it’s the home of giant statues of Paul Bunyan and Babe the Blue Ox, and it’s the curling capital of America. The sport, not hair.
Carol Olson of the Bemidji Chamber of Commerce told me I couldn’t leave town without stopping at Dave’s Pizza.
Well, OK.
Dave’s opens at 5 p.m., but Olson told me I had to go early because a line forms. A long line. By 4:40, there were about 50 people standing on the sidewalk.
One, a pleasant kind of guy, about 60, stood next to me.
“Have you eaten here before?” I asked the man, I’d later find was Lawrence Hunter, and yes, he has.
“This is the best pizza, maybe in the country,” he said without hesitation. “There’s always a line.”
Pete and Roxanne Fenson bought Dave’s Pizza in 1996. Pete’s a local legend. He was skipper of the bronze-metal-winning 2006 USA Olympic curling team.
“What are you going to order?” I asked Hunter.
He smiled. “My wife and I always order the House Special,” he said.
The take-out counter welcomes customers to Dave’s. A bright yellow, maroon and green menu board dominated the wall behind the counter. A man who looked a bit like actor Edward Norton leaned against the counter, smiling.
“So this is pretty good?” I asked Hunter, as he made his way past me and walked toward the dining room.
He stopped. “I’ve had pizza all over the world. I’ve had pizza in Italy,” he said, and pointed to the floor. “This is the best.”
The man who looked like Edward Norton was owner Fenson.
“We just do it the old fashioned way. We make everything in here. We even grind our own cheese,” Fenson told me. “I think our customers appreciate it.”
“What should I get?” I asked.
He smiled with a mouthful of straight, white teeth. “The Italian Combo.”
Will do.
I seated myself, wandering through the restaurant until I found the rear dining room. By 5:25 p.m., the restaurant was packed.
I ordered a small, extra-thin crust Italian Combo that came with Italian sausage, pepperoni, Bavarian sausage, onions, and garlic from Stephanie, a blonde, perky waitress.
The pizza — cut into squares by a bladed tool that looked like a Klingon weapon — was amazing. The crust, not too doughy, not too crisp, was covered by a generous helping of a pleasant, but not overpowering sauce. The Italian and Bavarian sausage dominated the toppings, underscored by a persistent, pallet tingling hint of garlic that I would happily taste for hours. And the cheese was what Fenson had told me — ground in-house. My one gripe was the price. One beer and a small pizza (albeit with enough leftovers for at least another meal) cost $18, sans tip.
Hunter stopped me on my way out, a box of leftovers in my left hand.
“Hey,” he called from his family’s table, half of a large House Special sitting between them. “What did you get?”
“Italian Combo.”
“How was it?”
Judging from his smile, I only had one answer to give. “It was fantastic.”
OK, new pizza restaurant in town, beat that.
